DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Blade Runner- All 5 cuts in HD! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/519711-blade-runner-all-5-cuts-hd.html)

E Unit 12-13-07 08:12 AM


Originally Posted by MBoyd
I will be popping in the theatrical and then workprint. I have seen the Final Cut recently in the theater so I will be concentrating on extras.

I think you should watch the Final Cut and then theatrical and workprint. I have seen the directors cut a bunch, so I might never even get around to watching that one for a while.

MBoyd, you're in Austin, right? Did you see it at the Paramount? How was the presentation?I'm kicking myself for missing out on it, but at least it's being shown again the first week in January.

Doughboy 12-13-07 08:13 AM


Originally Posted by Jay G.
As for viewing order, if you haven't seen the Final Cut, see that first, then watch the International Theatrical Cut (unless you can't stomach the violence and would prefer the US Theatrical Cut), then the Workprint.

The Final Cut has the same violence as the International Theatrical Cut.

Cosmic Bus 12-13-07 08:17 AM


Originally Posted by DamingR
I've never seen Blade Runner and I'm not huge into sci-fi - how is this as a blind buy?

To offer up a counter-view to the other responses, I'll say that Blade Runner is impressive from a visual/design perspective and clearly influential in that regard, but as a movie, it isn't especially good or terribly interesting.

MBoyd 12-13-07 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by trespoochies
MBoyd, you're in Austin, right? Did you see it at the Paramount? How was the presentation?I'm kicking myself for missing out on it, but at least it's being shown again the first week in January.

I live in the Plano/Richardson area but get down to Austin a lot since my mom lives there. During Thanksgiving week I had grandiose plans about seeing a movie down there everyday including BR and it just didnt work out. I did however see it at the Inwood 2 weeks ago here in Dallas. It looked spectacular. Very crisp. It was on 35mm same as the Paramount I believe. That made it the fourth time I have seen it in the theater.

Definitely go in Jan if you can. Paramount is such a great theater; i love the summer movie series. Unfortunately I missed them all this year.

The Monkees 12-13-07 10:35 AM

I just found the HD-DVD version at a local store. I was tempted to buy but with christmas coming people in my family would be pissed. but it looked really nice!

E Unit 12-13-07 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by MBoyd
Definitely go in Jan if you can. Paramount is such a great theater; i love the summer movie series. Unfortunately I missed them all this year.

I'll definitely be there - family can wait one evening. And the Paramount summer series is the best. I make my religious pilgimmage every summer to see Lawrence of Arabia in 70MM.

Patman 12-13-07 09:41 PM

Is there any interactivity advantages with going with the HD DVD over the BD version?

Jay G. 12-13-07 10:52 PM


Originally Posted by Patman
Is there any interactivity advantages with going with the HD DVD over the BD version?

There's no interactive features on any of the versions, so no.

Patman 12-13-07 10:58 PM

Okay, then. Thanks. I think I'll still go red for the suitcase edition, then, just because the red casing looks better with the Blade Runner coverart and red lettering.

Legolas 12-14-07 05:03 PM

Is there a difference between the 5-disc complete collection and the 5-disc briefcase ultimate collection besides the briefcase?

Supermallet 12-14-07 05:07 PM

The briefcase comes with a few more physical extras, but no extra content on the discs.

jiggawhat 12-14-07 06:38 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
The briefcase comes with a few more physical extras, but no extra content on the discs.

Are you currently reviewing and if so, when is that review going up?

Supermallet 12-14-07 11:59 PM

I just got my copy in today. My goal is to have it up prior to the release date, which is Tuesday. That's a lot of marathon nights. :) I'd be watching it right now if I didn't have this pesky day job (or, in this case, I suppose you'd say it's a night job).

I actually got the non-suitcase 5 disc edition, but we're getting sent the suitcase (just the case, not the discs) separately. Don't ask me why.

El Kabong 12-15-07 01:45 AM

How/why did they change the title of my post? It did ask "only final cut in HD?", now the title says "all 5 cuts in HD". So they can edit your posts/titles as they wish?

Qui Gon Jim 12-15-07 05:37 AM

They changed you title to "answer" the question and to cut down on confusion.

Supermallet 12-15-07 05:56 AM

Correct.

By the way, I'm watching The Final Cut now, and my god is it ever beautiful. WB did a brilliant restoration. I haven't even dug in to this set and I'm already in love.

E Unit 12-15-07 10:33 PM

I just happened to get a copy myself earlier this evening (thanks Hastings for not knowing to hold it until Tuesday) and so far the Final Cut is nothing short of jaw dropping. The opening scene showing the Tyrell building should persude just about anybody just how incredible this cut is. Like Suprmallet, I got the 5 disc release without the briefcase.

Supermallet 12-16-07 05:49 AM

I am such a Blade Runner fan that I have pre-ordered the Blu-ray briefcase edition to complement my HD DVD set. I listened to all the commentaries on the Final Cut and am now watching Dangerous Days.

Jason Bovberg 12-16-07 11:11 AM

YMMV, but I just picked up the 5-disc digipack at my Best Buy this morning.

DVD Polizei 12-16-07 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
I actually got the non-suitcase 5 disc edition, but we're getting sent the suitcase (just the case, not the discs) separately. Don't ask me why.

Probably because the disc manufacturing plant where the 5-disc set is made, is at a different location than the suitcases.

I haven't purchased this yet, but if I go by yours and others observations, I will be pleased. I'll probably get it this week. I'm still debating the suitcase but I'm not as excited about it as I was.

Legolas 12-16-07 01:58 PM

Damnit. I can't decide between whether or not I want to pay $40 more for the briefcase. :(

Patman 12-16-07 04:28 PM

I decided to get the briefcase, but mainly because
Spoiler:
it's being released on my frikkin' birthday, so it was destined that I treat myself to this most uber of Blade Runner deluxe editions.
Plus, I look at such an extravagant purchase as a reward for WB to finally greenlight the Final Cut and go through the process to provide fans with all the other cuts of the film. Now, I can't really offer a reason not to go for the briefcase edition, especially if it means you'll have to eat ramen noodles for few days up to a week. Suck it up for the cause, man. Replicants needs love, too.

Supermallet 12-16-07 05:24 PM

I'm watching the theatrical and director's cut. They're not quite as sharp as the transfer for The Final Cut, and the sound seems more shallow. But they're not awful.

Supermallet 12-16-07 05:52 PM

Now watching the workprint. The sound and picture is much more rough than the other versions, which is to be expected. Ridley Scott warns in the introduction that it's not clean and a work in progress, but is the most different of all the cuts. Really fascinating stuff.

Gizmo 12-16-07 06:43 PM

So for someone that has never seen this movie before...which version should I watch? I won't watch the other cuts) for at least a few weeks...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:13 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.