DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   General Blu-ray News and Discussion - PART 4 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/519678-general-blu-ray-news-discussion-part-4-a.html)

The Cow 12-23-07 04:16 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Regardless, I see extras don't matter in this case, but they do on Harry Potter. :lol:

Nobody said that.

Supermallet 12-23-07 04:32 PM

Fucking Fox. Their asses must be huge to get their heads stuck so far up in them.

bunkaroo 12-23-07 04:45 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
I very much doubt it even warranted a 50GB disc. It would have been just fine on a 25GB disc even with some extras. I still wonder if Fox/Disney are getting the 50GB discs cheaper then 25GB disc at least for the time being.

Regardless, I see extras don't matter in this case, but they do on Harry Potter. :lol:


146 minute runtime with lossless audio is enough to warrant BD50 IMO. No sense crowding it when you don't have to. Even if it only used 30-35 GB, it's still worth it.

tonymontana313 12-23-07 05:45 PM

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/...906b3ecd?imw=Y

Prediction: Blu-ray blows away HD DVD

2008 is the year Sony's Howard Stringer and the Blu-ray Disc will slay HD DVD as effectively as Joseph Turok dispenses with dinosaurs. If you're unfamiliar with that metaphor, you probably don't have a PlayStation 3.

Every PS3 console sold in the U.S. comes equipped with a Blu-ray DVD player. That's an advantage that has put the Sony device in about 2.7 million U.S. homes, compared with fewer than 750,000 for HD DVD. Blu-ray movies also outsell HD DVD movies in Europe by a 3-to-1 margin. This despite HD DVD players costing less than half the price of a PS3/Blu-ray combo unit. True, Paramount, DreamWorks and DreamWorks Animation recently joined Universal in exclusively embracing HD DVD. But those decisions stemmed from a $150 million "incentive payment" that smacked of desperation.

To truly understand Blu-ray's dominance, compare titles that are available in both formats. Warner Bros.' "300" is the best-selling next-gen DVD, and Blu-ray boasts an advantage of 66% to 34% over HD DVD in sales of the title.
Advertisement

The final stake in HD DVD's heart could come from Blockbuster, which is testing both formats. "It's still about 70%-30% in favor of Blu-ray at our stores that offer both," a Blockbuster spokeswoman says.

Dual players are expensive, and a recent Forrester Research study suggests that 22% of Americans say they will not buy a next-gen player until one format wins over the other. Couple that with the 25% who say they'll never buy a next-gen player, and the incentives are in place for Hollywood to finally stop confusing the consumer with one too many choices.

Gizmo 12-23-07 05:49 PM

1.

Joseph Turok dispenses with dinosaurs. If you're unfamiliar with that metaphor, you probably don't have a PlayStation 3.
I imagine they won't know what you're talking about. Turok Evolution was last on the PS2, which is now not playable thanks to the 40GB PS3. Bad comparison right there.

2.

The final stake in HD DVD's heart could come from Blockbuster, which is testing both formats. "It's still about 70%-30% in favor of Blu-ray at our stores that offer both," a Blockbuster spokeswoman says.
This is numbers from several months ago. They may have changed, they may have not. Regardless, when your stocking Blu-ray in 5 times as many stores and carry 4-5times more titles then HD DVD in neutral stores, WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? :lol: Lets not even consider how "well' Blockbuster is dong right now.

3. Take a look at the site. They have several Blu-ray banners everywhere. C'mon.

Here, just taken!
Not one...Not two...but THREE! No HD DVD...anywhere.
http://img518.imageshack.us/img518/4...ylolnx1.th.jpghttp://img518.imageshack.us/img518/1...lol2wc3.th.jpg

Biased much?

tonymontana313 12-23-07 06:07 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
1.

I imagine they won't know what you're talking about. Turok Evolution was last on the PS2, which is now not playable thanks to the 40GB PS3. Bad comparison right there.

2.

This is numbers from several months ago. They may have changed, they may have not. Regardless, when your stocking Blu-ray in 5 times as many stores and carry 4-5times more titles then HD DVD in neutral stores, WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? :lol: Lets not even consider how "well' Blockbuster is dong right now.

3. Take a look at the site. They have several Blu-ray banners everywhere. C'mon.

Here, just taken!
Not one...Not two...but THREE! No HD DVD...anywhere.
http://img518.imageshack.us/img518/4...ylolnx1.th.jpghttp://img518.imageshack.us/img518/1...lol2wc3.th.jpg

Biased much?

Actually there is a new Turok coming out on the PS3 so it is relevant. Also I didn't know that the Hollywood Reporter even cared about the format war therefore I would hardly call them biased.

Supermallet 12-23-07 06:09 PM

That new Turok game is also coming out on the 360, AFAIK.

Gizmo 12-23-07 06:14 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
That new Turok game is also coming out on the 360, AFAIK.

Yes, PS3 and Xbox 360. Its just a horrible thing to put in an article. Like who is going to know that? They were better off putting a GTA quote in there.

Gizmo 12-23-07 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by tonymontana313
Actually there is a new Turok coming out on the PS3 so it is relevant. Also I didn't know that the Hollywood Reporter even cared about the format war therefore I would hardly call them biased.

Again, Ive looked at that article several times on several different computers. It ALWAYS shows 3 Blu-ray advertisements. Notice, no HD DVD ones? Hardly a reputable source.

Gizmo 12-23-07 06:51 PM


Originally Posted by Burnt Thru
hopefully they've maxed out the bitrate on man on fire. it should look amazing!

Case says AVC...there should be plenty of space on that disc left over.

candyrocket786 12-23-07 07:10 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
3. Take a look at the site. They have several Blu-ray banners everywhere. C'mon.

Here, just taken!
Not one...Not two...but THREE! No HD DVD...anywhere.
http://img518.imageshack.us/img518/4...ylolnx1.th.jpghttp://img518.imageshack.us/img518/1...lol2wc3.th.jpg

Biased much?

rotfl

Funny Shit.

I hope the war continues indefinitely.

It just guarantees more HD/BD BOGO offers and cheaper hardware for years to come.

I can live with that.

:D

RichC2 12-23-07 07:44 PM

whoa that article is super up to date mentioning that nail biting competition at Blockbuster in HD vs Blu!!

Qui Gon Jim 12-23-07 08:38 PM

I'm fond of citing the 4:1 hardware lead in the US and a 3:1 software lead in Europe. Let's talk the 3:2 lead here, and then compare that to the 4:1 hardware lead. Oops.

Arpeggi 12-23-07 08:42 PM

I just cancelled my Man on Fire preorder. Will wait for a deal on it.

Gizmo 12-23-07 08:47 PM


Originally Posted by Arpeggi
I just cancelled my Man on Fire preorder. Will wait for a deal on it.

Shouldn't be too long for a BOGO. Mr and Mrs Smith took 3 days for Best Buy to do one. I'm still waiting on Castaway though...sigh.

Arpeggi 12-23-07 08:53 PM

I just bought Ronin from amazon.co.jp. Fuck you Fox for not releasing MGM titles!

Hammer99 12-23-07 09:02 PM

Here's a good one floating around, try to connect the dots (just for fun):

Jeff Bewkes Named CEO of Time-Warner effective January 1, 2008

Time Warner Names Jeffrey L. Bewkes Chief Executive Officer, Succeeding Richard D. Parsons Who Remains Chairman
November 05, 2007

NEW YORK - Time Warner Inc. (NYSE:TWX) today announced that its Board of Directors has elected Jeffrey L. Bewkes as Chief Executive Officer of Time Warner Inc., effective January 1, 2008. Mr. Bewkes currently serves as President and Chief Operating Officer, and he will retain the title of President. Mr. Bewkes will succeed Richard D. Parsons as CEO, and Mr. Parsons will remain as Chairman of the Board.
Business Week 10/2005 article

Despite Time Warner's long alliance with Toshiba, CEO Richard Parsons asked Jeff Bewkes, chairman of the company's entertainment unit, to reconsider the best way to recharge DVD sales. Bewkes decided that the studio should forget appearances and back Blu-ray if it was the format most likely to win consumers' hearts.
Bewkes is the reason Warner went neutral in the first place. :shrug:

Qui Gon Jim 12-23-07 09:23 PM

Interesting, but I think this decision, as well as some of the other BD studios was made on the assumption that the PS3 was a sure-fire hit, and it sure seemed a wise gamble, and one I might add that I would have taken until the details of PS3's launch started to solidify.

PS3 being in third place out of three is hardly what the industry expected.

Gizmo 12-23-07 09:36 PM


Originally Posted by Hammer99
Here's a good one floating around, try to connect the dots (just for fun):

Jeff Bewkes Named CEO of Time-Warner effective January 1, 2008


Business Week 10/2005 article
Bewkes is the reason Warner went neutral in the first place. :shrug:

How many PS3s did Sony say they would sell there first year, 20 million? That obviously did not happen and they are in last place, behind Micrsoft AND Nintendo. Blu-ray has a 4:1 hardware advantage over HD DVD yet can't even pull a 2:1 ratio every week. Its only sometimes, and usually because of BOGOs. Harry Potter would be the decision maker, and so far, its all in HD DVD.

Hammer99 12-23-07 09:46 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
How many PS3s did Sony say they would sell there first year, 20 million? That obviously did not happen and they are in last place, behind Micrsoft AND Nintendo. Blu-ray has a 4:1 hardware advantage over HD DVD yet can't even pull a 2:1 ratio every week. Its only sometimes, and usually because of BOGOs. Harry Potter would be the decision maker, and so far, its all in HD DVD.

I don't think you connected the dots, try again. :D

Gizmo 12-23-07 09:56 PM


Originally Posted by Hammer99
I don't think you connected the dots, try again. :D

I don't get it.

"Bewkes decided that the studio should forget appearances and back Blu-ray if it was the format most likely to win consumers' hearts."

Warners was HD DVD exclusive. Then went Neutral because of Bewkes. I don't see why you are confused. I am confused now at this. Huh?

Damed 12-23-07 10:27 PM

^^ He's insinuating that Bewkes was a Bluray fan, which is why he pushed them to go neutral.

Now that he's CEO, he thinks he'll choose to go Blu exclusive.

I would find that extremely surprising.

QuePaso 12-24-07 02:00 AM

Prepare to be surprised.

Supermallet 12-24-07 02:09 AM

An announcement either way wouldn't surprise me. The only thing that would catch me off guard is if WB said they're bowing out of HDM entirely.

Bcolon 12-24-07 07:23 AM


Originally Posted by QuePaso
Prepare to be surprised.

Now why do you say that? Do you have some kind of inside info? I don't think we will see a change at all. And I really don't think any of the people running around acting like they are in the know have a clue what the decision will be. It is all just getting so annoying. I can't wait till CES is over so we can put all this talk to bed for awhile.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:16 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.