DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Will old TV shows eventually make it to HD? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/516822-will-old-tv-shows-eventually-make-hd.html)

Jay G. 11-12-07 10:40 PM


Originally Posted by ScissorPuppy
Another question, Isn't NSTC 525 lines of resoultion?

No, NTSC has 525 scan line, of which around 480 provide actual picture.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NTSC#Li...d_refresh_rate

NTSC DVD provides exactly 480 lines of actual picture:
http://www.dvddemystified.com/dvdfaq.html#3.4.1

MTRodaba2468 11-12-07 10:52 PM


Originally Posted by CaptainRon
Seinfeld won't be on HD any time soon. Believe me.


Originally Posted by CaptainRon
Ok I'll bite, even if it does it won't be for a really really really long time. However, I will say that i THINK Sopranos will be be in a complete series HD around the same time that the complete series comes out on SD.


Doesn't anyone appreciate the fact that the way a show was filmed originally allows it to keep some of it's character?

I could see Seasons of Seinfeld being released on HD soon, if only because they remastered the show in HD for when they released the standard DVDs.

As far as the Complete Sopranos goes, it wouldn't surprise me if they waited to release the individual seasons first, considering how high the price tag for a Complete Series release on HD-DVD or Blu-Ray would be.

Drexl 11-12-07 10:56 PM


Originally Posted by MTRodaba2468
As far as the Complete Sopranos goes, it wouldn't surprise me if they waited to release the individual seasons first, considering how high the price tag for a Complete Series release on HD-DVD or Blu-Ray would be.

Can you imagine? The MSRP would be at least $500, probably more.

The Bus 11-12-07 11:15 PM

Would be cool to get the complete series in HD and also get one or two discs with the complete series in SD. So for $ridiculous you get the HD and also the ease of having 100 episodes (or whatever) on one disc.

Ocelot 11-13-07 08:10 AM

Yeah, i like the idea of having less discs... it would be cool if the complete series is on few discs instead of like 20-40 :eek:

Well, for one thing, less space and the other is, you don't have to get up and change disc often (well, if you have those 5-disc player thing, i guess it's okay).

Qui Gon Jim 11-13-07 08:13 AM


Originally Posted by ScissorPuppy
I am aware of the original resolution being what it is and unchangable. I was thinking along the lines of what superbit claimed to be. I just figured with alot more space, a better almost "master" transfer could be given to older shows.


here could theoretically be less compression, but we have seen that is is the quality of the compression codec used coupled with the skill of the person managing the compression that results in a good looking transfer.
That was the second part of my answer.

Superbit, in theory, is just a less compressed transfer. But we have seen that that does not always translate into a better image, even in the case of Superbit releases.

Jay G. 11-13-07 11:06 PM


Originally Posted by Ocelot
Yeah, i like the idea of having less discs... Well, for one thing, less space and the other is, you don't have to get up and change disc often.

Most DVD discs hold 2-3 hours of content. Over the course of watching some 20+ hours of content you're going to be getting up anyway, so I don't really see what the big deal is over switching discs.

Ocelot 11-14-07 01:12 PM

you're right and wrong Jay G... it's not about being lazy for some... for me, packing all episodes on few discs means easiness of searching for a particular episode or a particular scene. If you got one those photographic memory brain, then i don't think it's a problem for you. However, i don't remember all of the episode titles and having one season on fewer discs, it really helps...

Jay G. 11-14-07 08:59 PM


Originally Posted by Ocelot
you're right and wrong Jay G... it's not about being lazy for some... for me, packing all episodes on few discs means easiness of searching for a particular episode or a particular scene.

I use the internet for that. It's great, you can use keywords and everything. Are you seriously saying you scan through every episode in a box set to find a particular scene?

CaptainRon 11-15-07 11:37 AM


Originally Posted by Jay G.
He sure as hell wasn't talking about the pops and hisses when he said that.

Ummmm yes he was...

Jay G. 11-15-07 08:25 PM


Originally Posted by CaptainRon
Ummmm yes he was...

First off, All Nic Cage's character in The Rock says is that Beatles LPs "sound better" than the CDs. He doesn't say at all why he thinks they sound better, so there's no way to say definitively whether he was referring to the pops and hisses, or instead to a perceived better audio reproduction in the LPs.

Secondly, find me any [i]non[i/]-fictional character that says that they prefer LPs because of the pops, scratches and hisses.

Finally, as I mentioned in the first post, the pops and hisses are side-effects of the medium, not features. They don't appear in the original masters for the work replicated on vinyl, and in most cases every attempt is made to reduce the introduction and audio reproduction of these audio artifacts. It's just like with film: every attempt is made to keep dirt and scratches off of the film in the first place, and extensive restoration projects are undertaken to remove what scratches and dirt do inevitably end up on the film.

From
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramoph...d#LP_versus_CD

vinyl records were still prized by audiophiles because of better reproduction of analog recordings; however, the drawback was greater sensitivity to scratches and dust....


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:22 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.