DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   RUMOR: Warner Bros. and Wal-Mart offered considerable money to go format exclusive.. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/511745-rumor-warner-bros-wal-mart-offered-considerable-money-go-format-exclusive.html)

tbickle 09-10-07 05:18 PM

RUMOR: Warner Bros. and Wal-Mart offered considerable money to go format exclusive..
 
Check out the story here: http://www.latimes.com/business/la-f...,7403241.story

I pretty much presumed all of this but reading it here suggests that WB and Wal-Mart are strongly considering it....

tonymontana313 09-10-07 05:19 PM

You got your story wrong. Walmart is considering going Blu-ray exclusive.

Supermallet 09-10-07 05:28 PM

Both stories are currently both in the realm of rumor. I just want to make that clear before we start a discussion about it.

tbickle 09-10-07 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by tonymontana313
You got your story wrong. Walmart is considering going Blu-ray exclusive.

damn, as much as I hate to, here's a link to digitalbits commenting on the story:http://www.thedigitalbits.com/#mytwocents, where they quote 'Toshiba has pledged to [Wal-Mart] "a large cooperative promotional budget to support HD DVD sales."'

Admittedly, I couldn't find that quote in the article so make of that what you will.

Gizmo 09-10-07 05:55 PM


Originally Posted by tonymontana313
You got your story wrong. Walmart is considering going Blu-ray exclusive.

Where do you get your info from?

Even the DigitalBits, which should be renamed 'We love Blu-ray', concurs with the OP. Toshiba is in talks to give Wal-Mart a large sum of money, same with WB.

dan30oly 09-10-07 06:35 PM

I would love to chip in with Toshiba to pull Warner HD-DVD exclusive.

tonymontana313 09-10-07 06:51 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Where do you get your info from?

Even the DigitalBits, which should be renamed 'We love Blu-ray', concurs with the OP. Toshiba is in talks to give Wal-Mart a large sum of money, same with WB.

The article the OP linked has all the info you are looking for, my friend.

kvrdave 09-10-07 07:11 PM

It would be nice if all movies were available on both formats so that a format could win on its merits instead of from crap like this. If walmart went exclusive, like it or not, it would be a huge push for that format.

tonymontana313 09-10-07 07:14 PM


Originally Posted by kvrdave
It would be nice if all movies were available on both formats so that a format could win on its merits instead of from crap like this. If walmart went exclusive, like it or not, it would be a huge push for that format.

Only if the price is right.

Mr. Cinema 09-10-07 07:14 PM

If this gets us closer to ONE format, I'm all for it.

DthRdrX 09-10-07 07:17 PM


What's more, Wal-Mart Stores Inc., the dominant seller of DVDs, has been contemplating whether to boot stand-alone HD DVD players from its shelves in favor of Blu-ray. Wal-Mart executives would not talk about the company's conversations with suppliers, but said it would continue to carry hardware and software in both formats until consumers indicate a clear preference.
There are a few conflicting things in this reporting, to say the least ....

ResIpsa 09-10-07 07:30 PM


Originally Posted by tbickle
damn, as much as I hate to, here's a link to digitalbits commenting on the story:http://www.thedigitalbits.com/#mytwocents, where they quote 'Toshiba has pledged to [Wal-Mart] "a large cooperative promotional budget to support HD DVD sales."'

Admittedly, I couldn't find that quote in the article so make of that what you will.

Heh, old Blu-Ray Bill seems pretty worked up over this rumor. It's amusing that he (and a lot of other BD fanboys) continue to rant about money changing hands. Isn't that how business works? How else did Sony manage to line up so much studio support at the beginning and how else did they "convince" Target and others to promote BD? Please... :rolleyes:

mzupeman2 09-10-07 07:36 PM

I can find my HD-DVD's and I can get Warner titles on HD. So I really don't care how it goes, either way. It still just baffles me how BR backers that have large voices on the net can actually still nit-pick this tactic when Sony has been doing it for a long time already.

DthRdrX 09-10-07 07:36 PM


Originally Posted by ResIpsa
Heh, old Blu-Ray Bill seems pretty worked up over this rumor. It's amusing that he (and a lot of other BD fanboys) continue to rant about money changing hands. Isn't that how business works? How else did Sony manage to line up so much studio support at the beginning and how else did they "convince" Target and others to promote BD? Please... :rolleyes:

Actually, I found it kinda funny!

A rant about Toshiba paying off WB and then a knock at the "big studio" CEO, a final rant about everything being about money.

Then ... the very next entry is...

Warner's sent over another announcement this morning.
All about money indeed! ;)

Bill Geiger 09-10-07 08:03 PM

Out of the whole article, I think this is 100% wrong.


"This is an eye chart test," said James Burger, a lawyer who represents technology companies in Washington. "You don't even begin to see the difference unless the screen is larger than 42 inches."
I have a 32 inch and I could CLEARLY see a difference.

Giles 09-10-07 08:03 PM

being the evil corporation they are, money can buy anything from Walmart.

Qui Gon Jim 09-10-07 08:16 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
being the evil corporation they are, money can buy anything from Walmart.

Bookmark this quote so we can reminisce about it if WalMart becomes BD exclusive.

ALL corporations are evil.

Gizmo 09-10-07 08:20 PM


You got your story wrong. Walmart is considering going Blu-ray exclusive.

Originally Posted by tonymontana313
The article the OP linked has all the info you are looking for, my friend.


Ok, so the very article has this



What's more, Wal-Mart Stores Inc., the dominant seller of DVDs, has been contemplating whether to boot stand-alone HD DVD players from its shelves in favor of Blu-ray. Wal-Mart executives would not talk about the company's conversations with suppliers, but said it would continue to carry hardware and software in both formats until consumers indicate a clear preference.
So how was I wrong?

tofferman 09-10-07 08:25 PM


Originally Posted by tonymontana313
Only if the price is right.

We are talking Walmart here...right? By default, does that not imply Walmart would set a price point that appeals to J6P for both HD-DVD titles and presumably HD-DVD?


Originally Posted by mzupeman2
It still just baffles me how BR backers that have large voices on the net can actually still nit-pick this tactic when Sony has been doing it for a long time already.

100% correct...the hipocracy is amazing with the blu ray fanboys...

Jake77444 09-10-07 08:34 PM


Originally Posted by ResIpsa
Heh, old Blu-Ray Bill seems pretty worked up over this rumor. It's amusing that he (and a lot of other BD fanboys) continue to rant about money changing hands. Isn't that how business works? How else did Sony manage to line up so much studio support at the beginning and how else did they "convince" Target and others to promote BD? Please... :rolleyes:

Obvious HD-DVD Fanboy. Enough said.

DthRdrX 09-10-07 08:37 PM


Originally Posted by Jake77444
Obvious HD-DVD Fanboy. Enough said.

How dare ye speak the truth!

Giles 09-10-07 08:41 PM


Originally Posted by Qui Gon Jim
Bookmark this quote so we can reminisce about it if WalMart becomes BD exclusive.

ALL corporations are evil.

but Walmart sets the bars so low in their sheer evilness, it has drawn an entire nation to be cheap bastards and not to give a toss at what cost and outcome on local, national and international economics.

(steps off soapbox)

RichC2 09-10-07 08:56 PM


Originally Posted by Jake77444
Obvious HD-DVD Fanboy. Enough said.

Blasphemy! Oh wait no, you're spot on.

I'm a huge supporter of HD-DVD over Blu-ray, I don't get the game console-style fanboyisms though.

tonymontana313 09-10-07 08:57 PM

My thing is, why aren't either camps going for Best Buy? Best Buy would be the real coup over Walmart. I would never buy any electronics from Walmart to begin with and i'm sure most of you share my sentiment as well. Getting Best Buy would be huge considering how well they are pushing high def.

Gizmo 09-10-07 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by tonymontana313
My thing is, why aren't either camps going for Best Buy? Best Buy would be the real coup over Walmart. I would never buy any electronics from Walmart to begin with and i'm sure most of you share my sentiment as well. Getting Best Buy would be huge considering how well they are pushing high def.

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...8&postcount=18

?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:00 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.