So 300....get it on BR or HD-DVD?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
So 300....get it on BR or HD-DVD?
I tend to buy HD-DVD when given the choice, but am not sure if there is extra stuff on one or the other that would sway me. Anyone know, and are the reviews of the PQ comparable?
#2
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
Crap, just looked on Amazon and it looks like the HD-DVD is a combo disc, and thus costs $4 extra for something I don't care about. Is there some super special HD-DVD feature that would make one want to spend the extra $4?
#3
DVD Talk Special Edition
The HD DVD version has few extras that are not available on the Blu-ray disc. From hidefdigest.com:
Now whether that is worth an extra $4...
Easily the most anticipated bonus is the "Bluescreen Picture-in-Picture Version" of the film. A true first for any home video format, Warner has encoded the entire feature in its bluescreen, pre-post-produced version. Like your typical In-Movie Experience track, just activate the feature and a large picture box will appear in the bottom left of the screen, allowing you to watch the before-and-after versions of the film along with audio commentary by director Zack Snyder.
The first few minutes of this one in particular are way cool -- it's really a kick to both see and hear, shot-by-shot, how each effect was done. Everything about the film looks so different -- not just the bluescreen elements that were eventually added in later, but also the entire tone, mood and appearance of the live-action footage. I suspect this will be an instant classic at film schools everywhere.
Having said that, and as truly trend-setting as this feature is, a certain sameness does start to creep in after a while. Sure, CGI geeks will swoon, but 30 minutes on in or so, you get the basic idea of the process Snyder used in creating his visual wizardry, and some may find it overkill to sit through this one in its entirety. Still, this is certainly the kind of pioneering bonus feature that has propelled Warner to the forefront of studios supporting high-def, so far be it from me to complain. Please keep this stuff coming!
The bluscreen feature alone would have earned '300' its place in next-gen history, but Warner has also included some groundbreaking web-enabled extras, too.
The most intriguing among the web-enabled extras is a feature called "Pick Your Favorite Scenes." Here, you can assemble and re-organize your favorite bits of '300,' and then store the line-up to your player's internal accessible memory and/or put it online to share with others. Warner will even let you review and rate other fan-made cuts. While I'm not sure how many of "'300's Greatest Hits" I'd want to watch, the technology here is undeniably exciting.
There is also a fresh interactive game, "Vengeance and Valor." Think Risk meets Checkers, only using iconography from the movie. Gameplay is pretty basic: you can select a few components (such as the type of infantrymen you want to fight your opponent with, and your plan of attack), but it's not all that involving. Plus, without a worthy online opponent you're kinda out of luck. Still, I suspect Warner is just testing the waters with this one -- depending on the reaction from early adopters, here's betting that future applications will be more sophisticated and complex.
Finally, in a nod to unabashed capitalism, '300' is also the first next-gen title ever to provide viewers with one-click access to buy film-specific merchandise. Thanks to the miracle of HD DVD, you can now "take '300' with you wherever you go!" by using the disc's web interface to purchase custom wallpaper and ringtones for your mobile phone. Of course, you could do this on any old PC, too, so aside from the novelty factor this is hardly much of a "feature." Still, I can't wait until my HD DVD player starts to try selling me Harry Potter plush toys...
The first few minutes of this one in particular are way cool -- it's really a kick to both see and hear, shot-by-shot, how each effect was done. Everything about the film looks so different -- not just the bluescreen elements that were eventually added in later, but also the entire tone, mood and appearance of the live-action footage. I suspect this will be an instant classic at film schools everywhere.
Having said that, and as truly trend-setting as this feature is, a certain sameness does start to creep in after a while. Sure, CGI geeks will swoon, but 30 minutes on in or so, you get the basic idea of the process Snyder used in creating his visual wizardry, and some may find it overkill to sit through this one in its entirety. Still, this is certainly the kind of pioneering bonus feature that has propelled Warner to the forefront of studios supporting high-def, so far be it from me to complain. Please keep this stuff coming!
The bluscreen feature alone would have earned '300' its place in next-gen history, but Warner has also included some groundbreaking web-enabled extras, too.
The most intriguing among the web-enabled extras is a feature called "Pick Your Favorite Scenes." Here, you can assemble and re-organize your favorite bits of '300,' and then store the line-up to your player's internal accessible memory and/or put it online to share with others. Warner will even let you review and rate other fan-made cuts. While I'm not sure how many of "'300's Greatest Hits" I'd want to watch, the technology here is undeniably exciting.
There is also a fresh interactive game, "Vengeance and Valor." Think Risk meets Checkers, only using iconography from the movie. Gameplay is pretty basic: you can select a few components (such as the type of infantrymen you want to fight your opponent with, and your plan of attack), but it's not all that involving. Plus, without a worthy online opponent you're kinda out of luck. Still, I suspect Warner is just testing the waters with this one -- depending on the reaction from early adopters, here's betting that future applications will be more sophisticated and complex.
Finally, in a nod to unabashed capitalism, '300' is also the first next-gen title ever to provide viewers with one-click access to buy film-specific merchandise. Thanks to the miracle of HD DVD, you can now "take '300' with you wherever you go!" by using the disc's web interface to purchase custom wallpaper and ringtones for your mobile phone. Of course, you could do this on any old PC, too, so aside from the novelty factor this is hardly much of a "feature." Still, I can't wait until my HD DVD player starts to try selling me Harry Potter plush toys...
#8
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Guelph, Ontario
I'm really torn... I really want to check out the blue screen PIP feature on the HD DVD, but I really do get better sound out of my PS3...I initially thought hands down I'd go with HD, but now I'm thinking maybe I'll just go with the blu-ray to enjoy the actual movie with the best options, rather than having some really cool features.... tough choice!
#13
Senior Member
I'm still kind of pissed that they still haven't figured out how to do the in movie experience thing on blu-ray, but while the blue-screen feature might be cool to see once it's probably not something I'd ever look at again. I'll probably get the blu-ray.
#15
Member
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 244
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Studio City
Definitely HD-DVD for me...The added IME content is cool and this would be one pic where having a DVD version would come in handy for my office and portable player for trips...
#17
I'd happily cough up the extra 4 bucks, which saves me the $20 of having to buy the SD DVD SE for use with every other TV in my house not to mention my laptop, portable player, and any non-hd friend's house I happen to be at. Whereas some IME features are disposable imo, I'm REALLY looking forward to this one.
However, I pre-ordered the HD DVD from Fry's when it was only $21 shipped, so the $4 is moot in my case.
However, I pre-ordered the HD DVD from Fry's when it was only $21 shipped, so the $4 is moot in my case.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
If you order from Warner Brothers using their coupon, the difference in price is only $2.40. So the cost difference is pretty minimal, even if you don't really love the extras.
#21
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Originally Posted by dvd182
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
FYI, if you want to buy in-store, Target will have the BD on sale for $24.99.
This is the route I'm going.
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
FYI, if you want to buy in-store, Target will have the BD on sale for $24.99.
This is the route I'm going.Edit to Add: We're pretty sure that this is untrue, but shelf tags in BBs are advertising "BB exclusive content" on their copies of 300 HD, seeming to indicate more than just what is "exclusive (from BluRay)" on all of the HDs everywhere.
Last edited by Trevor; 07-30-07 at 11:14 AM.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
BD for me. I rarely look at special features and hate having double sided discs. I probably would have gone HD if it weren't a combo disc.
#23
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 2,109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The city with no sports championships...Cleveland
I can't believe there are people that have both formats and have to make this decision! You guys must be millionaires!! I'm sure whichever one you buy is gonna blow you away.
#24
DVD Talk Limited Edition
HD-DVD. I really enjoy the IME's on the discs I have and gladly pay the extra $3.59 (after the 10% off discount) for the one on this disc. Heck, even if you're only going to watch the IME once, it's worth it (IMO).
#25
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 568
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
in the best buy ad when you buy the Sd 2 disc version you get a limited trophy helmet statue thing, think you could slide by and get this with the HD DVD release or is it only with the SD release. By the way, im going HD DVD for 300 and hot fuzz as well.



