Welcome to round 2 of the 2007 DVDTalk HD DVD/Blu Ray draft voting. Please vote for which collection you think is the best for each matchup. Matchups were reseeded based on how many HD discs the participants have. Use whatever criteria you feel is the most appropriate; I loook for whichever HD disc I feel is the most "must-have." Your vote will not be counted if you don't vote in all 4 matchups or if you vote more than once. This round of voting will last 72 hours.

Matchup 1
speedyray
Casino Royale Blu Ray
Goodfellas HD DVD
The Departed HD DVD
The Fast & the Furious: Tokyo Drift HD DVD
Jarhead HD DVD
Miami Vice HD DVD
The Rundown HD DVD
Superman Returns HD DVD

versus

cleaver
Batman Begins HD DVD
King Kong HD DVD
V for Vendetta HD DVD
Black Hawk Down Blu Ray
Corpse Bride Blu Ray
Crank Blu Ray
The Thing HD DVD
A Scanner Darkly HD DVD

Matchup 2
arpeggi
Children of Men HD DVD
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind HD DVD
The Departed Blu Ray
Out of Sight HD DVD
Reservoir Dogs Blu Ray
12 Monkeys HD DVD
The Usual Suspects Blu Ray
Goodfellas Blu Ray

versus

sayguh
Troy HD DVD
Terminator 2 Blu Ray
Rocky Balboa Blu Ray
Layer Cake Blu Ray
Mission: Impossible III Blu Ray
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown Blu Ray
Training Day HD DVD
Enter the Dragon HD DVD

speedyray - Much more varied list, only 1 actively bad movie
Arpeggi - This one really isn't close at all.

cleaver and Arpeggi.

speedyray (duh, its me - I do really like cleaver's list though)

Arpeggi (has more "must have" movies - sayguh's list is real good, but I see most of those as between very good and decent choices with none being absolute musts - T2 would if it had been a little better disc - more extras, lossless sound, etc)

speedyray
Arpeggi

speedyray
Arpeggi

speedyray
sayguh

speedyray
arpeggi

MATT

Matchup 1
speedyray because
Casino Royale Blu Ray
The Departed HD DVD
Jarhead HD DVD
Miami Vice HD DVD

Matchup 2
arpeggi because
Children of Men HD DVD
The Departed Blu Ray
Out of Sight HD DVD
Reservoir Dogs Blu Ray

I missed the first round of voting as I was away... and I am going to vote in this round... I just need some time to think

hmm very tough choice ... I'll go with Cleaver in the first match.... Speedy ray started very strong but I think it weakened out after the first 3. I rented Tokyo Drift over the weekend though, I did like it..

But still.. Cleaver

And Arpeggi has a solid collection too... I put him next in line after me.

sayguh in matchup #2! ftw!

cleaver
arpeggi