HD DVD vs. Blu-Ray Disc vs. Everything Else: Round 5
#151
PS3 Japan Shipments cut(again)
October 30, 2006 - What's worse than 100,000 units at launch? How about 80,000? The Nikkei Keizai Shimbun morning edition reports today that due to component shortages, Sony will have only 80,000 units ready for the PS3's 11/11 Japanese launch. This cuts back by a fifth the initial launch target of 100,000.
The lack of digits in that number is even more staggering when you consider that the PS2 sold out of nearly a million units when it launched back in March of 2000.
Having lived through a few weeks of attempting to obtain a PS3 pre-order, we're not too surprised by the lowered shipping numbers. Allocations disappeared quickly at online retailers that were brave enough to start pre-order programs. The online arm of media retailer Tsutaya ran out of units in 6 minutes according to Nikkei (it felt more like 1 minute to us).
Major electronics chains like Yodobashi Camera won't be taking pre-orders, Nikkei reports, so there's only one option left: line up the day before launch. Although with fewer units to go around, we're considering getting in line starting from the week prior.
October 30, 2006 - What's worse than 100,000 units at launch? How about 80,000? The Nikkei Keizai Shimbun morning edition reports today that due to component shortages, Sony will have only 80,000 units ready for the PS3's 11/11 Japanese launch. This cuts back by a fifth the initial launch target of 100,000.
The lack of digits in that number is even more staggering when you consider that the PS2 sold out of nearly a million units when it launched back in March of 2000.
Having lived through a few weeks of attempting to obtain a PS3 pre-order, we're not too surprised by the lowered shipping numbers. Allocations disappeared quickly at online retailers that were brave enough to start pre-order programs. The online arm of media retailer Tsutaya ran out of units in 6 minutes according to Nikkei (it felt more like 1 minute to us).
Major electronics chains like Yodobashi Camera won't be taking pre-orders, Nikkei reports, so there's only one option left: line up the day before launch. Although with fewer units to go around, we're considering getting in line starting from the week prior.
#153
Banned
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 6,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Blu-Ray: We Don't Need No Stinkin' Petition
Originally Posted by RockStrongo
You seem to be the only one who thinks hd-dvd is not high quality.
12 Monkeys
- High Def Digest: 3/5 "it is probably the most inconsistent and just plain wonky presentation I've yet seen on the format"
- Home Theater Spot: 2.5/5 "When taking the whole video presentation as a whole, this is a below average effort on HD DVD."
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
#154
Originally Posted by joshd2012
Its not that I don't think HD DVD can and has presented high quality, its that I don't live in some dream world where I think they have been perfect. Just look at how 12 Monkeys got reviews, which was released last week:
12 Monkeys
- High Def Digest: 3/5 "it is probably the most inconsistent and just plain wonky presentation I've yet seen on the format"
- Home Theater Spot: 2.5/5 "When taking the whole video presentation as a whole, this is a below average effort on HD DVD."
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
12 Monkeys
- High Def Digest: 3/5 "it is probably the most inconsistent and just plain wonky presentation I've yet seen on the format"
- Home Theater Spot: 2.5/5 "When taking the whole video presentation as a whole, this is a below average effort on HD DVD."
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
#155
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,099
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Coral
I'd say those whose personal preference is lossless/uncompressed audio are in the small minority.
#156
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,662
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: H-Town, TX
Originally Posted by DthRdrX
The T3 disc is far from a dud. I havn't watched the other two yet so I won't comment.
#157
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 7,937
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Doughboy
No kidding. If T3 is considered a bad-looking title, I hope every HD-DVD release sucks as much.
#158
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 4,582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dallas, TX
Originally Posted by joshd2012
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
I didnt say that every hd-dvd title has been good, but as far as reviews are concerned, BD has had more lackluster titles (as far as I remember from reading the reviews as they came out).
Granted, BD had terrible reviews at the beginning and they seem to have at least matched hd-dvd in some of their current releases (again, mainly because they started using VC-1).
#159
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 4,582
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dallas, TX
Originally Posted by bravesmg
Another vote for T3 kicking ass on HD-DVD. I've got 12 Monkeys ordered too, I'll be surprised if it isn't as impressive.
#164
Originally Posted by joshd2012
Is the film actually split in half? Or is one disc the feature and one disc the extras?
#165
Banned
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 6,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Blu-Ray: We Don't Need No Stinkin' Petition
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Thread says the first 96 minutes are on disc 1 and the rest on disc 2. WTF? I thought the purpose of higher disc storage was to avoid crap like this.
I hope the Blu-ray version is a single disc release.
#166
Originally Posted by joshd2012
So 96 minutes on the first disc, and 98 on the second? Are they using two 15GB discs?
I hope the Blu-ray version is a single disc release.
I hope the Blu-ray version is a single disc release.
Disc 1 is 96 mins
Disc 2 is 99 mins
#167
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by DthRdrX
Well the BR version is not announced as a BD50 so who knows. Someone threw out the idea that maybe they split it up because they couldn't fit the whole thing on a BD25. Maybe they just decided to make both releases the same?
#168
Banned
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 15,957
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
Originally Posted by Drexl
That's just what I was thinking: they used up to 25GB of space for each of two HD-DVDs so they could use the same encoding on two 25GB BD discs.
#169
DVD Talk Legend
It's not like they couldn't have fit the movie on 1 disc. Grand Prix is 3 hours long and has over an hour of video supplements yet all fit on one disc.
I suspect that Paramount ran out of space on the Blu-ray (where they're using MPEG2) and decided to split the movie on both formats more as a marketing decision than a technical one. It might be hard for them to explain to the average consumer why the HD DVD is only 1 disc while the Blu-ray is a "2 Disc Special Edition".
I suspect that Paramount ran out of space on the Blu-ray (where they're using MPEG2) and decided to split the movie on both formats more as a marketing decision than a technical one. It might be hard for them to explain to the average consumer why the HD DVD is only 1 disc while the Blu-ray is a "2 Disc Special Edition".
#170
DVD Talk Legend
Reds was one of the last films to have an intermission. Maybe they split it over two discs to meet Warren Beatty's desire to keep and enforce the intermission. The DVD version is split over two discs as well.
If space had been an issue, they could still have fit the whole movie on one disc on HD DVD, while moving the extras to a second disc, to keep the HD DVD a two-disc set. So I don't think that's the issue.
Originally Posted by Josh Z
It might be hard for them to explain to the average consumer why the HD DVD is only 1 disc while the Blu-ray is a "2 Disc Special Edition".
Last edited by Jay G.; 10-30-06 at 04:45 PM.
#171
Banned
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 6,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Blu-Ray: We Don't Need No Stinkin' Petition
Originally Posted by Jay G.
Reds was one of the last films to have an intermission. Maybe they split it over two discs to meet Warren Beatty's desire to keep and enforce the intermission. The DVD version is split over two discs as well.
#172
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 516
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Detroit
Originally Posted by DthRdrX
PS3 Japan Shipments cut(again)
October 30, 2006 - What's worse than 100,000 units at launch? How about 80,000? The Nikkei Keizai Shimbun morning edition reports today that due to component shortages, Sony will have only 80,000 units ready for the PS3's 11/11 Japanese launch. This cuts back by a fifth the initial launch target of 100,000.
The lack of digits in that number is even more staggering when you consider that the PS2 sold out of nearly a million units when it launched back in March of 2000.
Having lived through a few weeks of attempting to obtain a PS3 pre-order, we're not too surprised by the lowered shipping numbers. Allocations disappeared quickly at online retailers that were brave enough to start pre-order programs. The online arm of media retailer Tsutaya ran out of units in 6 minutes according to Nikkei (it felt more like 1 minute to us).
Major electronics chains like Yodobashi Camera won't be taking pre-orders, Nikkei reports, so there's only one option left: line up the day before launch. Although with fewer units to go around, we're considering getting in line starting from the week prior.
October 30, 2006 - What's worse than 100,000 units at launch? How about 80,000? The Nikkei Keizai Shimbun morning edition reports today that due to component shortages, Sony will have only 80,000 units ready for the PS3's 11/11 Japanese launch. This cuts back by a fifth the initial launch target of 100,000.
The lack of digits in that number is even more staggering when you consider that the PS2 sold out of nearly a million units when it launched back in March of 2000.
Having lived through a few weeks of attempting to obtain a PS3 pre-order, we're not too surprised by the lowered shipping numbers. Allocations disappeared quickly at online retailers that were brave enough to start pre-order programs. The online arm of media retailer Tsutaya ran out of units in 6 minutes according to Nikkei (it felt more like 1 minute to us).
Major electronics chains like Yodobashi Camera won't be taking pre-orders, Nikkei reports, so there's only one option left: line up the day before launch. Although with fewer units to go around, we're considering getting in line starting from the week prior.
PS..
#173
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 516
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Detroit
Originally Posted by joshd2012
Its not that I don't think HD DVD can and has presented high quality, its that I don't live in some dream world where I think they have been perfect. Just look at how 12 Monkeys got reviews, which was released last week:
12 Monkeys
- High Def Digest: 3/5 "it is probably the most inconsistent and just plain wonky presentation I've yet seen on the format"
- Home Theater Spot: 2.5/5 "When taking the whole video presentation as a whole, this is a below average effort on HD DVD."
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
12 Monkeys
- High Def Digest: 3/5 "it is probably the most inconsistent and just plain wonky presentation I've yet seen on the format"
- Home Theater Spot: 2.5/5 "When taking the whole video presentation as a whole, this is a below average effort on HD DVD."
People over at AVS have been even harsher than the reviewers. Spartacus took a beating, and so did Terminator 3 when it was released. Like I said, duds on both sides.
As I have stated in the past the only person in the history of Hollywood that was able to use Super-35 and get an end product that rivaled regular anamorphic is James Cameron and it was because of his rigorous testing and the fact that he made the processing lab who made the intermediate prints do testing that was equally laborious.
Bottom line is Terminator 3 looked great and every single review that faulted T3's transfer completely ignored the process used to make T3 and it was evident in their review. Every single thing they faulted T3 for was in fact completely normal for a film made with the Super-35 process. In the end what they were in fact ripping on was their own ignorance for not having enough education in film to even know the different film processes and what those difference equate to in a HD transfer.
As for the other 2 titles you have brought up, I have yet to see them but even if they are bad that is 2 titles out of what, like 90? Ill take those odds any day of the week and twice on sunday.
Josh, everyone on this board knows that you absolutely despise HD-DVD and you do everything in your power to make it look bad. Funny thing is we dont have to go out of our way and put effort into making BD look bad. They have done that all by themselves. Bottom line is HD-DVD is a much better value and has beaten the so called superior Blu-Ray in quality since day 1. Yes, BD has gotten better and will most likely continue to do so but HD-DVD doesn't have to get better. They have been at the top since day 1. You will never admit that and I dont think anyone on this board expects you to. That would be like Sony admitting they have had their butt handed to them by HD-DVD and that just isn't going to happen.
PS..
#174
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: In the Universe.
It might be hard for them to explain to the average consumer why the HD DVD is only 1 disc while the Blu-ray is a "2 Disc Special Edition".
Last edited by jiggawhat; 10-30-06 at 09:35 PM.
#175
Banned
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 6,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Blu-Ray: We Don't Need No Stinkin' Petition
Originally Posted by PornoStar
Josh, everyone on this board knows that you absolutely despise HD-DVD and you do everything in your power to make it look bad.



