Is HD-DVD worth it for a 27" HDTV?
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Is HD-DVD worth it for a 27" HDTV?
I have decided to buy a HDTV next year with my tax refund money. I only plan to get a 24"-27" HDTV because of space limitations (ie my apartment is very small). Would it even be worthwhile for me to get a HD-DVD player? What I mean is, will the increased resolution be noticeable on such a small screen or will it just "appear" the same as a regular 480p DVD? Also, for a HDTV of that size, is my only option an LCD? I haven't seen any other types (plasma, DLP, etc) that size.
#2
DVD Talk God
I watch on 122" at 13' and can obviously see a huge difference. The smaller the screen, the closer you have to be to the screen to get any benefit from HD programming.
If you look at a site like this http://www.myhometheater.homestead.c...alculator.html you will see that for a 27" HDTV, the MAXIMUM viewing distance to gain any benefit is 3.5' away, and that is for a 16:9 screen. A regular 4:3 screen would be a maximum of 3.2" away.
I would probably wait, if I were you. And I think LCD would be the only real way to go for that size.
If you look at a site like this http://www.myhometheater.homestead.c...alculator.html you will see that for a 27" HDTV, the MAXIMUM viewing distance to gain any benefit is 3.5' away, and that is for a 16:9 screen. A regular 4:3 screen would be a maximum of 3.2" away.
I would probably wait, if I were you. And I think LCD would be the only real way to go for that size.
#3
DVD Talk Godfather
I have a 26" LCD in my bedroom and if I am close (2' to 3') I can see a difference. If you're going to be any further away, don't waste your money on such a small LCD.
The good news is that in spring of next year, LCDs will be cheaper. My 26" Aquos was $1100 last year, now it's under $900. The 36" model was almost $2000, now it's under $1500. If I were you, I'd save an extra $20 per month now and wait until summer of next year, then get a 32". My 26" is way too small for my tastes.
The good news is that in spring of next year, LCDs will be cheaper. My 26" Aquos was $1100 last year, now it's under $900. The 36" model was almost $2000, now it's under $1500. If I were you, I'd save an extra $20 per month now and wait until summer of next year, then get a 32". My 26" is way too small for my tastes.
#4
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: H-Town, TX
Posts: 3,662
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have a 32" Samsung LCD TV and I can definitely notice a difference between HD-DVD and DVD. I would prefer a larger screen, but that's all I can fit in my room.
#5
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,874
Received 1,897 Likes
on
1,246 Posts
Moronic posts removed.
#8
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thanks for the link, kvrdave. I was just the discussing the viewing distance issue with my neighbors during an HD demo last night. They are about to take the HDTV plunge and were wondering what screen size to get for their viewing distance.
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by The Bus
lizard: Tell them to remember what every owner says when they take theirs home...
"Man, I could've gone bigger."
"Man, I could've gone bigger."
The viewing angle stuff will be of particular interest to them because one of them mentioned the difference in tracking the picture on my widescreen versus the static way they watched their 4:3 (from a great distance).
So far as kgrogers1979's original question, I agree with others above that 24 to 27 inches is too small to derive enough benefit from HD DVD, unless one plans to upgrade to a bigger screen in the near future (which does not seem to be the case given space limitations). It just wouldn't have enough impact to justify the extra expense of the HD DVD player (and discs).
Last edited by lizard; 09-05-06 at 10:26 AM.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Indianapolis, IN
Posts: 1,465
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by namja
What about a 30" TV?
I may be able to get my hands on a 30" CRT HDTV for under $150 (industry perks). Wondering what I can do with it ...
I may be able to get my hands on a 30" CRT HDTV for under $150 (industry perks). Wondering what I can do with it ...
Yesterday, I bought an RCA player for my 30" Toshiba CRT. I can really notice a difference. Much sharper and "deeper" picture.
#14
DVD Talk God
Originally Posted by namja
What about a 30" TV?
I may be able to get my hands on a 30" CRT HDTV for under $150 (industry perks). Wondering what I can do with it ...
I may be able to get my hands on a 30" CRT HDTV for under $150 (industry perks). Wondering what I can do with it ...
Interestingly, for standard def, I can go back over 40 feet.