HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray vs. everything else free-for-all: Round two
#777
DVD Talk God
Thanks for the help. I getting ready to draft FF, so I will try it all later.
I will say, though, as much as I love it (and loved college football in HD yesterday), I do think this is a niche market that will be bigger than LD, but will not overtake dvd...at least in the next 3 years or more.
I will say, though, as much as I love it (and loved college football in HD yesterday), I do think this is a niche market that will be bigger than LD, but will not overtake dvd...at least in the next 3 years or more.
#778
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 1999
Posts: 1,423
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Indianapolis, IN
I agree. The difference in picture quality isn't that great, especially to the normal person. I can't see upgrading more than 100 of my current DVDs to be honest.
#779
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by kvrdave
...I will say, though, as much as I love it (and loved college football in HD yesterday), I do think this is a niche market that will be bigger than LD, but will not overtake dvd...at least in the next 3 years or more.
#780
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by DamingR
I agree. The difference in picture quality isn't that great, especially to the normal person. I can't see upgrading more than 100 of my current DVDs to be honest.
#781
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 1999
Posts: 1,423
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Indianapolis, IN
Originally Posted by The Bus
I'm with you there. There's a very limited number of my DVDs which I will upgrade. However, most new day&date releases I will probably get on HD.
Exactly.
#782
If HDtv sales keep increasing like they are, then why wouldn't HD disc media make a big splash? So in 3 years when many more people have high-definition tvs, they're still going to settle for standard definition discs?
#783
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
If HDtv sales keep increasing like they are, then why wouldn't HD disc media make a big splash? So in 3 years when many more people have high-definition tvs, they're still going to settle for standard definition discs?
• Despite increasing sales of HDTVs a lot of people will still have SD TVs for some time to come.
• 100 million or so SD DVD players aren't going to disappear quickly in favor of the new HD players.
• Cost (1). The players will remain fairly expensive for another year or two. Anyone who expects them to be $50 to $100 by the end of next year is going to be disappointed, I think. The HD machines have a lot of processing power and expensive components in them and it should take some time for them to approach the $100 level.
• Cost (2). The discs will be somewhat more expensive than SD DVDs for some time to come.
• Upscaled DVDs on an HDTV look almost as good as HD discs, especially when compared to viewing them at NTSC resolutions on a SD TV. Some displays do an excellent job of upscaling DVDs (mine does), so even an upscaling player won't be necessary. For many people SD DVD will be "good enough" for awhile.
• The infamous format war. Need I say more?
I just don't see these formats taking off for awhile. I'd sure like to be wrong about that, however... Feel free to gloat in three years if HD disc sales approach SD DVD sales!
#784
DVD Talk Legend
Another factor relating to the typical content of HD discs: while people can easily notice the clarity of HD video such as sports and things on channels like Discovery HD, people aren't as likely to appreciate the difference with film transfers. People can be annoyed that film with its natural grain does not appear as clean as HD video.
#785
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 2,020
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: CANADA
Wow. Apparently even the EXPENSIVE PS3 won't ship with an HDMI cable, or ANY HD cable whatsoever.
http://www.stageselect.com/News/News...2285&fromint=1
http://www.stageselect.com/News/News...2285&fromint=1
#786
DVD Talk Legend
I think I ran into Blitz at my local Best Buy tonight. There I am, with 2 HD DVDs in my hand, scanning the rest of their selection, and this punk I've never seen before in my life (not an employee) just starts talking to me. He tried to explain how there's no sense buying those HD discs, because as soon as Blu-ray launches (and keep in mind that there's a bunch of Blu-ray discs for sale on the shelf directly behind him) that they were going to stop making those HD discs because nobody would need to buy them anymore. I said, "Yeah, that's nice" and walked away.
#787
DVD Talk Godfather
Didn't you heart? As soon as the PS3 launches, the Blu Goblins will eat our discs and make our purchase worthless! The "real launch" refers to Goblin-filled techno-missiles launched at all HD-DVD players who have no chance to defend themselves against something that is Beyond High Definition™®!
#788
Banned
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 673
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Josh Z
I think I ran into Blitz at my local Best Buy tonight. There I am, with 2 HD DVDs in my hand, scanning the rest of their selection, and this punk I've never seen before in my life (not an employee) just starts talking to me. He tried to explain how there's no sense buying those HD discs, because as soon as Blu-ray launches (and keep in mind that there's a bunch of Blu-ray discs for sale on the shelf directly behind him) that they were going to stop making those HD discs because nobody would need to buy them anymore. I said, "Yeah, that's nice" and walked away.
ha-ha!
#789
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Blitz6Speed
You'd know if you met me, you'd walk away with a feeling of amazement from my charm, not walk away with combo discs.
#790
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Mpls, MN
Originally Posted by Drexl
Another factor relating to the typical content of HD discs: while people can easily notice the clarity of HD video such as sports and things on channels like Discovery HD, people aren't as likely to appreciate the difference with film transfers. People can be annoyed that film with its natural grain does not appear as clean as HD video.
#791
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Mpls, MN
Do I see many people starting to say that the video upgrade isn't necessarily the hottest thing? And many people saying the audio is really great?
Weird, that sounds....familiar somehow.
Weird, that sounds....familiar somehow.
#794
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Spiky
Um, not sure you have this understood correctly. Don't confuse grain with resolution. Perhaps you mean films from poorly kept masters that look bad.
#795
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 673
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Oregon
I got a flyer from Sony in my Sunday paper. On the back was an ad for blu-ray. In the description it says:
"Delivers full HD 1080p for over twice the resolution of regular DVD."
I thought the Sony was going to be better than the Samsung?
The Samsung has 5 times better resolution than DVD, but Sony is only twice the resolution?
"Delivers full HD 1080p for over twice the resolution of regular DVD."
I thought the Sony was going to be better than the Samsung?
The Samsung has 5 times better resolution than DVD, but Sony is only twice the resolution?
#796
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by bdhart
I got a flyer from Sony in my Sunday paper. On the back was an ad for blu-ray. In the description it says:
"Delivers full HD 1080p for over twice the resolution of regular DVD."
I thought the Sony was going to be better than the Samsung?
The Samsung has 5 times better resolution than DVD, but Sony is only twice the resolution?
"Delivers full HD 1080p for over twice the resolution of regular DVD."
I thought the Sony was going to be better than the Samsung?
The Samsung has 5 times better resolution than DVD, but Sony is only twice the resolution?
#797
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
yeah....okay.
Is the picture better with HD? Sure, it certainly is. But, in my experience, the step up from SD DVD on a conventional 480 line TV to a well upscaled DVD on a 1080 line HDTV is bigger in perceived picture improvement than going from a well upscaled DVD on a 1080 line HDTV to HD DVD on a 1080 line HDTV. (Whether this would be so using a 720p display, I have no idea.)
This has nothing to do with pixel counts (both have the same number of pixels) but in perceived PQ. Upscaling DVDs by interpolating lines of resolution can look pretty good if done well. This issue was much discussed (argued over, would be more like it) several months ago in this forum with regard to the step up from VHS to DVD versus DVD to HD. Some of us tried to make the argument that the perceived step from a crappy VHS picture to upscaled DVD was greater than from DVD to HD DVD, pixel counts notwithstanding. Others disagreed, to put it mildly. In their view, numbers of pixels were everything and they showed little understanding of the merits of upscaling. Qué será.
If you see things differently on your system, great. But I maintain that an average HDTV buyer will find the PQ of upscaled DVDs to be pretty damn good, especially if he/she moved way up in screen size at the same time.
But you're right: "Yeah....okay." It is just my opinion, after all.
#798
Banned by request
Lizard, I've found the exact opposite. The only DVD I've seen that looked remotely HD when upconverted was Chronicles of Riddick. Everything else I've watched upconverted on DVD looks soft to my eyes. You just can't escape the fact that trying to simulate 1080 lines of information when you're only working with 480 lines of reference is not going to give you as good of an image as when you have all 1080 lines present on the disc.
#799
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Lizard, I've found the exact opposite. The only DVD I've seen that looked remotely HD when upconverted was Chronicles of Riddick. Everything else I've watched upconverted on DVD looks soft to my eyes. You just can't escape the fact that trying to simulate 1080 lines of information when you're only working with 480 lines of reference is not going to give you as good of an image as when you have all 1080 lines present on the disc.



