Toshiba HD-DVD Player for pre-order at Best Buy (deal dead)
#51
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
At least yours lasted a few days. I got the fucking run around from them. Am I wrong in saying that if the charge your credit card they are bound to sell it at that price? Also, there may be some gray area here because this was essentially purchased in-store.
I'm pissed that they held my money for a week. I am considering getting in touch with the attorney general. It is bad enough they are "fixing" their mistake, but I don't think it is legal to do after they charge you for it.
I'm pissed that they held my money for a week. I am considering getting in touch with the attorney general. It is bad enough they are "fixing" their mistake, but I don't think it is legal to do after they charge you for it.
#52
Banned
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 1,718
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by paradicelost
I guess i'm a bigger idiot when it comes to this stuff than i thought. Again i'm apologize for being completely ignorant when it comes to this stuff but i have to admit when it comes to hdtv i'm pretty much a J6P. Again i usually try to come off this stupid, but with this I'd like to know.
#53
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Blu-Ray: We Don't Need No Stinkin' Petition
Posts: 6,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Qui Gon Jim
At least yours lasted a few days. I got the fucking run around from them. Am I wrong in saying that if the charge your credit card they are bound to sell it at that price? Also, there may be some gray area here because this was essentially purchased in-store.
I'm pissed that they held my money for a week. I am considering getting in touch with the attorney general. It is bad enough they are "fixing" their mistake, but I don't think it is legal to do after they charge you for it.
I'm pissed that they held my money for a week. I am considering getting in touch with the attorney general. It is bad enough they are "fixing" their mistake, but I don't think it is legal to do after they charge you for it.
#54
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by joshd2012
I doubt they charged. More than likely, they put a hold on that money (as all retailers do to ensure that the money is there when they do ship).
#55
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is my understanding (maybe I'm wrong) that you can't be charged for a pre-order until the item ships. Just about every other e-tailer works this way. The buyer won't be stuck holding the bag if the company goes out of business before the order ships.
You can call it a "hold" but to me, the money was gone for almost a full week after they cancelled. To me, that is charging. I understand that they do a pre-authorization, but I have never seen it done for the full amount.
I'm not specifically crying over the cancellation, though I do think that legally, if you are charged, then they are obligated to follow through. I am angry that I was charged and cancelled immediately, was told my order could not be re-instated, and they kept my money for a week.
You can call it a "hold" but to me, the money was gone for almost a full week after they cancelled. To me, that is charging. I understand that they do a pre-authorization, but I have never seen it done for the full amount.
I'm not specifically crying over the cancellation, though I do think that legally, if you are charged, then they are obligated to follow through. I am angry that I was charged and cancelled immediately, was told my order could not be re-instated, and they kept my money for a week.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Order canceled, no surprise.
No $50 though.
Edit: I just didn't read down far enough! My email included the $50 as well.
No $50 though.
Edit: I just didn't read down far enough! My email included the $50 as well.
Last edited by Chew; 01-23-06 at 11:31 AM.
#58
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Qui Gon Jim
It is my understanding (maybe I'm wrong) that you can't be charged for a pre-order until the item ships. Just about every other e-tailer works this way. The buyer won't be stuck holding the bag if the company goes out of business before the order ships.
You can call it a "hold" but to me, the money was gone for almost a full week after they cancelled. To me, that is charging. I understand that they do a pre-authorization, but I have never seen it done for the full amount.
I'm not specifically crying over the cancellation, though I do think that legally, if you are charged, then they are obligated to follow through. I am angry that I was charged and cancelled immediately, was told my order could not be re-instated, and they kept my money for a week.
You can call it a "hold" but to me, the money was gone for almost a full week after they cancelled. To me, that is charging. I understand that they do a pre-authorization, but I have never seen it done for the full amount.
I'm not specifically crying over the cancellation, though I do think that legally, if you are charged, then they are obligated to follow through. I am angry that I was charged and cancelled immediately, was told my order could not be re-instated, and they kept my money for a week.
However, your opinion on holds means little to the legal world I'm afraid, which has apparently decided that a hold is different from a charge. If it is becoming a problem, contact your bank. I've had holds removed early twice in certain circumstances, one very similar to this. It is a pain and will require several phone calls, no doubt. NEVER do long term shopping (preorders, hotel room reservations, etc.) on your bankcard, only on a credit card.
I posted this once before but it was deleted as a threadcrap, should be ok now: BB will not honor its mistakes. Unlike CC and some other stores that will. I think BB has language somewhere that states this, "not responsible for errors in ads" or some such. Although other stores have the same language printed and still will honor some mistakes.