Why Why Are We C*%^&ring The Internet?
#26
Re: Why Why Are We Censoring The Internet?
Originally posted by shifrbv
Why do people always like to censor things on internet forums? It seems like every forum that is even halfway decently populated has it's own group that want to strike down what others say.
Especially in America, where every human is supposed to have the right to free speech (first, therefore, most important amendment), I am constantly amazed how Americans are the first to whip out the black magic marker and erase others opinions.
I, myself, can't imagine finding someone else's opinion even remotely offending enough to want to strike it off some forum. But I guess, I'm too tolerant. I should become like everyone else and get out my Sharpie.
What ever happened to free speech?
Why do people always like to censor things on internet forums? It seems like every forum that is even halfway decently populated has it's own group that want to strike down what others say.
Especially in America, where every human is supposed to have the right to free speech (first, therefore, most important amendment), I am constantly amazed how Americans are the first to whip out the black magic marker and erase others opinions.
I, myself, can't imagine finding someone else's opinion even remotely offending enough to want to strike it off some forum. But I guess, I'm too tolerant. I should become like everyone else and get out my Sharpie.
What ever happened to free speech?
If you had started another thread, and then I (or another mod) deleted those posts as well, then that would be censoring. What occurred in that thread was nothing more than a thread cleanup.
For the record, I used the term "whining" to mean "political discussion." Nothing more than that.
#27
Originally posted by Groucho
The point is, we all have our differences with the moderators.
The point is, we all have our differences with the moderators.
#28
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by shifrbv
. . .
As far as having the freedom to conduct your own little fascist feifdom just because you own something, doesn't make it right.
I would never restrict speech (unless it was of an illegal nature) on my forum. I would consider that distinctly unAmerican.
. . .
As far as having the freedom to conduct your own little fascist feifdom just because you own something, doesn't make it right.
I would never restrict speech (unless it was of an illegal nature) on my forum. I would consider that distinctly unAmerican.
Be a decent person and understand the goals of that thread. You actively chose to change it. I don't know about you, but I don't think asking you to start your own ****ing thread is a huge limitation on your expression.
Again, you can run a messageboard how you choose, as a forum for everyone to impose themselves on others. There are lots of those forums out there, I choose to not participate in them. This is run with some level of community responsibility.
Last edited by Bushdog; 09-09-03 at 03:53 PM.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by shifrbv
I would never restrict speech (unless it was of an illegal nature) on my forum. I would consider that distinctly unAmerican.
I would never restrict speech (unless it was of an illegal nature) on my forum. I would consider that distinctly unAmerican.
I've seen unmoderated (or poorly moderated) forums. Be glad that this isn't one of them.
#31
DVD Talk Legend
It always amuses me when people say, "Hey, this is America! I can do whatever I want!"
The right to free speech is pretty direct: you can state your mind on a public street corner, in your home, and in your own private establishment, or publish whatever you want, or start your own club, or whatever, but it is not and was never intended to be some kind of expressed permission to shoot your mouth off whenever you want.
If you work for Best Buy, they will not let you wear your "Legalize Marijuana" button; at church, wearing a shirt that says "Satan Rules" will probably get you escorted to the door. If someone is giving a speech and you heckle them, you can be legally thrown out; and in a private Internet forum such as this, if a moderator deletes or changes one of your posts, that is their duty and right.
The fact that the mods and admins allowed you to have this new thread to complain in tells you that at least there is a sincere effort here to let you speak your mind, but that is by no means a right -- it is a privelege, and it can and will be taken away.
(By the way, don't take any of this as a personal attack. Everyone here is just exchanging thoughts and ideas, and no one is out to get you personally. For an example of what a personal attack looks like, see my next post.)
The right to free speech is pretty direct: you can state your mind on a public street corner, in your home, and in your own private establishment, or publish whatever you want, or start your own club, or whatever, but it is not and was never intended to be some kind of expressed permission to shoot your mouth off whenever you want.
If you work for Best Buy, they will not let you wear your "Legalize Marijuana" button; at church, wearing a shirt that says "Satan Rules" will probably get you escorted to the door. If someone is giving a speech and you heckle them, you can be legally thrown out; and in a private Internet forum such as this, if a moderator deletes or changes one of your posts, that is their duty and right.
The fact that the mods and admins allowed you to have this new thread to complain in tells you that at least there is a sincere effort here to let you speak your mind, but that is by no means a right -- it is a privelege, and it can and will be taken away.
(By the way, don't take any of this as a personal attack. Everyone here is just exchanging thoughts and ideas, and no one is out to get you personally. For an example of what a personal attack looks like, see my next post.)
#32
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by dork
I haven't said anything about this until now, but I feel emboldened by this thread. Why do the mods keep changing all of my posts to make them really suck?
I haven't said anything about this until now, but I feel emboldened by this thread. Why do the mods keep changing all of my posts to make them really suck?
#33
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 6,646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: wishing I was in Vegas
Another thread by someone confused about the concept of "censorship"?
Oh well.
FINALLY someone with a clear view of the "right" to free poop, an equally confused concept.
Oh well.
Originally posted by Groucho
That's exactly right. For the same reasons, I cannot go into your home and poop in your living room.
That's exactly right. For the same reasons, I cannot go into your home and poop in your living room.
#34
Admin Emeritus
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
You have to wonder, though, what the founding fathers believed about the right to free poop. Even hairier is the concept of separation of poop and state, which isn't found anywhere in the text of the Constitution.
#35
#36
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Why Why Are We Censoring The Internet?
Originally posted by shifrbv
What ever happened to free speech?
What ever happened to free speech?




