The offer for Cinescape, Premiere & Fangoria I think is
too high. You have it listed for all 3 $65 for one year.
But I checked each individually. I rounded them off.

Fangoria is $25.
Premiere is $15.
Cinescape is $15.
Total of the 3 is $55.
Plus there is a $5 off coupon that ends today.

Am I reading this dvdtalk offer wrong or what?

Thanks for the info, I'll follow up with them and see if they made an error

Is this offer good for re-subscribing (I already have a subscription to the magazines, but would love to extend for that price)???

yes