Embedded quotes?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 4,795
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kailua, HI
Embedded quotes?
With the old forum software when you quoted someone who had a quote in his message, both quotes appeared. I think this can still be done manually, but it is turned off by default. This change sometimes creates confusion and makes things harder to read. I sometimes have to scroll up and find the original quote for things to make sense. I know this used to lead to some clutter and I even remember a joke thread in Other with over 30 embedded quotes (
), but I think removing this feature does more harm than good. Is there any chance of this being changed back?
), but I think removing this feature does more harm than good. Is there any chance of this being changed back?
#2
Retired
I vote to leave it off. The added clutter caused by embedded quotes isn't worth the slight convenience gained by enabling them. Too many people already clutter posts by quoting whole posts only to address one sentence of them. Turn this back on and they will quote 5 embedded quotes and the whole post just to respond to one sentence as they did on the old software.
#3
Mod Emeritus
Joined: Feb 1999
Posts: 19,053
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Gone to the islands - 'til we meet again.
FWIW, I liked having all quotes included... made for easier reading. Now you may have to go back through dozens of posts to try to figure out what someone is talking about.
#5
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by Bushdog
If there were a setting to allow for 2 (maybe 3) embedded quotes max, I would be all for it. The problem last time was too much of a good thing.
Originally posted by Dead
FWIW, I liked having all quotes included... made for easier reading. Now you may have to go back through dozens of posts to try to figure out what someone is talking about.
Originally posted by joshinkle
I vote to leave it off. The added clutter caused by embedded quotes isn't worth the slight convenience gained by enabling them. Too many people already clutter posts by quoting whole posts only to address one sentence of them. Turn this back on and they will quote 5 embedded quotes and the whole post just to respond to one sentence as they did on the old software.
Originally posted by foker
With the old forum software when you quoted someone who had a quote in his message, both quotes appeared. I think this can still be done manually, but it is turned off by default. This change sometimes creates confusion and makes things harder to read. I sometimes have to scroll up and find the original quote for things to make sense. I know this used to lead to some clutter and I even remember a joke thread in Other with over 30 embedded quotes (
), but I think removing this feature does more harm than good. Is there any chance of this being changed back?
With the old forum software when you quoted someone who had a quote in his message, both quotes appeared. I think this can still be done manually, but it is turned off by default. This change sometimes creates confusion and makes things harder to read. I sometimes have to scroll up and find the original quote for things to make sense. I know this used to lead to some clutter and I even remember a joke thread in Other with over 30 embedded quotes (
), but I think removing this feature does more harm than good. Is there any chance of this being changed back?
Last edited by Aghama; 10-11-01 at 11:29 AM.
#6
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Dead
FWIW, I liked having all quotes included... made for easier reading. Now you may have to go back through dozens of posts to try to figure out what someone is talking about.
FWIW, I liked having all quotes included... made for easier reading. Now you may have to go back through dozens of posts to try to figure out what someone is talking about.




