![]() |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Cheato
(Post 10238971)
Thanks, Giles, for proving my point earlier in this thread.
Rave all you want about "OAR," but sometimes it's neither (a) the dimensions that were planned by the creators, nor (b) the ratio that looks best. I'll take my FS Jungle Book and Robin Hood and 2.55:1 Sleeping Beauty. Enjoy your cropped versions that some marketer says you should have watched 20 or 30 or 40 years ago. These pressbooks were written by marketers for marketing purposes, and they would say "project at 100:1" if they thought it would sell more tickets. But hey, if you want to insist you're right, that's your prerogative. However, I'd like to think that we can agree that both the theatrical ratio and the animated ratio should be given on future releases, as that would satisfy, mostly, both camps on the ratio issue. Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Tim Tucker
(Post 10238332)
I wonder why Disney's preferred ratio was 1.75:1, when everyone else was using 1.66:1 or 1.85:1?
From what I can gather, after Lady and SB, which were costly for the Disney company to make, they went back to shooting live-action, and animating, Disney films at academy ratio, framing the action in that 1.75:1 frame, which became the "Disney" ratio, as it was more cost effective for them to do it this way. Of course, as with anything, there were exceptions, "Old Yeller" & "The One and Only, Genuine, Original Family Band" being instructed at 1.85, and "Swiss Family Robinson", etc. being shown at the wider, cinemascope ratio of 2.35. Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Tim Tucker
(Post 10238332)
I wonder why Disney's preferred ratio was 1.75:1, when everyone else was using 1.66:1 or 1.85:1?
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Were there any 70 mm engagements of Sleeping Beauty in its original release? What aspect ratio were they?
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
most 70mm were/are 2.20:1
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Maybe I need a refresher course. Wasn't Sleeping Beauty supertechnirama? I think it's 4 perf 70mm. I thought supertechnirama's AR was 2.55.
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Sleeping Beauty was acutally photographed in 8-perf 35 mm Technirama process and then optically enlarged to 70 mm 5-perf prints for select venues that were equipped to present the movie as such.
http://www.widescreenmuseum.com/widescreen/wingtr3.htm Disney's 'The Black Cauldron' was also a Super Techirama 70 film - the last one actually. 26 films were released as such and most were shot in 35mm (2.35) but when projected in SPTech70 were 2.20:1 |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Ah, I knew I needed a refresher, thanks. It was a horizontal process using 35mm film in-camera, running "double wide" across what would be two standard frames. Kind of like Vista Vision. Right?
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Mabuse
(Post 10250232)
Ah, I knew I needed a refresher, thanks. It was a horizontal process using 35mm film in-camera, running "double wide" across what would be two standard frames. Kind of like Vista Vision. Right?
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 10245321)
Sleeping Beauty was acutally photographed in 8-perf 35 mm Technirama process and then optically enlarged to 70 mm 5-perf prints for select venues that were equipped to present the movie as such.
http://www.widescreenmuseum.com/widescreen/wingtr3.htm Disney's 'The Black Cauldron' was also a Super Techirama 70 film - the last one actually. 26 films were released as such and most were shot in 35mm (2.35) but when projected in SPTech70 were 2.20:1 Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
I have some pressbook information to add...
:up: "The Black Hole" 1979 Premiere Release Information: "FOR A PERFECT PRESENTATION THE ASPECT RATIO FOR A SUPER WIDESCREEN IMAGE MUST BE 2:35 to 1" (NOTE: Both the Disney and Anchor Bay DVDs present "The Black Hole" in it's original theatrical aspect ratio.) The Disney DVD is 16X9 enhanced, not sure about the Anchor Bay one. Also, this pressbook is one of three from an order I placed, the other two were shipped separately, waiting on them still... :up: "Sleeping Beauty" 1959 Premiere Release Information: "MR. EXHIBITOR...IMPORTANT NOTE! To Present "Sleeping Beauty" In It's Full, Breathtaking Scope, It Is Absolutely Necessary That You Use Aspect Ratio 2:35 to 1" Of course, we already had the link to the letter from the pressbook, from that Digital Bits article. The pressbook I received had an insert, not the letter, stating the same info in the letter... "IMPORTANT! The 35mm Print of "Sleeping Beauty" Must Be Projected at an Aspect Ratio of 2.35 to 1" For 1960's "The Sign Of Zorro", there were no projection instructions in it's pressbook, adding to the list of those not having that info. "Lady And The Tramp" was shipped separately, so I'm waiting on that one. Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
I also wanted to add these four to the list, which I had already known about them, but wanted to add to my collection...
:up: "The Aristocats" 1970 Premiere Release Information: "MR. EXHIBITOR THE ASPECT RATIO FOR "THE ARISTOCATS" FOR BEST SCREEN QUALITY IS 175 TO 1." * (NOTE: Only the 'Special Edition' DVD release of "The Aristocats" presents the film in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.75:1.) *That's not a typo from me by the way, it actually says 175 TO 1 in the pressbook, not 1.75 or 1:75. "The Strongest Man In The World" 1975 Premiere Release Information: "The Aspect Ratio for "The Strongest Man in the World" to create the most spectacular screen image is 1.75 to 1." (NOTE: While the theatrical framing for this release is 1.75:1, the DVD release is at a (Open-matte/ Pan & Scan?) 1.33:1 ratio.) :up: "The Apple Dumpling Gang" 1975 Premiere Release Information: (NOTE: The animated featurette, *"Donald and his Duckling Gang" premiered with this.) *EDIT - This was a compilation of previous animated shorts/ Thanks to Mabuse for catching that... "MR. EXHIBITOR: THE ASPECT RATIO TO BEST EXHIBIT THE HILARIOUS WILD WEST ACTION IN THE APPLE DUMPLING GANG IS 1-75 TO 1." (NOTE: Only the DVD releases of "The Apple Dumpling Gang" presents the film in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.75:1.) "Pete's Dragon" 1977 Premiere Release Information: (NOTE: The theatre kit states that the running time of the film is 2 hours and 7 minutes, while the DVD releases are 2 hours and 9 minutes. That makes an extra 2 minutes.) "So Elliott the Dragon can be seen at his brazzle dazzle best, please project "Pete's Dragon" at the ASPECT RATIO 1.75 to 1" (NOTE: While the theatrical framing for this film is 1.75:1, the DVD releases are misframed at 1.66:1.) I'll update the list shortly... Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by AlwaysOAR
(Post 10254894)
I want to say that "Tron", I believe, is one of those 26 films, not sure though. Do you have a link to those 26?
Scott 'Digital & 65mm' the films: Solomon and Sheba Sleeping Beauty Spartacus The Trials of Oscar Wilde El Cid King of Kings Carthagine in Fiamme The Savage Innocents Madame Sans Gene Barabbas Black Tights/Les Collants Noirs The Music Man Shin No Shikotei/The Great Wall Venus Imperiale 55 Days of Peking The Golden Head Shaka / Buddha Hercule a la Conquette de l'Atlantide La Fayette Zulu The Pink Panther Circus World The Long Ships Custer of the West Clint, El Solitario The Black Cauldron 'Tron' is listed as a Super Panavision 70 release. |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
in regards to Pete's Dragon - I've read from various sources the original roadshow version ran at 134 minutes.
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 10255168)
'Tron' is listed as a Super Panavision 70 release.
Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 10255178)
in regards to Pete's Dragon - I've read from various sources the original roadshow version ran at 134 minutes.
In any event, whatever is missing hopefully will be made available on the next release of Pete's Dragon, in addition to it's theatrical release, and the aspect ratio being fixed. Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
"The Apple Dumpling Gang" 1975 Premiere Release Information:
(NOTE: The animated featurette, "Donald and his Duckling Gang" premiered with this.) "MR. EXHIBITOR: THE ASPECT RATIO TO BEST EXHIBIT THE HILARIOUS WILD WEST ACTION IN THE APPLE DUMPLING GANG IS 1-75 TO 1." (NOTE: Only the DVD releases of "The Apple Dumpling Gang" presents the film in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.75:1.) ---------------------------------------- What is Donald and his Duckling Gang? I've never heard of it. There were no original Donald shorts in the '70s. This must have been a retitle of an old cartoon or something. |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Mabuse
(Post 10256983)
What is Donald and his Duckling Gang? I've never heard of it. There were no original Donald shorts in the '70s. This must have been a retitle of an old cartoon or something.
wikipedia article infers that it was a compilation |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by AlwaysOAR
(Post 10227118)
In regards to "Tron", I've yet to come across a pressbook for it.
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Mabuse
(Post 10256983)
"The Apple Dumpling Gang" 1975 Premiere Release Information:
(NOTE: The animated featurette, "Donald and his Duckling Gang" premiered with this.) "MR. EXHIBITOR: THE ASPECT RATIO TO BEST EXHIBIT THE HILARIOUS WILD WEST ACTION IN THE APPLE DUMPLING GANG IS 1-75 TO 1." (NOTE: Only the DVD releases of "The Apple Dumpling Gang" presents the film in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.75:1.) ---------------------------------------- What is Donald and his Duckling Gang? I've never heard of it. There were no original Donald shorts in the '70s. This must have been a retitle of an old cartoon or something. Oh wow...Nice catch! I usually check both wiki and IMDB for that stuff, not that they're that reliable sometimes, and IMDB even says 1977 for "Donald And His Duckling Gang", and Apple... premiered in '75. I don't remember what I read originally from them. Looking at IMDB again, it is apparent that this is a compilation of some previous shorts. Usually for any live-action or animated featurette attached to a feature release, it'll say Released by or Re-released by Walt Disney...which is indication as to whether or not it is a premiere. For "Donald And His Duckling Gang" it only says Walt Disney Productions next to it. I'll correct that in the list...Thanks again for catching that... Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
I received the remaining pressbooks I ordered...
1955's "Lady And The Tramp", no projection instructions in it's pressbook, though it states throughout, "FIRST All-Cartoon Feature In Cinemascope". It is pretty much established though that Lady premiered at the 2.55:1 ratio, along with an academy ratio version, when it came out in '55. Also, the live-action featurette, "Switzerland", premiered with Lady, and it also was advertised as the first "People and Places" featurette to be shown in Cinemascope. 1964's "The Misadventures of Merlin Jones", no projection instructions in it's pressbook. 1966's "The Ugly Dachsund", no projection instructions in it's pressbook. Also, the animated featurette, "Winnie The Pooh And The Honey Tree" premiered with this. 1980's "Midnight Madness", again no projection instructions in it's pressbook. "Babes In Toyland" 1961 Premiere Release Information: (NOTE: The animated featurette, "Aquamania" premiered with this. Also, the theatre kit states a run time of 100 Minutes, while the DVD release states 106 min., that's a gain of 6 minutes.) "Mr. Exhibitor... Perfect projection will assure your audiences of getting all the wonderful pleasures of "Babes in Toyland"... so be sure to use ASPECT RATIO 1:75 to 1 WARNING: If projected at a ratio less than 1:75 to 1 there will be a black border at top and/or bottom of screen!" (NOTE: While the theatrical framing for this film was 1.75:1, the DVD release is (Open-matte/ Pan & Scanned?) at 1.33:1.) For 1966's Lt. Robin Crusoe, U.S.N., I got the '74 re-release one for it, and I will be sending it back, as the seller will be sending me the premiere release one he should have sent me originally. I'll get it in a couple of weeks at my work address overseas. I also received the following pressbook, but didn't bother to mention it previously as we already had the info for it... For The Parent Trap , it does state a runtime of 129 MINUTES. I had mistakenly believed it's pressbook said 125 minutes from the scans of it on it's Vault Disney release, as the scans were somewhat blurry, but the rest of the information I posted about it earlier is still correct. Anyway, I'll be updating the list soon with the new info... Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
I wanted to add that in addition to waiting for 1966's Lt. Robin Crusoe, U.S.N., I ordered for delivery, at my work address overseas, the following...
1960's Ten Who Dared 1971's The Wild Country 1971's The Barefoot Executive 1972's Napoleon And Samantha Anyway, I'll be getting the info out for these in about two weeks... Scott |
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
in regards to Lady and the Tramp were all the theatrical engagements, even the non-Cinemascope mass 35mm prints released in 2.55 or optically reduced/cropped to 2.35 or lower?
|
Re: The Disney Films - Theatrical Aspect Ratios Verified
Originally Posted by Giles
(Post 10262648)
in regards to Lady and the Tramp were all the theatrical engagements, even the non-Cinemascope mass 35mm prints released in 2.55 or optically reduced/cropped to 2.35 or lower?
By what I can gather, in 1956/57 I believe, the original 2.55:1 aspect ratio of CinemaScope was changed into 2.35:1, to allow for an optical mono track (plus 2.35:1 was getting to be the standard screen ratio), if I'm remembering what I read somewhere correctly, and the website escapes me now. So unlike 1959's "Sleeping Beauty", which was animated at 2.55:1, but premiered at 2.35:1 (or 2.20:1 for the 70mm roadshow engagements), 1955's "Lady And The Tramp" I believe was premiered at 2.55:1. Also, from your earlier post... in a memo dated July 28, 1953, the Studio green lit the CinemaScope version of Lady and the Tramp, while it also established a "Standard Version" ... I believe that the standard version (academy ratio) backgrounds for L&TT were animated first, with additional information animated on the sides of the academy ratio version to create the cinemascope version. The characters and action were then animated for both versions, or were basically repositioned from the academy to the wider cinemascope. As it was 1955, and widescreen was only a couple of years into becoming the norm, I assume Disney wasn't sure if the cinemascope version could be shown everywhere, as the transition from the standard to widescreen was still in it's earliest stages. Just my guess/theory anyway. Also, for the Platinum DVD release of L&TT, instead of giving us that standard version, we got a pan & scan of the cinemascope version. I guess Disney didn't want to go through the trouble/cost of remastering the standard version. When you compare Lady and the Tramp to other CinemaScope pictures of 1955 (The Seven Year Itch, Guys & Dolls, Rebel Without A Cause, etc.), all of them use the 2.55:1 ratio also. Scott |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:58 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.