Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Not sure where you have seen a lot of mixed reviews for this one:
Rotten Tomatoes: 97%
Metacritic: 88

The general consensus is that, yes, it is good....

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

My opinion is that it is my favorite Pixar movie to date. This movie totally blindsided me. I did not expect to enjoy it walking into the theater.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

The first 10-15 min of the movie is the most touching I have ever watched in an animated movie. Pixar knows how to hit the heart.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

surprised at no 3D version listed. Granted the 3D effects in the film were subtle and not overbearing, but surprised non the less

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

we will see a 3D version down the road when the home technology catches up...Pixar does not want to release the old school 3D version..

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

double dip!!!

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

This was one of the funniest, most beautifully shot, intensely moving films I have seen in years. Definitely not what I was expecting, but it's going to go in some sort of favorites list. two thumbs up!

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

I agree 100% Just brilliant film making, love that that particular section was done dialogue free as well.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Yeah, I too 100% agree. I was in tears by the end of that. I was just thinking, being a film major and hopeful future film director, how the fuck do I make a full film top something like this? It makes me happy to be in film and also childishly jealous of the talent Pixar has. It was soooo powerful just seeing a couple's history like that. Made me love and miss Mr. F's wife a lot. Of course it only hurt more when he would mention her and with the photo.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Wait, so where have you found bad reviews?


Deluxe DVD for me. Even if I did own a BD player, I don't really see any must-have features on the BD version.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Oh..sorry...wrong movie....

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

so does the 4-disc Blu-ray contain the Special Edition SDVD with the commentary and the docu (that would be in the 2-disc Up! SE) and not just the 1-disc SDVD? (so 2 Blu-ray, 1 SE SDVD, 1 digital copy)

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

it's most likely the 1 DVD version.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Although "Bolt" BD+DVD came with the Deluxe edition DVD, not the single disc barebones edition, so there might be a possibility.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

Has anyone picked this up yet?

Is the packaging as bad as the Wall-E DVDs?

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

the 2-disc SDVD was normal non-eco friendly keepcase with snap closures and slipcase. or course it also fits nicely in the BB SteelBook™.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

And yet another useless 'exact copy of the case art' slipcover. :p

2-disk did seema bit bare-boned though. Two shorts, commentary,travelogue and alternate villain endings. Guess BR really did get all the goodies this time. A shame really as I really liked what they did with the Wall-E 3-disker.

Re: Pixar's "Up" (11/10/09)
 

I got the steelbook release by best buy! I love it :)