DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   X-Men(animated) coming to DVD (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/548502-x-men-animated-coming-dvd.html)

Gizmo 05-01-09 12:15 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by macnorton (Post 9420046)
Keep in mind those were aired out of order, so it is possible that that it may be closer to 6 volumes.

6 Volumes would not work at all unless each one had 10 or so episodes. Its either going to be 2 or 3 volumes otherwise they run the risk of consumers getting burned out from buying a disc with 10 episodes (if even that) vs one with 15 like the previous 2.

43 episodes remain so 2 volumes with 21 each or 3 with 15 each make sense (rough numbers). I think 3 Volumes makes the most sense.

Isny 05-01-09 12:17 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Apparently Canada didn't get the slipcovers at BB =(

I'd be willing to purchase a set if anyone has an extra with the covers.

Shoot me a PM if you do =D

macnorton 05-01-09 12:30 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9420105)
6 Volumes would not work at all unless each one had 10 or so episodes. Its either going to be 2 or 3 volumes otherwise they run the risk of consumers getting burned out from buying a disc with 10 episodes (if even that) vs one with 15 like the previous 2.

43 episodes remain so 2 volumes with 21 each or 3 with 15 each make sense (rough numbers). I think 3 Volumes makes the most sense.

Sorry your math is correct. I was counting the pending volume 3 release plus 3 more (that is how I got 6). 5 volumes would be perfect.

Gizmo 05-01-09 12:33 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by macnorton (Post 9420131)
Sorry your math is correct. I was counting the pending volume 3 release plus 3 more (that is how I got 6). 5 volumes would be perfect.

It all depends how Disney breaks up these various 'Part 1 of x' episodes. While 15 on each makes sense, that 15 make fall as 'Part 2 of 5' which would not work. We'll know soon enough!

Now my hunt for the slip covers...

macnorton 05-01-09 12:37 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9420137)
It all depends how Disney breaks up these various 'Part 1 of x' episodes. While 15 on each makes sense, that 15 make fall as 'Part 2 of 5' which would not work. We'll know soon enough!

Now my hunt for the slip covers...

Agreed...Spidey breaks down nicer on DVD then the X-Men...but glad to have them on DVD.

Also a point to note, my Amazon order came yesterday without slip covers.

MrStayPuft 05-01-09 01:17 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Ran to my Best Buy today, found only one copy of Vol 1 left with slipcover, and like 5 of vol 2 left with slipcover.

Glad I have a matching set! Next time I won't wait so long.

joltman 05-01-09 02:16 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9419960)
Looking at an episode list (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_X-Men_episodes) its possible Vol 3 could be 16-18 episodes (16 is Xavier Remembers and 18 is Secret, No Longer Buried the last episode of Season 3).

Vol 4 could be 15 episodes which would be all of Season 4

Vol 5 could be 10 episodes being all of Season 5

Otherwise the Vols would look odd because they have to make "Part x" inbetween. Some episodes of S4 aired during S3. Its a big tossup.

I just realized, when I was looking at the episodes, I was looking at the airdate order, not story order. What you say makes sense, although it could be:
Vol 3: 16 episodes (through Xavier Remembers)
Vol 4: 17 episodes (through Beyond Good and Evil part 4)
Vol 5: 10 episodes (through the end of the series)

Considering they don't seem to care about separating by seasons, I think this makes more sense.

Something else I just thought of, I doubt it would happen, but they could fill out the 10 episode volume 5 with the 5 episodes of Spider-Man that had X-Men guest stars.

Gizmo 05-01-09 02:24 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by joltman (Post 9420349)
I just realized, when I was looking at the episodes, I was looking at the airdate order, not story order. What you say makes sense, although it could be:
Vol 3: 16 episodes (through Xavier Remembers)
Vol 4: 17 episodes (through Beyond Good and Evil part 4)
Vol 5: 10 episodes (through the end of the series)

Considering they don't seem to care about separating by seasons, I think this makes more sense.

Something else I just thought of, I doubt it would happen, but they could fill out the 10 episode volume 5 with the 5 episodes of Spider-Man that had X-Men guest stars.

Likely. Only problem with filling in with Spider-man episodes is only if Disney owns the right to that show as well (I have no clue).

Anyway, I went to Best Buy and found they have 8 copies of each Volume with slip covers. Phew.

soccerstud652 05-01-09 03:57 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Can someone post pics of the slipcovers? Both my BB's did not have them.

Breakfast with Girls 05-01-09 04:04 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by soccerstud652 (Post 9420513)
Can someone post pics of the slipcovers? Both my BB's did not have them.

Maybe you should try looking in the thread.

Gizmo 05-01-09 04:39 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by soccerstud652 (Post 9420513)
Can someone post pics of the slipcovers? Both my BB's did not have them.


Originally Posted by DarkPhantom13 (Post 9417256)


soccerstud652 05-01-09 04:51 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Slipcovers are NICEEEEEE. Were they first run only or after the first run? I ordered them on Amazon on Tuesday and they arrived today, without slipcovers.

Edit: Just went to BB, and they had PILES of Vol. 1 & 2 with slipcovers. I guess the slipcovers did not ship with the original shipment because my BB only had one Vol 1 & 2 in stock Tuesday morning without slipcovers.

My Other Self 05-01-09 05:51 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
My Best Buy sold out on Tuesday and still hadn't gotten a second shipment in.

Fry's had nothing.

I just want the damn slipcover ones. I'll have to hit up some more stores tonight.

stingermck 05-01-09 08:58 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Watching episode 1 right now, man has it been a long time. But am I the only one that thinks video quality is rather flat? The picture just doesn't seem that sharp.

shyguy1083 05-01-09 09:08 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by soccerstud652 (Post 9420593)
Edit: Just went to BB, and they had PILES of Vol. 1 & 2 with slipcovers. I guess the slipcovers did not ship with the original shipment because my BB only had one Vol 1 & 2 in stock Tuesday morning without slipcovers.

Yea, I dunno how/why that happened, but i think that's the case. When I went to several stores on release day, NONE of them had any slipcovers and a lot of them were on the verge of selling out. When I went back today and it looked like they had restocked, nearly all stores had slipcovers for both. Kinda odd.

Boba Fett 05-02-09 02:21 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by stingermck (Post 9420895)
Watching episode 1 right now, man has it been a long time. But am I the only one that thinks video quality is rather flat? The picture just doesn't seem that sharp.

I noted that in my review. The colors don't seem as bright as I remember them being, but nothing about the transfer leads to believe the source has deteriorated.

JarJarBinks 05-02-09 08:00 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
There's a good chance that the X-Men crossover episodes of Spider-Man:TAS could be used to pad out the episode numbers. Those two episodes were recently released as a stand-alone in Canada. So for those who want them, they're at least available. Plus 'Pryde of the X-Men' as a bonus on the final volume. I know Disney has control of the Spidey toon, but not sure about Pryde of the X-Men.

Ep #17 - "The Mutant Agenda"

Spider-Man's progressing neogenic mutation is making him ill and he seeks the aid of Professor Charles Xavier. In doing so he meets the X-Men but is disappointed to learn that Xavier does not 'cure' mutancy, only helps those born that way to accept and control their abilities. Later, Beast tells Spider-Man to go to Dr. Herbert Landon, who is working on a cure for mutants. When Spider-Man leaves, Landon's men kidnap Beast. Later Wolverine attacks Spider-Man, thinking he had something to do with Beast's disappearance. The episode ends with Spider-Man and Wolverine fighting. Part 1 of 2.

Ep #18 - "Mutants' Revenge"

Wolverine catches up with Spider-Man, who is hot on the trail of the missing Hank McCoy. Later Hobgoblin steals the mutant technology that Dr. Herbert Landon had prepared for the Kingpin. Spider-Man and Wolverine follow him and discover Beast's location as well as the plot to destroy all mutant-kind; the two team up and rescue Beast from becoming the first test subject of Landon's plot. When Landon accidentally falls victim to his own experiment he is changed into a giant monster that feeds on electrical energy; the X-Men and Spider-Man once again work together and defeat Landon and the Hobgoblin. Part 2 of 2.

There was also a 3-Parter based on Secret Wars. But the only X-Character was Storm.

strawberryshortcake 05-02-09 09:11 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by JarJarBinks (Post 9421310)
There's a good chance that the X-Men crossover episodes of Spider-Man:TAS could be used to pad out the episode numbers.
There was also a 3-Parter based on Secret Wars. But the only X-Character was Storm.

Maybe I've got to re-watch (or watch them for the first time, don't recall whether I've seen them or not) those episodes. Don't know whether I was excited or disappointed to see them either.

I personally would rather see them delegated to Spider-Man's release. Or better yet, maybe even a stand alone release. From your description, it looks as if these episodes could be more "Spider-Man dominant."

The "3-Parter based on Secret Wars. But the only X-Character was Storm" certainly should be reserved for Spider-Man's release.

joltman 05-02-09 10:54 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by JarJarBinks (Post 9421310)
Plus 'Pryde of the X-Men' as a bonus on the final volume. I know Disney has control of the Spidey toon, but not sure about Pryde of the X-Men.

Not THAT would be really cool! If Disney holds the rights to it, I don't see any other way really to release it (I wouldn't think they'd release one 30-minute episode by itself).

As to the Spider-Man episodes, I agree they should definitely be on the Spider-Man releases, but it would be kind of nice for X-Men fans to have those episodes on the X-Men releases. Of course, this doesn't apply to me, because I would have all of the X-Men AND Spider-Man releases :)

Sessa17 05-02-09 12:45 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
It is well worth getting the slipcovers of these, normally I think they don't matter, but these are really nice. Picked them up this morning at Best Buy, they had tons of them, also they rang up $17.50 each which I didn't see advertised so that was a bonus. Really looking foward to watching them, I don't remember them too much of these when I was a kid, so I hope it holds up.

http://i237.photobucket.com/albums/f...g?t=1241285727

shacmasta 05-02-09 03:16 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
My local Best buy finally got another shipment, so I picked up the slipcovers from there. All's well in the world.

Quack 05-02-09 04:40 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
They look so nice.... :)

fumanstan 05-02-09 09:18 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
The video quality definitely looks flat, and it would have been nice to have some sort of work done on it. Oh well, at least they're out. Watched the first 4 episodes and I forgot how much I enjoy the series and the storylines.

The Monkees 05-03-09 01:49 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by Sessa17 (Post 9421593)
It is well worth getting the slipcovers of these, normally I think they don't matter, but these are really nice. Picked them up this morning at Best Buy, they had tons of them, also they rang up $17.50 each which I didn't see advertised so that was a bonus. Really looking foward to watching them, I don't remember them too much of these when I was a kid, so I hope it holds up.

http://i237.photobucket.com/albums/f...g?t=1241285727

It was advertised as 2 for $35

Lipid 05-03-09 04:15 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Is the quality on the DVDs any better than that's on youtube or that one network channel that still shows them?

Isny 05-03-09 04:38 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
Managed to find the slipcovers in Canada. HMV seems to have them in limited quantities. The one I went to in Ottawa at the Rideau Centre had 2 left of volume 2 with the slipcovers, but no volume 1's.

They said HMV has more with slipcovers on order and will have them this coming week.

I also called BB/FS and they said they won't have any with slipcovers.

shanomac316 05-05-09 09:50 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
anyone know if the best buy 2 for 35 is still on ?

joltman 05-05-09 11:30 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by shanomac316 (Post 9425802)
anyone know if the best buy 2 for 35 is still on ?

Nope, that was only through Saturday.

actionjackson29 05-06-09 04:00 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
So has no one gotten the slipcovers online?

jmj713 05-06-09 09:18 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
I keep reading the transfers are subpar with no restoration. I canceled my preorder. I'd like to see some screenshots.

Gizmo 05-06-09 01:17 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by jmj713 (Post 9427796)
I keep reading the transfers are subpar with no restoration. I canceled my preorder. I'd like to see some screenshots.

They will never see a restoration. It took 10 years to get them on DVD - don't expect anything else from this show. They look pretty damn good for being 15+ years old.

Doctor Zoidberg 05-06-09 01:54 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
People also need to remember that the animation of X-Men was never its strong point. What's on the DVD is about the best quality you're going to get, and if you expect a much better transfer and restoration then you might as well ask them to reanimated the show.

Sessa17 05-06-09 04:33 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
I watched the first two eps today, & the transfer really is not that bad, given how long these took to be released, it's silly to expect anything better.

I will say the animation is very weak, I was like 9 when this first aired, I remember it being like the greatest show ever. But I was pretty shocked after watching two eps how bad the animation is. The voice work as well, Gambit makes me cringe (always hated the character anyway), same with Wolverine's voice.

pete5000 05-06-09 04:47 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by Isny (Post 9423046)
Managed to find the slipcovers in Canada. HMV seems to have them in limited quantities.

I also called BB/FS and they said they won't have any with slipcovers.

?

I found the slipcover versions in Ontario at BB for $20 each. They'll fit in with my other Marvel animated movies with the slips...

fumanstan 05-06-09 05:52 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by Sessa17 (Post 9428865)
I watched the first two eps today, & the transfer really is not that bad, given how long these took to be released, it's silly to expect anything better.

I will say the animation is very weak, I was like 9 when this first aired, I remember it being like the greatest show ever. But I was pretty shocked after watching two eps how bad the animation is. The voice work as well, Gambit makes me cringe (always hated the character anyway), same with Wolverine's voice.

I heard the same animation complaint a little while ago in the Comic section, and maybe its just me but I think it's pretty good. I dig the style and art of the show. Of course, I actually really liked the voice work as it brought back great memories of how spot on I felt the voices were. I pretty much associate those voices now with all the characters.

dago2727 05-06-09 09:12 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by actionjackson29 (Post 9427530)
So has no one gotten the slipcovers online?


Order the 2 for $30.98 online at Amazon and received them today. Volume 1 had no slipcover, but Volume 2 did.

stingermck 05-06-09 09:37 PM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by jmj713 (Post 9427796)
I keep reading the transfers are subpar with no restoration. I canceled my preorder. I'd like to see some screenshots.

There were taken off my PC's power DVD. Like others have said this will probably be the only release, but for research sake:

http://img22.imageshack.us/img22/706/pdvd008e.png

http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/6083/pdvd009u.png

http://img22.imageshack.us/img22/2098/pdvd004m.png

http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/7173/pdvd010v.png

Solid Snake 05-07-09 09:37 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
after buying them I can say the visual quality is ok. Wished it was cleaned up but it looks like when it came out...good or bad. Anyone find it weird that when the show was out they'd always do this "Last time on X-Men..." and it'd reference 5 episodes or more ago? The DVD does the same...were they originally released out of order or is that the way they just did it?

stingermck 05-07-09 10:08 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 9430086)
after buying them I can say the visual quality is ok. Wished it was cleaned up but it looks like when it came out...good or bad. Anyone find it weird that when the show was out they'd always do this "Last time on X-Men..." and it'd reference 5 episodes or more ago? The DVD does the same...were they originally released out of order or is that the way they just did it?

I think that was because the story lines were so connected, something would be referenced from many episodes back. I don't recall anything being out of order at the time.

joltman 05-07-09 10:57 AM

Re: X-Men(animated) coming to DVD
 
All the episodes on the DVD are in the correct order, which, with one exception ( 8 8 The Unstoppable Juggernaut March 6, 1993 aired a couple episodes early), is the order they were broadcast as well.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:29 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.