LA Times Notes Lack of Audio Commentaries
12-19-06, 09:01 AM
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 318
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1.) I found that it is most rewarding to listen to these directors talk:
Martin Scorsese
Riddley Scott
David Cronenberg
Terry Gilliam
Oliver Stone
You may not like/agree everything they said (specially Stone,) but you can learn about, not just the insignful stuff of the movies, but also other non-movie-related issue. you can see how intellgence they are.
2.) Some commentaries by Film Historian/critic are also excellent. Ebert's on Critizen Kane come to mind immediately. There are so many info/insign that I feel like Ebert is giving me a leature.
Just recently I watched Gone with the Wind. I am fairly disappointed the commentor is just reading out the movie's background info. Even though it is very informative. It is borning becasue the commentor does not talk about what's going on on-screen.
3.) It is great that some DVD has subtitle for the commentary track. It will be most helpful when the commentors have stronge foreign accent, or they are senior whose voice are weak. (I remenber it is not easy to listen to the commentaries on Sean Connery 007 DVD.)
Martin Scorsese
Riddley Scott
David Cronenberg
Terry Gilliam
Oliver Stone
You may not like/agree everything they said (specially Stone,) but you can learn about, not just the insignful stuff of the movies, but also other non-movie-related issue. you can see how intellgence they are.
2.) Some commentaries by Film Historian/critic are also excellent. Ebert's on Critizen Kane come to mind immediately. There are so many info/insign that I feel like Ebert is giving me a leature.
Just recently I watched Gone with the Wind. I am fairly disappointed the commentor is just reading out the movie's background info. Even though it is very informative. It is borning becasue the commentor does not talk about what's going on on-screen.
3.) It is great that some DVD has subtitle for the commentary track. It will be most helpful when the commentors have stronge foreign accent, or they are senior whose voice are weak. (I remenber it is not easy to listen to the commentaries on Sean Connery 007 DVD.)
12-19-06, 09:28 AM
#27
Member
Hopefully, this isn't what the future holds for new DVDs. Audio commentaries are probably my fav extra feature on a dvd, providing it's a good one (Excorcist: TVYNS, 'nuff said). I understand that a lot of people don't really listen to them, but they are usually such a good source for inside info, trivia, etc.
12-19-06, 09:29 AM
#28
Moderator
Originally Posted by tsetse27
1.) I found that it is most rewarding to listen to these directors talk:
Martin Scorsese
Ridley Scott
David Cronenberg
Terry Gilliam
Oliver Stone
You may not like/agree everything they said (specially Stone,) but you can learn about, not just the insignful stuff of the movies, but also other non-movie-related issue. you can see how intellgence they are.
2.) Some commentaries by Film Historian/critic are also excellent. Ebert's on Critizen Kane come to mind immediately. There are so many info/insign that I feel like Ebert is giving me a lecture.
Just recently I watched Gone with the Wind. I am fairly disappointed the commentor is just reading out the movie's background info. Even though it is very informative. It is borning becasue the commentor does not talk about what's going on on-screen.
3.) It is great that some DVD has subtitle for the commentary track. It will be most helpful when the commentors have stronge foreign accent, or they are senior whose voice are weak. (I remenber it is not easy to listen to the commentaries on Sean Connery 007 DVD.)
Martin Scorsese
Ridley Scott
David Cronenberg
Terry Gilliam
Oliver Stone
You may not like/agree everything they said (specially Stone,) but you can learn about, not just the insignful stuff of the movies, but also other non-movie-related issue. you can see how intellgence they are.
2.) Some commentaries by Film Historian/critic are also excellent. Ebert's on Critizen Kane come to mind immediately. There are so many info/insign that I feel like Ebert is giving me a lecture.
Just recently I watched Gone with the Wind. I am fairly disappointed the commentor is just reading out the movie's background info. Even though it is very informative. It is borning becasue the commentor does not talk about what's going on on-screen.
3.) It is great that some DVD has subtitle for the commentary track. It will be most helpful when the commentors have stronge foreign accent, or they are senior whose voice are weak. (I remenber it is not easy to listen to the commentaries on Sean Connery 007 DVD.)
not to go into specific best and worst commentaries, but as we have pointed out, commentaries are a mixed bag - some work some don't, and with HD-DVD's giving us video commentary tracks, the future of filmmaking insight might look different for better or for worse.
- Joe Dante's commentaries are also great
- Joe Bob Briggs commentary for 'I Spit On Your Grave' takes the cake for being the most entertaining commentary - ever - period. The movie maybe flawed, but the comments/insight are priceless.
12-19-06, 11:57 AM
#29
Originally Posted by Giles
Joe Bob Briggs commentary for 'I Spit On Your Grave' takes the cake for being the most entertaining commentary - ever - period. The movie maybe flawed, but the comments/insight are priceless.
12-19-06, 01:41 PM
#30
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by tsetse27
3.) It is great that some DVD has subtitle for the commentary track. It will be most helpful when the commentors have stronge foreign accent, or they are senior whose voice are weak. (I remenber it is not easy to listen to the commentaries on Sean Connery 007 DVD.)
Although he isn't bad, paired up with Ah-nuld makes you realize that Arnie doesn't have as bad of an accent as people joke about.
12-19-06, 02:38 PM
#31
Moderator
Originally Posted by Mondo Kane
Give Samurai Cop a listen when/if you get the chance. Briggs tops himself in that one. An impossible feat!
12-19-06, 04:38 PM
#32
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Vichy America
Posts: 13,533
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
*NO* commentary at all is worse than a boring one.
12-19-06, 04:47 PM
#33
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by UAIOE
I'd rather there be a cutback in commentaries and a push for a smaller number of *GOOD* commentaries instead of numerous commentaries done because "commentaries are expected".
Nothing is worse than a boring commentary.
12-19-06, 04:49 PM
#34
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by UAIOE
Paul Verhoven
"Deegital.... Reeal.... Deegital... Reeal...."
*INSERT MASSIVE BLOODCURDLING SCREAM HERE THAT WAKES UP THE ENTIRE POPULATION OF NOVA SCOTIA*
Ahhh... the early summer of 1998... good times, man.
12-19-06, 11:59 PM
#35
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I've got to get "Starship Troopers", I do think Paul Verhoven is a riot.
Only if he was doing a boring commentary. 
Originally Posted by Matt Millheiser
What about Hitler?
12-20-06, 07:37 AM
#36
DVD Talk Special Edition
Well I know audio commentaries are going the way of the dodo when Matt Groening and Co. stop recording commentaries on every Simpsons and Futurama episode.
12-20-06, 10:46 AM
#38
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by DJariya
Do the studios have to pay the directors, actors any additional fees to record an audio commentary for DVD's? I know alot of commentaries appear to be recorded during the films initial release in theatres, which would probably force the actors, stars to do it as part of the promotion of the film.
I'd prefer there to be more good and worthwhile commentaries. It's not something you can just demand and sometimes they are interesting, other times not.
12-20-06, 01:11 PM
#41
DVD Talk God
It's funny how we've seen that most of Warner's new releases don't have commentaries and now they give us a commentary on a mediocre film (The Wicker Man) with Nic Cage.
12-20-06, 01:12 PM
#42
Moderator
Originally Posted by DJariya
It's funny how we've seen that most of Warner's new releases don't have commentaries and now they give us a commentary on a mediocre film (The Wicker Man) with Nic Cage.
from what I have read from others who have seen the movie, 'mediocre' is putting it nicely.
12-20-06, 02:06 PM
#43
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by The Bus
I do believe they get paid. I know Arnold got paid a hefty sum for his Total Recall commentary.
No matter what, it was one of the better commentaries.
02-19-07, 08:13 PM
#44
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 196
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looks like this trend is here to stay. Almost all of the recently announced Warner box sets (especially classic films) contain no commentaries.
Sad - I enjoy hearing an expert on the subject or film scholar if the original director or star is not available.
Sad - I enjoy hearing an expert on the subject or film scholar if the original director or star is not available.
Last edited by js097; 02-19-07 at 08:13 PM. Reason: spelling
02-19-07, 10:11 PM
#46
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 688
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
david o. russell's on three kings a warner release is great. I think groening stopped being involved on simpsons commentaries because he became less involved with the show.
commentaries are needed by cast and director.
even a commentary by john mctiernan on predator can help you fall asleep.
commentaries are needed by cast and director.
even a commentary by john mctiernan on predator can help you fall asleep.
02-20-07, 01:25 PM
#47
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: The Other Side
Posts: 985
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Groening no longer does Simpsons commentaries? Really?
Although, I have to say, he never has that much to say. I think he holds back.
I loved Mann's commentary on Collateral.
Although, I have to say, he never has that much to say. I think he holds back.
I loved Mann's commentary on Collateral.
02-20-07, 01:48 PM
#48
Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 67
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Egon's Ghost
Groening no longer does Simpsons commentaries? Really?
Although, I have to say, he never has that much to say. I think he holds back.
Although, I have to say, he never has that much to say. I think he holds back.
Matt Groening still does commentaries
02-20-07, 01:57 PM
#49
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Portland OR
Posts: 1,747
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm in the minority who would much rather see a well made documentary than simply listen to a commentary (like Spielberg does). And I agree that 90% of today's commentaries could go and I wouldn't miss them. The ones that actually appeal to me are very few and far between. I've reached the point these days where I just put them on my laptop with a pair of headphones while I'm at work.
02-20-07, 02:06 PM
#50
DVD Talk Legend
I really like the film historian commentaries. Few of the director ones are worth listening to, but the good ones like Gilliam or Smith are gold.
BTW, I would gladly give up ever having another commentary on DVD if it would stop Brett Ratner from doing them.
BTW, I would gladly give up ever having another commentary on DVD if it would stop Brett Ratner from doing them.