DVD's to be inbedded with an RFID chip
#51
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Out of the sandbox!
Posts: 1,609
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by UAIOE
And they will have people not buying DVD's and ranting up a storm on DVD forums.
Boycotts and terrible sales will follow.
Boycotts and terrible sales will follow.
And when they finally break down and give the customer what they want (I am thinking Star Wars...) they do such a crappy job at that it seems that they almost wanted to make it look like crap.
I don't think some upset DVD connoisseurs will deter them. Yes, people who subscribe to this forum will, initially, piss and moan and they may not buy anything for a while. But Joe Schmo on the street wouldn't give two shits about our little "sticking to the man" Boycott, and we, being who we are, will want to see that 'special feature' that seems so illusive. And we will conform. Not all of us, but majority of us will.
Eventually, a way around this would be found, and then the industry will come out with some other cockamamie way to stop 'piracy'. This cycle will continue for a very long time.
#52
DVD Talk Limited Edition
"IPICO claims that its RFID tags can be read from at least six metres away, and at a rate of thousands of tags per minute. The passive chips require no battery, as they are powered by the energy in radio waves from the RFID reader."
Does this mean someone can drive by my house with a RFID Scanner to see what kind of "Products"/DVD I have in my house. Then could drive around a get a shopping list together and break into the houses that only have what they want.
I have a feeling privacy groups are not going to allow this, law suits coming down the road?
Does this mean someone can drive by my house with a RFID Scanner to see what kind of "Products"/DVD I have in my house. Then could drive around a get a shopping list together and break into the houses that only have what they want.
I have a feeling privacy groups are not going to allow this, law suits coming down the road?
#53
DVD Talk Legend
I think it's important to note that no major studio or DVD player manufacturer has been attached to this project yet. The vnunet article only mentions some studios that the disc manufacturer prints for, not that any of them will use this tech on their discs.
Here's an editorial saying a lot about this tech that people here already have:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060917-7760.html
Here's an editorial saying a lot about this tech that people here already have:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060917-7760.html
#54
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Work. Or commuting. Certainly not at home.
Posts: 17,816
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Jay G.
I think it's important to note that no major studio or DVD player manufacturer has been attached to this project yet. The vnunet article only mentions some studios that the disc manufacturer prints for, not that any of them will use this tech on their discs.
Here's an editorial saying a lot about this tech that people here already have:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060917-7760.html
Here's an editorial saying a lot about this tech that people here already have:
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060917-7760.html
The second article is likely right though. This technology probably won't take hold for this or the next generation. Maybe in 15-20+ years when/if HVD is the standard we'll see it.
#56
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 295
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I fail to see how this will even slow down piracy much less stop it. Even if you have an RFID dvd player it has to be able to play non RFID tags or your home movies you created, old dvds etc would be unplayable. All it takes is one person to figure out how to rip a new RFID DVD to a computer and burn it without the RFID to a blank dvd and the copy protection is gone. How does whoever came up with this retarded idea still have a job?
#57
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Nuff
All it takes is one person to figure out how to rip a new RFID DVD to a computer and burn it without the RFID to a blank dvd and the copy protection is gone.
I this case, a straight copy wouldn't work if it moved this new bit with it. However, a re-author of the disc would probably get rid of it, and since CSS is cracked, it would be easy for pirates and copiers to do so.
So maybe not as simplistic a protection as it first seems, although it's still going to be ultimately circumventable, and thus worthless.
#59
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Alexandria, VA
Posts: 1,197
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by dpz301
i understand the right for one's IP, but all this sounds like it is is a money making venture.
#60
Mod Emeritus
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Gone to the islands - 'til we meet again.
Posts: 19,053
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Iron_Giant
"IPICO claims that its RFID tags can be read from at least six metres away, and at a rate of thousands of tags per minute. The passive chips require no battery, as they are powered by the energy in radio waves from the RFID reader."
Does this mean someone can drive by my house with a RFID Scanner to see what kind of "Products"/DVD I have in my house. Then could drive around a get a shopping list together and break into the houses that only have what they want.
I have a feeling privacy groups are not going to allow this, law suits coming down the road?
Does this mean someone can drive by my house with a RFID Scanner to see what kind of "Products"/DVD I have in my house. Then could drive around a get a shopping list together and break into the houses that only have what they want.
I have a feeling privacy groups are not going to allow this, law suits coming down the road?
Potentially, yes. But, six meters isn't a very long distance and RFID communications tend to work best line of sight, as opposed to through walls. So, with current technology the risk is probably minimal. As time progresses, and technology grows, the risk will probably become much more real.
#61
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by gijon213
I don't think some upset DVD connoisseurs will deter them. Yes, people who subscribe to this forum will, initially, piss and moan and they may not buy anything for a while. But Joe Schmo on the street wouldn't give two shits about our little "sticking to the man" Boycott, and we, being who we are, will want to see that 'special feature' that seems so illusive. And we will conform. Not all of us, but majority of us will.
Remember the original DVIX format. It died despite the efforts of Circuit City and the big studios (Disney, Paramount, etc.) pushing it. "Joe Schmo" just didn't want it.