DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Who else thinks Easter Eggs Blow? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/461832-who-else-thinks-easter-eggs-blow.html)

Josh H 04-10-06 06:25 PM

Yeah, I hate them as well. Stupid to have to search around, enter codes etc. to get to watch some usually worthless, brief extra feature.

GoldenJCJ 04-10-06 08:05 PM


Originally Posted by Billyspunk
Some easter eggs are damn tough to get to. I am still trying to figure out how to get at the Mememto extras in the SE set. Also the 1st Harry Potter had some tough ones...

I ended up just printing out a cheat sheet for the extras on the back of one of the pieces of paper that came inside the DVD. insane that I have to pull out crib notes to access special features.


Usually the only time I watch an easter egg is whenI find it accidently. Otherwise I just never bother.
Besides, if the easter egg is good enough, I'll hear about it eventually through this forum.

Now for The Passion of the Christ NOT to have an easter egg is just plain wrong! :sarcasm:

milo bloom 04-10-06 09:23 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
so for the people complaining about "Easter Eggs"...you're complaining about having extra stuff on a dvd?

who cares what it is or what it entails, no matter what it is, it is still a little something else that wouldn't be there at all or just an extra that was supposed to be there, just hidden for a little effect. some are just the dvd credits, so whether it is there or not who cares (it takes what 2 seconds to play around and either find yourself or look up at DVD Talk), others can be an entire cut of a movie, like T2 Extended.

how can anything extra blow?


When they were first done they were the little extras that weren't any big deal, but then some DVD Producers got a big head and started putting legitimate documentary material on the disc, but hidden as easter eggs. That is when extras blow, and simultaneously, suck.

whotony 04-10-06 09:46 PM


Originally Posted by cdollaz
If they want to make the customer happy, they can make the features obvious instead of making us hunt for them.

Easter eggs are stupid.

this is my thought as well.

i won't call then easter eggs.
i just call them hidden features.

"For instance, the car that is in every Sam Rami film. Never knew that before I searched online."

thats not a hidden feature (easter egg) thats an inside joke for fans to look for.

Zodiac_Speaking 04-10-06 09:56 PM

Yes, the Terminator Extra Extended Cut was a higly cool easter egg, but as of late he eggs have been weak.

mndtrp 04-11-06 01:29 AM

It's the same as cd's and their "hidden" tracks. They were kind of cool the first few times, now it's just annoying.

matome 04-11-06 08:05 AM

They suck. Just put all the extras where they're readily accessible, as I rarely have time to watch the movie, much less do key presses in every direction on every menu or research on the web for an easter egg.

Nick Danger 04-11-06 10:17 AM

They suck, and I don't play the 'Easter egg hunt' game.

It was clever and cool when Monty Python did it on Matching Tie and Hankerchief, but that was thirty years ago.

lateforwork 04-11-06 10:22 AM

Since I have never celebrated Easter, decorating those eggs look they could have have the most fun they ever have together again.

Jamers 04-11-06 11:48 AM


Originally Posted by lateforwork
Since I have never celebrated Easter, decorating those eggs look they could have have the most fun they ever have together again.

Huh?

EddieN 04-11-06 11:56 AM

DVD-ROM only special features? :grunt:

Easter eggs? :|

lotsofdvds 04-11-06 12:15 PM

It would be like McDonalds telling you you get free fries when you buy a hamburger, but you have to go out back and dig under a rock to get them.

Don't make me work for what I've already paid for. Put all the extras on the menu. Hide the DVD credits if you must be cute.

OldBoy 04-11-06 12:38 PM

i don't think many of you understand what a DVD Easter Egg truly is...

TheNightFlier 04-11-06 12:44 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
i don't think many of you understand what a DVD Easter Egg truly is...

Please enlighten us then...

Sean O'Hara 04-11-06 02:04 PM

Easter eggs containing actual, substantial content really do suck, but I don't mind things like the Royal Tenenbaum DVD where there's a hidden outtake of Anjelica Houston's hair catching on fire.

Things like Memento and the original Harry Potter film, where you have to go through a whole rigamorole just to get to regular content, are insults to viewers.

Tscott 04-11-06 02:37 PM


Originally Posted by Sean O'Hara
Easter eggs containing actual, substantial content really do suck, but I don't mind things like the Royal Tenenbaum DVD where there's a hidden outtake of Anjelica Houston's hair catching on fire.

Things like Memento and the original Harry Potter film, where you have to go through a whole rigamorole just to get to regular content, are insults to viewers.

I agree. The best Easter eggs are the ones that could be stumbled upon by an average user and they have cool, but non-essential content. My favorite example is the "Clarice" music video from the Hannibal DVD made of a montage of clips filmed during the few seconds of film after the director called cut and before the cameraman stopped recording. Very cool if you find it, but if you don't you're not missing too much.

But when the content is something the average fan will definitely want to see, they shouldn't make it hard to find. The Nine Inch Nails concert DVD already mentioned is a prime example. The Duran Duran video collection is another bad one. If someone is buying the complete video collection, chances are they'll want to see all the alternate versions of the videos and all the interviews so don't hide them.

Another evil Easter egg is the one that makes you enter in a numbered code with your DVD remote. Not all DVD players have number keys. Who's horrible idea was this?

Even worse than the Easter egg, IMO, is content hidden by trivia games and the like. The Bond - Live at the Royal Albert Hall DVD features a music video that's only accessible after you answer a number of trivia questions. If you ever want to see it again you've got to answer all the questions again.

DrS 04-11-06 02:37 PM

Easter Eggs are a PITA. All content should be easy to get to, no games.

So, studios: please stop.

D

MEJHarrison 04-11-06 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by Sean O'Hara
Things like Memento and the original Harry Potter film, where you have to go through a whole rigamorole just to get to regular content, are insults to viewers.

While they certainly can be annoying, I've never felt insulted by them. :scratch2:

Alan Smithee 04-11-06 04:06 PM


Now for The Passion of the Christ NOT to have an easter egg is just plain wrong!
Same with Here Comes Peter Cottontail and The Easter Bunny Is Comin' To Town- no Easter Eggs on those!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:44 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.