DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Sliver (unrated) --> 3/28 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/453411-sliver-unrated-3-28-a.html)

ShagMan 03-17-06 02:45 PM

Welp, the first review is up, and WOAH, it's horrible. There's lots of problems listed, but the killer is that it's not OAR and there's NO extras, nothing. Looks like another hack job by Paramount, just to cash on Basic Instinct 2's release date.

I've picked up guilty pleasures with no extras before, like Robot Jox.... but no OAR, no sale!
http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=20679

Kerborus 03-17-06 03:26 PM

Can't wait, I loved this movie... Or Stone's boobs, I can't remember which it was...

Julie Walker 03-17-06 11:16 PM

Maybe it's another infamous DP deciding to crop his film for 'more resolution' on tv excuse?

pro-bassoonist 03-17-06 11:35 PM


Originally Posted by Julie Walker
Maybe it's another infamous DP deciding to crop his film for 'more resolution' on tv excuse?

As I mentioned in the review the film is far from being in the correct aspect ratio. In fact, the framing is rather unusual as there are very specific scenes (such as the one when Carly first enters Sliver through the garden and you could definitely tell that the aspect ratio is off) that stick out. Some might be able to tolerate the current version of Sliver but for me this is definitely a missed opportunity. Furthermore, considering the fact that Paramount did not bother to include even a single trailer leads me to believe that the DVD is just what its price suggests...a budget duff!

There are so many extras that they could have added...

Ciao,
Pro-B

MasterofDVD 03-18-06 12:09 AM

I guess I'll rent it just to get my fix. It's a shame they had to mess this up so badly.

Damn she was super hot in this movie.

Living Dead 03-18-06 02:20 PM

Too bad. I was looking forward to picking this one up, but not anymore.

man*machine 03-18-06 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by pro-bassoonist
Furthermore, considering the fact that Paramount did not bother to include even a single trailer leads me to believe that the DVD is just what its price suggests...a budget duff!

There are so many extras that they could have added...

Well, it's not much of a surprise that there are no extras. This is Paramount, you know, who rarely includes even a trailer on most of their catalog titles.

dvd_luver 03-18-06 02:51 PM

I am picking this up anyway, it will make a good VHS upgrade obviously, also I can't read these reviews coming in (see DVDtown), they are way to painful, tearing the film to death. I don't care what the critics say about Sliver, I love this film.

I see nothing has changed with the critics and this.

matome 03-18-06 04:53 PM

Man this sucks about the aspect ratio, but I'll still pick it up since I've never seen the unrated one and it'll probably be another 10 years before it comes out on blu-ray.

bunkaroo 03-19-06 12:45 AM

Any chance of getting a screenshot or two?

pro-bassoonist 03-19-06 01:06 AM

I am currently unable to provide direct screen caps :(

Ciao,
Pro-B

dvd_luver 03-19-06 11:38 AM

No screenshots for me, I still own this on VHS and would love to happily toss it in the garbage. I don't care about the aspect ratio being off, if you owned this on VHS and have to watch this in P&S all the time, it's so easy to not care about proper AR.

Anything but that stinkin VHS tape for me.

DJariya 03-20-06 01:57 AM

I wouldn't have expected a Phillip Noyce audio commentary anyways since he didn't do one for the Patriot Games and Clear and Present Danger Special Editions that were released a couple of years ago.

At least Paramount could have dug into their vaults and dug up an EPK for this movie. Also, Stone has a conversation feature on the new Basic Instinct DVD, was she too busy to do something for this movie?

pro-bassoonist 03-20-06 02:24 AM


Originally Posted by DJariya
Also, Stone has a conversation feature on the new Basic Instinct DVD, was she too busy to do something for this movie?

..quite frankly I do not think anyone invited her to do anything for this DVD release. A few nights ago she appeared on eXtra...and she was very excited about Basic Instinct 2. I would bet that she would have done something for Sliver had anyone made the effort to contact her.

Pro-B

DJariya 03-20-06 02:38 PM


Originally Posted by pro-bassoonist
..quite frankly I do not think anyone invited her to do anything for this DVD release. A few nights ago she appeared on eXtra...and she was very excited about Basic Instinct 2. I would bet that she would have done something for Sliver had anyone made the effort to contact her.

Pro-B

Very true, Paramount is pretty notorious for getting older movies and TV shows out on DVD ASAP and not wanting to spend any money on extras.

riley_dude 03-20-06 05:53 PM

So are they going to show the rumored Baldwin goods??

mike01 03-20-06 07:22 PM

common guys its gotta be worht 9.99?!

dvd_luver 03-21-06 11:09 AM


Originally Posted by mike01
common guys its gotta be worht 9.99?!

Yeah, your right, everyone needs to lighten up a bit and buy this for a fair price.

vedderstapp 03-21-06 12:17 PM

I have it, I just watched it, and it is a perfectly acceptable DVD.

bunkaroo 03-21-06 12:27 PM

I'm going to have this Friday, although there's a chance I'll have it sooner. I can try and post some screenshots then.

Josh Z 03-21-06 01:05 PM


Originally Posted by ChristopherS
An opening credits sequence showing a valcano erruption was scrapped when the crew filming the scene got into an accident and lost the footage.

There was a lot of talk about William Baldwin doing full nudity, which never made the film.

The ending was re-written from the script/ changed from the book to throw off readers/ possibly re-done after test screenings... it's hard to know what exactly happened there. I find it hard to believe whatever a test audience saw could have been worse, so I think it's debatable if there's an alternate ending available.

IIRC, at the time the movie was released it was said that Noyce shot 3 or 4 different endings, all of which test-screened horribly. The one they finally went with was the one that got the least derisive audience response cards.

bunkaroo 03-24-06 06:13 PM

Here's a screenshot-you can see the black bars are not as thick as a standard 2.35:1 release:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v4...htf/sliver.jpg

Hopefully it won't be cramped when I watch it.

Josh Z 03-25-06 02:46 PM

Assuming that screencap was ripped straight from the DVD with no cropping, by my measurement it's 2.08:1.

According to IMDb, the movie was shot with Panavision anamorphic lenses, which if correct would mean that the DVD is cropped, not open-matte.

bunkaroo 03-25-06 05:19 PM

Josh,

I just did the screencap in PowerDVD, pasted into MS Paint and saved as JPEG. Did not touch the image other than that.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:32 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.