DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Mel Brooks Collection Inc. RHMIT 4/4 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/452070-mel-brooks-collection-inc-rhmit-4-4-a.html)

bunkaroo 03-31-06 12:23 PM


Originally Posted by FrancisRizzo3
It is a plain silver disc, with the Young Frankenstein logo, the Fox Home Entertainment logo and the DVD logo.

Odd, huh?

That actually does sound like the old release.

darkside 03-31-06 12:25 PM

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/spikydan1/frank2.jpg

It is the old release. They just stuck it into the current set. That had better be a mistake and not something that happens a lot.

I will be pissed if this is a situation where they had a few hundred of the old discs still in the warehouse and figured they would just put them in the set to get rid of them.

Kocheese99 03-31-06 12:38 PM

i think its a mistake, mine was basically the coverart on the disk.

gryffinmaster 03-31-06 01:00 PM

This gets my vote for oddest and most confusing release so far this year. :up:

Anyone got any any info on what the Robin Hood: MIT disc is like?

FrancisRizzo3 03-31-06 02:01 PM

The weird thing is, that's not the disc I have for the original release. My copy has disc art that says 1998.


Originally Posted by darkside
http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/spikydan1/frank2.jpg

It is the old release. They just stuck it into the current set. That had better be a mistake and not something that happens a lot.

I will be pissed if this is a situation where they had a few hundred of the old discs still in the warehouse and figured they would just put them in the set to get rid of them.


cornbetts 03-31-06 02:16 PM

Are the discs really in those slim caes? The photo of YF looks like it is a normal DVD case.

Slim Cases vs Normal Cases will determine if I buy this set or not.

Kocheese99 03-31-06 02:27 PM

its slim cases

Davy Mack 03-31-06 03:07 PM

Woah, Crap shoot-time....!

darmok 03-31-06 03:10 PM

i'm waiting for them to release them individually. not compelled to own all the titles in the set, and the thinpak cases look cheap and flimsy!!!

bunkaroo 03-31-06 03:11 PM

I think the photo above is someone showing their old version. Definitely slimcases in the box set.

Also, I wonder if later repressings of the old disc dropped or added the 1998. I bought my copy of the old YF back in 2001-I'll have to check if it has the year or not.

darkside 03-31-06 03:37 PM


Originally Posted by bunkaroo
I think the photo above is someone showing their old version. Definitely slimcases in the box set.

Also, I wonder if later repressings of the old disc dropped or added the 1998. I bought my copy of the old YF back in 2001-I'll have to check if it has the year or not.

Yeah, that is a photo of the old version with this cover http://i7.ebayimg.com/02/c/03/c2/2e/b5_7.JPG
There were two versions though of Young Frankenstein with identical content on the disc, but different covers and I guess different disc art. The other cover looks like this.
http://img.oddbanana.com/coverart/am...01909bxlvl.jpg

bunkaroo 04-02-06 12:53 AM

Just found out some interesting info.

From an HTF member, his friend's copy which has the old disc has white text on the slimpak spine, and the art isd actually the same art as the old disc just converted to a slimpak format. It has a UPC too. This is strange because none of the other discs have a UPC.

Mine has no UPC, new art, and most importantly, yellow text on the spine.

This means you presumably can tell what disc in your set before opening it since the spines are visible through the shrinkwrap.

So:

White text=old
Yellow text=new

Hope this helps.

MrStayPuft 04-02-06 01:12 AM

So which release is anamorphic, if any, then? the new yellow, or old white?

bunkaroo 04-02-06 01:30 AM

New=yellow=anamorphic

LorenzoL 04-02-06 08:53 AM


Originally Posted by gryffinmaster
This gets my vote for oddest and most confusing release so far this year. :up:

A DVD set release should never be this confusing.

vegasbaby 04-02-06 11:30 AM

This sounds like another Mel Brooks practical joke.

FantasticVSDoom 04-02-06 04:54 PM

Well my wife just actually picked this up for me and brought it home, and my Young Frank. has the yellow writing but afraid to open it. :lol:

FantasticVSDoom 04-02-06 08:03 PM

Ok so I popped my YF in and it appears to be anamorphic...I dont know any other way to tell besides that its labeled as 1.85 Anamorphic and I have no bars on my 16:9 TV and the picture appears to be pretty clear (my dvd player is an Oppo through DVI on a 47" Panny). Here is what the disc looks like in my set:
http://static.flickr.com/1/122250694_d1c9c10d9a_m.jpg

http://static.flickr.com/34/122250695_198180b57e_m.jpg

http://static.flickr.com/37/122250696_aea7e5588f_m.jpg

gryffinmaster 04-02-06 08:13 PM


Originally Posted by FantasticVSDoom
... Here is what the disc looks like in my set...

That's ... actually kinda cool.

Are the rest looking spiffy as well?

FrancisRizzo3 04-02-06 08:42 PM


Originally Posted by gryffinmaster
That's ... actually kinda cool.

Are the rest looking spiffy as well?

Yes, they all have pretty nice artwork inside the cases. Normally, I prefer content there, but this wasn't an awful choice.

garmonbozia 04-03-06 05:10 PM

I just got my box set today in the mail from Digital Eyes.
My copy of Young Frankenstein is definitely anamorphic. I tested it in my player.

Just to confirm, mine too has yellow text on the spine and no UPC.

So happy I got lucky. Anamorphic versions of YF and HotWP1 are the two main reasons I got this set. If my YF was not anamorphic I would have been pissed.

pete1974 04-03-06 10:45 PM

I read on DeepDiscountDVD that "Blazing Saddles" is the 30th anniversary edition, is that true?

DGibFen 04-03-06 11:07 PM


Originally Posted by pete1974
I read on DeepDiscountDVD that "Blazing Saddles" is the 30th anniversary edition, is that true?

No, this box set includes the old flipper release. It is in widescreen, but doesn't have the deleted scenes/documentaries/TV pilot the 30th anniversary contains.

FantasticVSDoom 04-04-06 07:26 AM

Yeah, its the old release...However watched History of the World part I last night and it looked great. Cant wait to sit down and watch the rest of these!!

Hammer99 04-04-06 11:25 AM


Originally Posted by bunkaroo
Just found out some interesting info.

From an HTF member, his friend's copy which has the old disc has white text on the slimpak spine, and the art isd actually the same art as the old disc just converted to a slimpak format. It has a UPC too. This is strange because none of the other discs have a UPC.

Mine has no UPC, new art, and most importantly, yellow text on the spine.

This means you presumably can tell what disc in your set before opening it since the spines are visible through the shrinkwrap.

So:

White text=old
Yellow text=new

Hope this helps.

Thanks! Just picked up one at BB with yellow text, will check it out later tonight.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:43 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.