Sin City recut... only 4 minutes longer?
#1
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sin City recut... only 4 minutes longer?
Hi.
I was just wondering if there's any truth to the rumours that, instead of being 23 minutes longer, the recut Sin City is only 4 minutes longer? With most of the 'extra length' attributed to the title/credits for each story?
Initially I heard about it on a non-dvd forum I post at, which referred to the imdb boards and this:
http://www.nforce.nl/nfos/shownfoblack.php?nfoid=99461
I've also since seen it in the dvdactive comments page for the movie. But obviously no half-credible sources, as of yet.
Now, the official artwork here:
http://www.dvdactive.com/news/releases/sin-city10.html
Clearly states 'over 20 minutes of additional footage' (as opposed to 4 minutes of footage and 19 minutes of credits; credits which I'm sure most don't consider to be footage).
Most news sites only posted their own re-wordings of the press release (dvd active for example), so you lose the exact wording, but at davisdvd you can find the actual release:
http://www.davisdvd.com/news/bin/press.html
It only says '23 extra minutes'. This wording, unlike the wording on the artwork, could very well mean 19 minutes of credits.
I was just wondering what the case actual is? Seeing as I don't yet own the movie, I'll be buying it regardless, but it'll be disappointing that there will only be 1/6th of the new footage I thought there would be.
FWIW, amazon are using the wording from the artwork in their listing... over 20 minute of actual footage added.
If there is only 4 extra minutes... there's definitely been some deceptive/confusing marketing at play. I mean, giving each film its own title sequence and credits is cool... but just not when you weren't thinking they'd make up most of the extra time.
p.s. if the rumors ar true, it's not possible to watch the extended stories as one uninterrupted film.
I was just wondering if there's any truth to the rumours that, instead of being 23 minutes longer, the recut Sin City is only 4 minutes longer? With most of the 'extra length' attributed to the title/credits for each story?
Initially I heard about it on a non-dvd forum I post at, which referred to the imdb boards and this:
http://www.nforce.nl/nfos/shownfoblack.php?nfoid=99461
I've also since seen it in the dvdactive comments page for the movie. But obviously no half-credible sources, as of yet.
Now, the official artwork here:
http://www.dvdactive.com/news/releases/sin-city10.html
Clearly states 'over 20 minutes of additional footage' (as opposed to 4 minutes of footage and 19 minutes of credits; credits which I'm sure most don't consider to be footage).
Most news sites only posted their own re-wordings of the press release (dvd active for example), so you lose the exact wording, but at davisdvd you can find the actual release:
http://www.davisdvd.com/news/bin/press.html
It only says '23 extra minutes'. This wording, unlike the wording on the artwork, could very well mean 19 minutes of credits.
I was just wondering what the case actual is? Seeing as I don't yet own the movie, I'll be buying it regardless, but it'll be disappointing that there will only be 1/6th of the new footage I thought there would be.
FWIW, amazon are using the wording from the artwork in their listing... over 20 minute of actual footage added.
If there is only 4 extra minutes... there's definitely been some deceptive/confusing marketing at play. I mean, giving each film its own title sequence and credits is cool... but just not when you weren't thinking they'd make up most of the extra time.
p.s. if the rumors ar true, it's not possible to watch the extended stories as one uninterrupted film.
Last edited by gOoBaLL; 12-06-05 at 06:19 PM.
#3
New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I hope it isn't true... the fact that there was no discussion about it on any major sites (this one, htf, etc.) lead me to think it's false... but I thought I'd ask to be sure.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Durham, NC USA
Posts: 994
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i read somewhere (can't remember) that there is indeed only 4 additional minutes. there is another 16 minutes of opening/closing credits because the different segments are now broken out into separate movies. So that's technically 20 additional minutes, but only 4 'real' additional minutes.
I am re-thinking about getting this one now.
I am re-thinking about getting this one now.
#6
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,411
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
nah its bullshit. From Rodriguez himself
"Quote:
Originally Posted by OutlawRonin
Hi my name is Jason and I'm from California. Mr. Rodriguez, I was just wondering if you could tell me a little about the added footage that was put into the extended cut of Sin City. EX: which stories have added footage, which characters are shown in the added footage, and also why you chose to make an extended cut of the film. Thank you for your time.
Hey everybody! Rodriguez here... typing in from Troublemaker Studios...
The new stuff that was put back in amounts to a total of about 24 minutes. Marv episode probably has the most new footage including the scene with his mom...
from a live chat over at cinecon tonight
"Quote:
Originally Posted by OutlawRonin
Hi my name is Jason and I'm from California. Mr. Rodriguez, I was just wondering if you could tell me a little about the added footage that was put into the extended cut of Sin City. EX: which stories have added footage, which characters are shown in the added footage, and also why you chose to make an extended cut of the film. Thank you for your time.
Hey everybody! Rodriguez here... typing in from Troublemaker Studios...
The new stuff that was put back in amounts to a total of about 24 minutes. Marv episode probably has the most new footage including the scene with his mom...
from a live chat over at cinecon tonight
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Canada, BC
Posts: 6,691
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mikewendt
I skiped the original... So I'm picking this up either way...
#13
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by Cameron
they premiered this at a film festival in austin a few months back. It has over twenty minutes worth of new footage.
really....you can stop freaking out.
really....you can stop freaking out.
As far as not being able to watch the segments together as one long film...there aren't credits following each sequence. There might be additional credits at the end of the entire film, but the only notation from sequence to sequence were the title screens.
-JP
#15
Member
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 108
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by gOoBaLL
Clearly states 'over 20 minutes of additional footage' (as opposed to 4 minutes of footage and 19 minutes of credits; credits which I'm sure most don't consider to be footage).
#16
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 1,141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by whynotsmile
nah its bullshit. From Rodriguez himself
"Quote:
... Rodriguez here... The new stuff that was put back in amounts to a total of about 24 minutes. Marv episode probably has the most new footage including the scene with his mom...
from a live chat over at cinecon tonight
"Quote:
... Rodriguez here... The new stuff that was put back in amounts to a total of about 24 minutes. Marv episode probably has the most new footage including the scene with his mom...
from a live chat over at cinecon tonight
That said, I will pick this up since I skipped the barebones version, but I am curious to see by how much scenes were extended versus credits.
#18
Retired
Originally Posted by mikewendt
I skiped the original... So I'm picking this up either way...
#19
I only watched two of the episodes but the new footage I did see didn't amount to that much in terms of screen time. Like someone else said, Marv visiting his mom didn't last that long. What did last long were the credits at the end of each of the four(?) chapters.
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: B-More
Posts: 676
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Trippin315
I jut took a look at both of my versions of Sin City and there is close to 23 minutes of additional footage. It is not in the titles or in the credits. I got an advanced copy.
#23
Originally Posted by dvdman47
But when you read the runtime of a film on the back of the case, that is from hitting the play button to the end of the credits...right?
#24
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Something to consider: most films have at least 90 or 100 scenes. Most film scenes are at most a couple of minutes long. Think of how much is added to a film like LOTR:FOTR that is already 3 hours long and has ~20~ minutes of additional footage inserted. You guys may be in for a harsh surprise.