DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   The DVDTalk DVD Draft Game (2nd Edition) - SIGN UP NOW!!! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/439069-dvdtalk-dvd-draft-game-2nd-edition-sign-up-now.html)

arsmith7 10-03-05 10:55 AM

City of God

illennium 10-03-05 11:00 AM

7. Strangers on a Train: 2-Disc Special Edition

The Ferret 10-03-05 11:01 AM


Originally Posted by illennium
7. Strangers on a Train: 2-Disc Special Edition

Already included in one of the box sets chosen (doesn't that make it invalid?). I was going to pick it myself.

The Ferret 10-03-05 11:02 AM

7. Looney Tunes Golden Collection V.1

illennium 10-03-05 11:09 AM


Originally Posted by The Ferret
Already included in one of the box sets chosen (doesn't that make it invalid?). I was going to pick it myself.

There's no rule against it. The LOTR EE box set was taken as a first-round pick, and then someone else was allowed to take one of the EE's in a later round.

darkhawk 10-03-05 11:20 AM

7. There's Something About Mary (2-disk Special Edition)

Atreus 10-03-05 11:21 AM

I would argue that since the Music Videos are the only aspect of the set that it is specifically a TV release and they are only one part of the release. It has more documentary and short film footage then videos. Plus the rules state one Television season (or miniseries) I don't think a disc should be classified as television simply because some of the content was aired on TV. If that were the case would Franchot's selection of the Casablanca 2 disc set be considered a TV selection since it contains two television episodes (the Looney Toons Sketch and the Premiere Episode of Who Holds Tommorrow?)

Just pleading my case.

ryuryu2949 10-03-05 11:23 AM


Originally Posted by arsmith7
City of God

Nice pick. I could have sworn that was already picked a lot earlier, and that was the only reason I did not swipe it. Kudos.

The Ferret 10-03-05 11:26 AM


Originally Posted by illennium
There's no rule against it. The LOTR EE box set was taken as a first-round pick, and then someone else was allowed to take one of the EE's in a later round.

Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn. What about my Looney Tunes pick, TV right?

Franchot 10-03-05 11:30 AM

7. The Godfather--Part II

jfrost 10-03-05 11:36 AM


Originally Posted by Atreus
7. Director's Label, Vol. 1 - The Work of Director Spike Jonze

Tough call... but I will let it stand as a standard release.

jfrost 10-03-05 11:37 AM


Originally Posted by The Ferret
Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn. What about my Looney Tunes pick, TV right?

Yeah... I think TV works.

Damfino 10-03-05 11:48 AM

7. Saving Private Ryan (WW II Edition)

kylerayner 10-03-05 12:05 PM

Bringing Up Baby - Special Edition

Nesbit 10-03-05 12:10 PM

Chinatown

das Monkey 10-03-05 12:17 PM

<b>The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie</b> (CC)

das

ViewAskewbian 10-03-05 02:28 PM

7. Halloween (25th Anniversary Edition Divimax)

In the spirit of the season. :)

mdc3000 10-03-05 03:20 PM

7. The Royal Tenenbaums (CC)

MATT

arsmith7 10-03-05 03:40 PM


Originally Posted by ryuryu2949
Nice pick. I could have sworn that was already picked a lot earlier, and that was the only reason I did not swipe it. Kudos.

Thanks, but I'm sure I led to your confusion. I picked it during round 3 and then changed after they announced that changing picks in round would be allowed. Oops ;)

Kocheese99 10-03-05 04:07 PM

Pick 7: Spirited Away: 2-disk

exharrison 10-03-05 04:11 PM

12 Angry Men

Cathepsin 10-03-05 04:57 PM

7 - Ghostbusters: Special Edition

(not the 2-pack with GB2)

chemosh6969 10-03-05 09:59 PM

7. Downfall

Sweet Baby James 10-04-05 09:55 AM

So I wonder how many contestants have Cinderella typed out and ready to submit.:)

Count de Monet 10-04-05 09:56 AM

Not me.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:07 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.