DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Which Superbits are worth it and which ones aren't? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/435285-superbits-worth-ones-arent.html)

Toka 08-24-05 02:40 PM

Oops! Yep, the UE. Same difference. :)

buckee1 08-24-05 02:48 PM

I've seen a very noticible difference in Air Force One, Dracula, Fifth Element & BLack Hawk Down. The images are deifinately sharper and cleaner than their non-SB counterparts.

exharrison 08-24-05 03:11 PM


Originally Posted by Toka
Oops! Yep, the UE. Same difference. :)

Its all good. I just wanted to make sure that I wasn't falling behind on my fifth element.

Giles 08-24-05 05:40 PM

How's the SB of The Dark Crystal I was thinking of buying at Best Buy for 9.99

bboisvert 08-24-05 06:17 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
How's the SB of The Dark Crystal I was thinking of buying at Best Buy for 9.99

The image looks identical to the previous editions (the first one and the one in the big box with the goodies).

It adds a DTS track, but it sounds no different from the DD track.


In short, don't bother. You're giving up a great hour-long documentary, deleted scene, trailers, and other stuff and getting nothing in return.

visitor Q 08-24-05 07:13 PM

Any comments on the Black Hawk Down DTS track? I have the standard R1 1 disk release and the DD5.1 track is extremely well done. Then again .. for 10$ :)

Big Worms 08-24-05 08:39 PM


Originally Posted by visitor Q
Any comments on the Black Hawk Down DTS track? I have the standard R1 1 disk release and the DD5.1 track is extremely well done. Then again .. for 10$ :)

I just bought it and haven't had a chance to watch it. But I own the 3 Disc CE set and now the Superbit. I read this review and then went out to get it.
http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=11094

Egon's Ghost 08-25-05 01:06 AM

Having watched the Desperado/El Mariachi disc, I certainly hope that the Superbit corrected the image of Desperado. Colors and fleshtones were off. I'm glad there's now a price drop; the original price was steep, and it begs the question, at least in the case of Desperado: why couldn't they just get it right the first time?

eau 08-25-05 02:08 AM

How about Cliffhanger and Vertical Limits? I recall there were reports of them having good improvement over the regular version. Is it true?

mzupeman2 08-25-05 04:56 AM

I was debating getting Hook but I think I'll pass. I may pick up Cliffhanger though if the film quality is supposed to be much improved.

wm lopez 08-25-05 06:22 AM

I wonder if we will ever see a CLOSE ENCOUNTERS OF THE 3RD KIND Superbit.

Giles 08-25-05 06:36 AM


Originally Posted by wm lopez
I wonder if we will ever see a CLOSE ENCOUNTERS OF THE 3RD KIND Superbit.

Japan did ;)

Doug Schiller 08-25-05 01:08 PM

I think this sale should tell you not to expect any double dip SuperBits anymore. Are there anymore on the horizon except for the new release marketing angle (i.e. Brown Bunny)?

I own Dracula (nice improvement, same dated transfer), Mark of Zorro (nothing to compare it to), SpiderMan2 (I noticed a difference) and Lawrence of Arabia (haven't watched).

I was going to pick up Das Boot but heard they also used the same dated transfer. Removing annoying MPEG artifacts is nice but is it worth another $10?

cleaver 08-25-05 01:20 PM

This thread convinced me to get Bad Boys, but it seems split on Labyrinth. What's the consensus on Labyrinth?

Big Worms 08-25-05 01:59 PM


Originally Posted by cleaver
This thread convinced me to get Bad Boys, but it seems split on Labyrinth. What's the consensus on Labyrinth?

Get the CE.

Skyler 08-25-05 04:38 PM

IMO, Starship Troopers is the best looking SB, with Hollow Man being a close second.

CrashNBurn69 08-26-05 02:07 AM

any opinions on bad boys 2. are the extras from the 2 disc worth getting that version instead?

fryinpan1 08-26-05 05:50 AM


Originally Posted by CrashNBurn69
any opinions on bad boys 2. are the extras from the 2 disc worth getting that version instead?

I would get the regular edition unless you really want the DTS from the Superbit. The transfer is already great and the film is on disc 1 and the extras (Seven deleted scenes, Stunts and visual effects featurettes, Six sequence breakdowns, including on-the-set footage, storyboards, and scripts, 19 production diary featurettes) are on disc 2.

Michael Corvin 08-26-05 06:22 AM


Originally Posted by Egon's Ghost
Having watched the Desperado/El Mariachi disc, I certainly hope that the Superbit corrected the image of Desperado. Colors and fleshtones were off. I'm glad there's now a price drop; the original price was steep, and it begs the question, at least in the case of Desperado: why couldn't they just get it right the first time?

Desperado looks amazing. Pick it up. I used to have the combo set you are talking about.

reverie 08-26-05 07:00 AM

I haven't watched it yet, but the 'Mask of Zorro's second disc has in big letters on it "full screen". I'm assuming this is correct, that the bonus disc was always this? Just curious since it's usually not on there like so. Also purely out of curiousity, is that just the same disc from the old set put into there?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:56 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.