Rodriguez talks Sin City DVD...
#26
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 10,059
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Cincinnati, OH
Wow, I think I started drooling just from reading the transcript. I don't think that I've ever wanted a DVD so much without even watching the movie yet. Rodriguez has to be on the best directors in terms of DVD content.
#27
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 573
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: State of Confusion
"How can you in one breath call the Spy Kids movies "crap" and then in the next one say you respect them for what they are. Just because something wasn't up your alley stylewise or content-wise, doesn't mean they are crap."
While it's great that he's branched out to different genres of film, the Spy Kids series just didn't seem to work on his usual level.
If comparing it to Lucas' work, i think RR's Spy Kids series is his Phantom Menace (all style, no substance). To me, it was a step sideways in his learning process. He learned how to hone his special effects work, but the story and characters were weak.
Even taking into account that it IS a kids movie. I think it was more a lesson on "how to" more than growing as a writer and being able to flesh out interesting characters and story. THAT'S why i called it crap, but admirable crap. In 20 years, I'm sure no one will remember those characters, but they WILL remember the achievement that he made.
make sense?
And if you want to argue the "kids movie" genre, my generation (I'm 31) will ALWAYS remember movies like The Goonies. Why? Because it had great special effects, great characters, great story ...AND it was a kids movie that adults could ALSO enjoy. I just did not enjoy the movies (which I'm sure alot of people will agree with me on). I'm taking into account that RR is a "Jack of all trades, Master of none" philosophy in that he's not a "great" writer, but Spy Kids wasn't as evenly balanced as his other films.
(Budget be damned) I just thought that RR could have done a little more to the Spy Kids movies to give them some oomph writing wise (and pacing ...they seemed to drag on). But, I'm sure he was more focused on learning how to deal with the special effects process to REALLY notice.
While it's great that he's branched out to different genres of film, the Spy Kids series just didn't seem to work on his usual level.
If comparing it to Lucas' work, i think RR's Spy Kids series is his Phantom Menace (all style, no substance). To me, it was a step sideways in his learning process. He learned how to hone his special effects work, but the story and characters were weak.
Even taking into account that it IS a kids movie. I think it was more a lesson on "how to" more than growing as a writer and being able to flesh out interesting characters and story. THAT'S why i called it crap, but admirable crap. In 20 years, I'm sure no one will remember those characters, but they WILL remember the achievement that he made.
make sense?
And if you want to argue the "kids movie" genre, my generation (I'm 31) will ALWAYS remember movies like The Goonies. Why? Because it had great special effects, great characters, great story ...AND it was a kids movie that adults could ALSO enjoy. I just did not enjoy the movies (which I'm sure alot of people will agree with me on). I'm taking into account that RR is a "Jack of all trades, Master of none" philosophy in that he's not a "great" writer, but Spy Kids wasn't as evenly balanced as his other films.
(Budget be damned) I just thought that RR could have done a little more to the Spy Kids movies to give them some oomph writing wise (and pacing ...they seemed to drag on). But, I'm sure he was more focused on learning how to deal with the special effects process to REALLY notice.
#29
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 2,730
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Las Vegas, NV
Originally Posted by Mike Lowrey
I gotta admit, Robert Rodriguez has got to be the coolest director/film maker I know. He's got that, "Hey, I'm just your ordinary cheap independant filmmaker that happens to get his work on the big screen and I make lots of bucks (and fun) doing so."
Maybe 5 years ago, but his ego has grown much since then. Watching him the other night on the LATE, LATE SHOW made me a little queasy. He's taking the Spielberg route...
#31
DVD Talk Hero
While I'm not the audience for the Spy Kids movies, and will admit to never having seen one, I can appreciate RR's business saavy.
It does provide a good cash cow, and allows him to reinvest the money back into more personal projects. And it's a stroke of brilliance to cast Antonio Banderas in them, to give Mom some eye candy.
It does provide a good cash cow, and allows him to reinvest the money back into more personal projects. And it's a stroke of brilliance to cast Antonio Banderas in them, to give Mom some eye candy.
#32
DVD Talk Hero
And let's not forget that daddy gets Carla Gugino (and Salma Hayek in the sequels).
#34
Member
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Austin, Texas
I'm gonna be lazy and not read this thread, but I was at the regional premiere for Sin City last night and I have some more news about the Sin City DVD. While there he had microphones set up around the theatre, he was recording the audience. So, on the DVD there will be an audio option to watch the movie with an "audience." I think its a pretty cool idea, and the audience was great. So...look for that.
#37
DVD Talk Hero
Gee, too bad the dvd couldn't also replicate the experience of some asshat kicking the back of your seat.
#38
Senior Member
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 746
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Oregon
Originally Posted by majorjoe23
I like the idea of being able to watch them seperately, but I would also like to see one long cut.
#40
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 18,537
Received 444 Likes
on
313 Posts
From: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Originally Posted by Cameron
for sure....
Ghost World and American Splendor come to mind though
Ghost World and American Splendor come to mind though




