View Poll Results: What did you think was the best DVD of March 2005?
Apollo 13 (10th Anniversary Edition)
3
2.04%
Bambi (Disney Special Platinum Edition)
15
10.20%
Finding Neverland
2
1.36%
Incredibles (Collector's Edition)
94
63.95%
Laura
3
2.04%
Orgazmo (Unrated Special Edition)
5
3.40%
Star Trek - First Contact (Collector's Edition)
5
3.40%
Star Wars - Clone Wars - Vol. 1 (Animated)
1
0.68%
Twilight Zone - Season 2 (Definitive Collection)
4
2.72%
Other (post your choice below)
15
10.20%
Voters: 147. You may not vote on this poll
Best DVD of March 2005
03-31-05 | 12:18 PM
#26
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,278
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hawaii
Originally Posted by Sessa17
How on earth is Kagemusha: Criterion Collection not in that poll? This thread should be called "best mainstream DVD" or "Favorite" DVD of March since its impossible for people to pic the "best" without buying literally every DVD that comes out.
Kagemusha gets my vote by a mile.
Kagemusha gets my vote by a mile.
However:
No, 'Best DVD of March' is a perfect title. I own Kagemusha, and the Incredibles is better.
If one were to use you logic {since its impossible for people to pic the "best" without buying literally every DVD that comes out} there would be no "best" of anything lists.
If you want Kagemusha to win a poll; you could start "March's Best Obscure Film". It would get my vote.
03-31-05 | 12:34 PM
#27
Is Kagemusha really that obscure? I always assumed it was quite well known.
03-31-05 | 01:59 PM
#30
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I haven't viewed everything in the "Kagemusha" set yet, but the transfer is splendid and the booklet with the full color reproductions of Kurosawa's paintings/storyboards is possibly the best Criterion has ever produced.
So, I'm not quite sure how all this will pan out, but so far (1) L'eclisse (2) Kagemusha (3) The Incredibles
So, I'm not quite sure how all this will pan out, but so far (1) L'eclisse (2) Kagemusha (3) The Incredibles
03-31-05 | 09:53 PM
#31
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by wendersfan
Is Kagemusha really that obscure? I always assumed it was quite well known.
I never heard of it until this thread (and still don't know what it is).
Stew
. I really cannot choose.
04-01-05 | 12:48 AM
#38
DVD Talk Special Edition
My vote goes to Warner's Classic Comedies Collection, which contains four of my all-time favorite films...Bringing Up Baby; The Philadelphia Story; Libeled Lady; and To Be or Not to Be...and the other two films in the set aren't too shabby, either.
04-01-05 | 10:47 AM
#42
DVD Talk Legend
The Incredbiles...it's not the best movie of the lot, but it's by far the best made DVD.
