DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Battlestar Galactica...when? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/412472-battlestar-galactica-when.html)

Mike Lowrey 07-04-05 07:09 PM

TVShowsOnDVD has the first shot of the R1 cover-art.

It's small...the smallest ever, but looks like it's a port of the R2 UK version without the UK rating thingy.

Patrick Mirza 07-20-05 08:20 AM

Universal Studios has officially announced Battlestar Galactica: Season One for release on September 20th.

The five-disc set will include the already-available pilot mini-series and subsequent thirteen episodes in 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen, along with Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks. Bonus materials will include commentary tracks on the mini-series and nine episodes (33, Bastille Day, Act of Contrition, You Can't Go Home Again, Tigh Me Up Tigh Me Down, The Hand of God, Colonial Day and Kobol's Last Gleaming Parts 1 & 2), deleted scenes, behind-the-scenes footage, "Battlestar Galactica: The Lowdown" featurette, sketches and artwork.

The set will also include one of three collectible DVD exclusive trading cards. Retail is $59.98.

http://www.davisdvd.com/images/cover...rgalactica.jpg

nemein 07-20-05 08:27 AM


The five-disc set will include the already-available pilot mini-series
:up:

pilot 07-20-05 08:36 AM


Originally Posted by nemein
:up:

boo..I already bought it a few months ago :p (bad for those who already have, good for those who don't) but won't stop me from getting the complete season..

tvshowsondvd.com has some expanded info ...


We've reported about the Battlestar Galactica (2004) DVD situation, and how next Tuesday there will be a Best Buy exclusive release of the "U.K. version" of the show (mainly featuring a different sequence for the opening credits). Best Buy's 4-disc exclusive set (currently selling at $48.95) runs through September, and then Universal will bring the show out on DVD for other retailers.

Universal has announced their "all retailers" release this morning, and as you can see on the left, the cover is noticably different than the box which Best Buy has been depicting. The release is set for September 20th, and the SRP is $59.98 (which means you'll be able to purchase it anywhere from $40 to $55, after retail discounts are applied). The running time is 757 minutes for a 5-DVD package (one more than the Best Buy set), including the 2003 mini-series on the first disc, and there are many extras. Here's a list of them, copied from Universal's release information:

Commentary Tracks:
Feature Commentary on "The Mini-Series" with Director Michael Rymer and Executive Producers David Eick and Ron Moore
"Pilot" Commentary with Director Michael Rymer and Executive Producers David Eick and Ronald D. Moore
"Bastille Day" Episode Commentary with Executive Producers David Eick and Ronald D. Moore
"Act of Contrition" Episode Commentary with Executive Producers David Eick and Ronald D. Moore
"You Can't Go Home Again" Episode Commentary with Executive Producers David Eick and Ronald D. Moore
"Tigh Me Up, Tigh Me Down" Episode Commentary with Executive Producer Ronald D. Moore
"The Hand of God" Episode Commentary with Executive Producer Ronald D. Moore
"Colonial Day" Episode Commentary with Executive Producer Ronald D. Moore
"Kobol's Last Gleaming: Part 1" Episode Commentary with Executive Producer Ronald D. Moore
"Kobol's Last Gleaming: Part 2" Episode Commentary with Executive Producer Ronald D. Moore
Behind the Scenes
Deleted Scenes
Battlestar Galactica Series Lowdown
Sketches and Art

An added bonus item listed is "1 of 3 Collectible DVD Exclusive Trading Cards"; we're not sure yet what these are trading cards of, or how someone would obtain the other thwo cards in the set. We'll look into it, and let you know what we find out. Video is shown as " Anamorphic Widescreen (1.78:1)", and sound is shown to be "English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround". English and Spanish subtitles are on board as well.
since moore was the only one on the podcasts, I guess the commentary tracks on (Tigh Me Up Tigh Me Down, The Hand of God, Colonial Day and Kobol's Last Gleaming Parts 1 & 2) are the podcasts but that's just a guess by me..probably the same commentary on the mini series as was on the original dvd as well..

I don't think ANYBODY should bother getting this at bestbuy, it'll show Universal that these "exclusive" releases are completely useless (especially since it's a completely different release..if they were smart, they would use the better of the two for their exclusive time period but why would they do something smart?) ...I hope people who aren't as well informed as dvdtalkers don't go and buy the bestbuy exclusive one, then find out there's a new, better release 2 months later and pick up that one too because they're a big fan..

nemein 07-20-05 08:50 AM


I don't think ANYBODY should bother getting this at bestbuy, it'll show Universal that these "exclusive" releases are completely useless
If anything I think the dual release w/ different content is going to garner more resentment against Universal than BB. I can see studios and retailers getting together for exclusive releases and quite frankly that's neither here nor there for me, but this form of double dip makes no sense whatsoever...


Also quite frankly at that price I think I'll wait for the next DDD sale, when is that BTW -ptth-

cajun_junky 07-20-05 08:55 AM

Great news and with the extra disc (not included with the best buy set) it is definitely worth the wait. I can't decide which cover I like best but this one is not bad. Wish there was a larger picture but I am sure that will come soon.

Here is a nice link to universal website with more info. LINKY

pilot 07-20-05 09:22 AM


Originally Posted by nemein
Also quite frankly at that price I think I'll wait for the next DDD sale, when is that BTW -ptth-

never again, EVER :p

Cartload 07-20-05 10:09 AM

This is great news. I'm glad I held out from buying the miniseries and I'll have no problem not going to best buy for their "exclusive" release.

Paul Arnette 07-20-05 10:30 AM


If anything I think the dual release w/ different content is going to garner more resentment against Universal than BB.
I'm sorry, but could someone please tell me what the differences are between these two sets apart from, possibly, a different intro and the inclusion of the mini-series? I couldn't find any details on the UK version on either Amazon UK or Best Buy's site. A side-by-side comparison would be great, if possible.

Thanks a lot.

pilot 07-20-05 11:09 AM


Originally Posted by Paul Arnette
I'm sorry, but could someone please tell me what the differences are between these two sets apart from, possibly, a different intro and the inclusion of the mini-series? I couldn't find any details on the UK version on either Amazon UK or Best Buy's site. A side-by-side comparison would be great, if possible.

Thanks a lot.

the bestbuy version will just be the episodes, and I think deleted scenes. nothing else...the episodes will have the alternate intro, probably no mini series, no commentaries, no other extras etc...

cajun_junky 07-20-05 12:10 PM


Originally Posted by Cartload
This is great news. I'm glad I held out from buying the miniseries and I'll have no problem not going to best buy for their "exclusive" release.

I was extremely happy about the miniseries being included. I came so close to picking it up at CH but kept thinking they might include it.

milo bloom 07-20-05 01:48 PM

I've been waffling on the mini-series for some time. Very glad I held off.

chamfer 07-20-05 02:24 PM

This is great news, I had been wondering if Universal was even going to say anything before the 26th came around. I think it's really stupid that the sets are different as it will only confuse people. Plus I wonder what BestBuy will do with the extra sets come september.... They will have an exclusive boxset that no one will want.

So this new release will have the miniseries on one disc but the current release spreads it out on to two discs. If they could have fit it on one, why didn't they do that from the beginning?

Paul Arnette 07-20-05 02:47 PM


So this new release will have the miniseries on one disc but the current release spreads it out on to two discs. If they could have fit it on one, why didn't they do that from the beginning?
IIRC, the current Battlestar Galactica mini-series is not spread out over two discs, but one. Additionally, the picture quality of the initial release leaves a lot to be desired. One could hope that Univeral will correct these PQ issues on the Season One release, but I'm not holding my breath.

chamfer 07-20-05 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by Paul Arnette
IIRC, the current Battlestar Galactica mini-series is not spread out over two discs, but one.

Mine is two discs.....

Mike Lowrey 07-20-05 04:03 PM


Originally Posted by chamfer
Mine is two discs.....

Yes, but the other disc is just the few extras that appeared on the second side of the one-disc version.

That said, WTF am I going to do with my mini-series disc now??? Sell it to the poor blokes who are going to buy the Best Buy Exclusive I guess. :lol:

Mike Lowrey 07-20-05 04:08 PM


Originally Posted by Paul Arnette
IIRC, the current Battlestar Galactica mini-series is not spread out over two discs, but one. Additionally, the picture quality of the initial release leaves a lot to be desired. One could hope that Univeral will correct these PQ issues on the Season One release, but I'm not holding my breath.

Yeah, it was a bit grainy for such a new release. Wonder how they're going to handle the inclusion of the mini on this new set. It was only about 3 hours long wasn't it? PQ shouldn't suffer on that much material on a DVD-9/18.

boredsilly 07-20-05 04:12 PM

Yeah, this exclusive store stuff is for the birds. You know what would set this practice straight? Is if no other retailer carried the set if it was an exclusive at bestbuy first(like that would happen). Universal would kill this practice quick though. This is also happening with Space Above and Beyond which is another title I'm really looking forward to.

About the set itself, I'm really excited about it. I love a set with a wealth of comms on it and this one doesn't look like it will let me down a bit. The only bad thing I can see is that no actors are on the comms. However, producers and directors usually give more valuable information anyways on the comm so it's not all bad (they just usually aren't as fun).

trammel 07-20-05 04:34 PM

If the Best Buy discs were made using the UK PAL masters will they suffer from PAL speed-up?

Mike Lowrey 07-20-05 05:36 PM


Originally Posted by trammel
If the Best Buy discs were made using the UK PAL masters will they suffer from PAL speed-up?

Probably, but who knows. Supposedly the new Masters of the Universe releases were done using restored PAL masters and they'll suffer from the 2-3% speed-up.

But in any case, looks like waiting for the offfical R1 release will be the only way to go.

rdclark 07-20-05 06:32 PM

Well, I was sure the mini would not be included, so I was wrong about that. Let's see if there's a "proof of purchase" rebate for people who already bought the mini, which was not exactly bargain priced itself. I think $10 would be appropriate, $5 more likely, and $0 most likely of all.

Not happy *at all* about the way these releases have been handled.

RichC

Mike Lowrey 07-20-05 08:52 PM


Originally Posted by rdclark
Well, I was sure the mini would not be included, so I was wrong about that. Let's see if there's a "proof of purchase" rebate for people who already bought the mini, which was not exactly bargain priced itself. I think $10 would be appropriate, $5 more likely, and $0 most likely of all.

Not happy *at all* about the way these releases have been handled.

RichC

Agreed. However, at least it'll be a 5-disc set, which means that they won't be double-sided discs, and we'll get disc art.

mifuneral 07-20-05 09:31 PM

So it's confirmed that there is no commentary on the Best Buy exclusive set?

If so, that's very disappointing and there will be no purchase from me (even though I had planned on getting it).

The "all-retailers" version does sound good but I'm still pissed that I basically have to rebuy the mini.

Mhepburn20 07-20-05 09:42 PM


Originally Posted by mifuneral
So it's confirmed that there is no commentary on the Best Buy exclusive set?

If so, that's very disappointing and there will be no purchase from me (even though I had planned on getting it).

The "all-retailers" version does sound good but I'm still pissed that I basically have to rebuy the mini.

It's not confirmed but the UK edition only had the deleted scenes. I'm a bit ticked about having to buy the mini-series again as well. They really should include a rebate. Should, but won't.

D.Zero 07-21-05 12:50 AM

Still don't know why they'd include the mini-series but they did, so I was wrong as well. Nice package for the season one. I still think these retailer exclusives suck and I'd think Universal would want their best package out in as many hands as possible a couple of weeks ago in advance of season 2 but what do I know?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:32 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.