Legendary deleted 'Pie-Fight' scene from "Dr Strangelove" DVD question.
#1
Moderator
Thread Starter
Legendary deleted 'Pie-Fight' scene from "Dr Strangelove" DVD question.
Does the DVD special edition of "Dr. Strangelove" detail or talk about this deleted scene? I was curious since I have read about it in the past and would like to know more about this alternate ending.
#3
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by ShagMan
it talks about it a whole bunch, and there's some clips of it during one of the documentaries.
It is discussed in detail for a few minutes. They note that George C. Scott's character remarks, after the President has been hit with a pie, that "our president's been cut down in his prime!", which was probably too much in light of the recent Kennedy assasination (the previous year), and for that and other reasons Kubrick decided not to use the footage.
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,701
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Terry Southern writes about the scene in a book of essays and stories which, I believe, was called [EDIT: I was wrong when I posted this earlier, it was actually "Now Dig This"]. (When Kubrick decided to make 'Strangelove' a comedy, he enlisted Terry Southern as a co-writer, based on a book Peter Sellers had given him a few years earlier; 'The Magic Christian', I think.) Anyway, Southern says that Kubrick hadn't told the actors (mostly extras) to play the pie-fight stone-faced and angry, because the pie fight was supposed to (in some way) represent the ongoing battle for funding between the various wings of the military, and the bad blood between them do to this. Unfortunately, because Kubrick hadn't told them what to do, they played it with a lot of smiles and laughing and whatnot, and the footage was unusable. They couldn't afford to shoot it again, so Kubrick opted not to use it. Since nobody cared for it, and Kubrick didn't bother to save it, the footage is pretty much written off as lost at this point. Even if it were found, it was never cut together and never filmed correctly.
Last edited by ThatGuamGuy; 01-28-05 at 08:49 PM.
#7
DVD Talk Hero
Considering that Kubrick was notorious for filming almost EVERYTHING multiple times until it was absolutely perfect (his shooting ratio was usually around 100:1), I find that story a little uncharacteristic.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
i still think that the estate is holding on to this for some unforseen reason...it has to be around...
would love to see it...used to be a website with pics floating around...more than in the doc, but i can't find it now
would love to see it...used to be a website with pics floating around...more than in the doc, but i can't find it now
#9
DVD Talk Hero
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Hughson, CA
Posts: 5,160
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Numanoid
That's a whole lotta pie....
#12
DVD Talk Legend
'Not long afterward, we began shooting the famous eleven-minute "lost pie fight,"'
Eleven minutes of pie fight? I'm sorry, but after reading that description of the scene I am glad the footage was unusable. I am not even curious to see it as a deleted scene.
Eleven minutes of pie fight? I'm sorry, but after reading that description of the scene I am glad the footage was unusable. I am not even curious to see it as a deleted scene.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,701
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Numanoid
Considering that Kubrick was notorious for filming almost EVERYTHING multiple times until it was absolutely perfect (his shooting ratio was usually around 100:1), I find that story a little uncharacteristic.
When you say "usually", you're actually talking about the second half of his career (and that's being generous, it was really the last few, not even a full half).
Do you have anything to point to which contradicts what Terry Southern describes from the set of 'Strangelove'? Because I've never heard Kubrick express any satisfaction with what was shot of the pie scene either.