Top Gun SE aspect ratio question
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Top Gun SE aspect ratio question
I am watching the Top Gun SE that I got with some X-Mas money and notice that it is in 2:35 . I remember having this movie on VHS widescreen and seem to recall it being 1:85 then.
Any info as to whether or not this is a mistake?
Any info as to whether or not this is a mistake?
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
According to the reviews, it is a new 2:35 transfer. I don't know what this means, as I don't see why they would take a 1:85 movie and make it 2:35 or vice verca.
I guess it was 2:35 originally and the VHS release got it wrong.
I guess it was 2:35 originally and the VHS release got it wrong.
#4
Guest
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Posts: 2,239
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was in WalMart today and itching to buy some DVDs, so after grabbing Star Trek Generations, I spotted Top Gun. But... yeah, you guessed it, full screen only. Sales clerk said that was the only version they got, and it went straight to their middle of the isle bargain rack. He said if I want widescreen, I'd have to go to BB.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Yeah, from what I can tell it's just the 1:85 cropped to 2:35 (with no extra info on the sides). Kinda sucks, but I guess if that's the intended ratio I can live with it.
#6
Senior Member
Top Gun was filmed in Super35 so the ratio is somewhat variable. Theatrically, it was probably 2.35:1. My old laserdisc is around ~2.1:1, which is somewhat closer to the original theatrical release if the VHS is 1.85. Strange though.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
"Top Gun" was shot Super 35 and shown in theaters at 2.35:1. For whatever reason, for the widescreen VHS release the studio chose to open up the mattes a little and present the film at 1.85:1.
#10
Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 90
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was in WalMart today and itching to buy some DVDs, so after grabbing Star Trek Generations, I spotted Top Gun. But... yeah, you guessed it, full screen only. Sales clerk said that was the only version they got,
#11
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Georgia, USA
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Paramount did this with Ferris Bueller's Day Off, too.
The widescreen laserdisc is 1.85:1, despite the film being made for matted 2.35:1 (It's a Super-35 film as well). The DVD gets the 2.35:1 framing right.
The widescreen laserdisc is 1.85:1, despite the film being made for matted 2.35:1 (It's a Super-35 film as well). The DVD gets the 2.35:1 framing right.
#12
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by DavidH
Why would a 2:35 Super 35 still not be shown 2:35 at home? I see this all of the time. Why do they make it some other ratio for home?
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by DavidH
Why would a 2:35 Super 35 still not be shown 2:35 at home? I see this all of the time. Why do they make it some other ratio for home?
Tony Scott at one point felt that way about Top Gun, but reconsidered for the new DVD master.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Dr. DVD
I guess this wouldn't be a good disc to illustrate how you are losing stuff with P&S/full screen discs on a regular TV then?
Star Wars usually works for most people. For example:
http://www.ryanwright.com/ht/oar.shtml
#18
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Top Gun SE aspect ratio question
I recall the film "Bird on a Wire" with Mel Gibson arrived on DVD with packaging that stated 2.35:1 (non-anamorphic, 4:3 format) yet the DVD itself was framed 1.85:1 non-anamorphic 4:3.
I'm guessing, especially back in the 4:3 TV era, that most people found movies that were framed 2.35:1, the picture was far too small even on a "big" 36" set.
The 1.85:1 framing gave the widescreen look without the viewing area being so small.
The same concept is probably why Top Gun is 1.85:1 because people don't like the black bars and 1.78:1 (or 1.85:1) is the new "fullscreen" in the 16:9 era.
Added: Didn't realize this was a nine-year-old thread! I realize Bird on a Wire was also shot on Super35 according to IMDB so the 1.85:1 version may actually show more picture. I haven't compared it to anything.
I'm guessing, especially back in the 4:3 TV era, that most people found movies that were framed 2.35:1, the picture was far too small even on a "big" 36" set.
The 1.85:1 framing gave the widescreen look without the viewing area being so small.
The same concept is probably why Top Gun is 1.85:1 because people don't like the black bars and 1.78:1 (or 1.85:1) is the new "fullscreen" in the 16:9 era.
Added: Didn't realize this was a nine-year-old thread! I realize Bird on a Wire was also shot on Super35 according to IMDB so the 1.85:1 version may actually show more picture. I haven't compared it to anything.
Last edited by orangerunner; 07-09-14 at 03:16 PM.