DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Star Trek: Enterprise packaging (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/398087-star-trek-enterprise-packaging.html)

Mike Lowrey 11-29-04 09:07 PM

Star Trek: Enterprise packaging
 
If you've been to The Digital Bits in the last couple of days (Monday to be exact), you'll see possible R2 packaging for Star Trek: Enterprise. The Bits also say that this packaging is likely for R1 as well.

http://www.thedigitalbits.com/articl...prisedvd01.jpg

http://www.thedigitalbits.com/articl...prisedvd02.jpg

I must say, I don't like it, just as I don't like the TOS packaging either. Why O Why does Paramount think that we like this odd-ball packaging. Yeah, it looks cool all by itself, but try putting them in DVD shelves.

DVD Polizei 11-29-04 09:32 PM

The packaging is definitely out of this world.

milo bloom 11-29-04 09:44 PM

Not nearly as tacky as the TOS boxes.

Rogue588 11-29-04 09:47 PM

If this continues the trend of getting packages half as cool as r2, r3 or r4, i'm ALL for it.

Hell, that box is already more interesting than the show..

Holly E. Ordway 11-29-04 10:08 PM

Re: Star Trek: Enterprise packaging
 

Originally posted by Mike Lowrey
Why O Why does Paramount think that we like this odd-ball packaging. Yeah, it looks cool all by itself, but try putting them in DVD shelves.
Hear, hear! In my opinion, they got the packaging *exactly* right with DS9... why couldn't they have stuck with that style?!?!

Stylish packaging is all very well, but it should be secondary to being 1) easy to access, 2) convenient to store on the shelf, and 3) reasonably slim. Voyager has a pain-in-the-neck slipcover, but once you take that off (or wrestle it back on again) it's great on the other counts. TOS, on the other hand, is just awful awful awful. I mean, the retro look is cute for about 30 seconds, but after that it's just annoying.

At least it looks like Enterprise has full-sized pages for the DVDs, inside the shell, rather than the cheesy CD-sized case for TOS. And it looks a little more sensible to access than TOS. So, kind of like Voyager in terms of accessibility. I guess I can live with that, now that I think about it. It's better than going further down the oddball packaging road of TOS.

Josh-da-man 11-29-04 10:47 PM

So does this mean that TNG and DS9 will be re-released in plastic shells sometime in the not-too-distant future?

Admiral7 11-29-04 10:53 PM

I really like the packaging for Enterprise. I can definitely live with that . . . it's very classy in my opinion.

RoboDad 11-30-04 12:06 AM

Re: Star Trek: Enterprise packaging
 

Originally posted by Mike Lowrey
Why O Why does Paramount think that we like this odd-ball packaging. Yeah, it looks cool all by itself, but try putting them in DVD shelves.
Maybe they think we like it because some of do. Or did that not occur to you?

I like this packaging, just as I like the new TOS season set packaging. And I am not at all crazy about the DS9 packaging. yes, it is slim, but that is all it has going for it. In every other regard, it looks and feels cheap and amateurish.

illennium 11-30-04 12:14 AM


Originally posted by Admiral7
I really like the packaging for Enterprise. I can definitely live with that . . . it's very classy in my opinion.
Geek chic is not the same as class. Class involves some measure of simplicity and subtlety, which this packaging lacks.

Dazed 11-30-04 01:05 AM

I think it looks quite nice. Cant think of a reason id buy it though (at least not until I finish off the other trek shows, which given their outrageous pricing policy could take a long time ;) )

emhello 11-30-04 01:19 AM

Won't look good on a shelf with other DVDs that's for sure.

duz 11-30-04 02:50 AM

Tentative release dates if you were wondering:

- Season 1: May 3, 2005
- Season 2: July 12, 2005
- Season 3: September 6, 2005
- Season 4: November 1, 2005

Season 4 has been great so far (sans one episode)

ShagMan 11-30-04 07:54 AM

if the packaging doesn't suit you, take the digipack or whatever, OUT of the plastic shell, and put that on your shelf. Now, everybody's happy :)

reverie 11-30-04 08:00 AM

I know everyone praises DS9's boxes, but I'm not too thrilled with them. They seem that over the years with wear and tear that the plastic flaps will just fall off. Voyager sucks too. Why don't they just do something simple but effective, like Firefly's set?

lumberjack 11-30-04 09:37 AM

I imagine Paramount does this packaging to justify the ridiculous price point. That being said, I can't wait to be gouged!

Admiral7 12-01-04 11:02 PM

illennium, I'm very sorry if the packaging is too complicated for you. I fail to see what is unsimple and unsubtle about this set. While I don't like outrageous packaging (not crazy at all about any of the Star Trek season sets to date, I like this one a lot. If you don't, that's you.

Mike Lowrey 12-02-04 10:22 PM


Originally posted by Admiral7
illennium, I'm very sorry if the packaging is too complicated for you. I fail to see what is unsimple and unsubtle about this set. While I don't like outrageous packaging (not crazy at all about any of the Star Trek season sets to date, I like this one a lot. If you don't, that's you.
Well, the main issue with packaging like this, is they basically lack the common title spines.

Take a close look at the packaging here. When putting them on the shelf, how do you tell what is what? By season I mean. In the end (of 2005) one could have all four of these and have non-descript spines, so-to-speak. I know R2 & R4 has had unique packaging for all of its Trek releases, but I don't care for them just for the reason I stated above.

Admiral7 12-03-04 10:06 AM

Mike, I'm not so sure you can tell from that picture of the packaging that there is no spine title.

buckee1 12-03-04 11:02 AM


Originally posted by duz
Tentative release dates if you were wondering:

- Season 1: May 3, 2005
- Season 2: July 12, 2005
- Season 3: September 6, 2005
- Season 4: November 1, 2005

Season 4 has been great so far (sans one episode)

Looks like Sept. & November for me and while I'm not crazy about the packaging, it's not the worst thing in the world. It will look good next to my DS9,VOY & TOS box sets!

VicVegaMRBLOND 12-03-04 03:15 PM

I really hate the opening theme for this show ...

Shannon Nutt 12-03-04 03:35 PM


Originally posted by Admiral7
I really like the packaging for Enterprise. I can definitely live with that . . . it's very classy in my opinion.
I agree 100%. It looks really nice.

cardaway 12-03-04 04:18 PM

See the slits on the spine of the outer case. I'm betting those are to allow viewing of the inner case which will have the season number in small print. The TOS cases use this system.

Jason 12-03-04 04:37 PM

Does it come with the giant action figure of Archer that's in the picture?

Buck Turgidson 12-04-04 04:39 AM

Re: Re: Star Trek: Enterprise packaging
 

Originally posted by Holly E. Ordway
Hear, hear! In my opinion, they got the packaging *exactly* right with DS9... why couldn't they have stuck with that style?!?!
Agreed.




<s>This series should come in replica colostomy bags.</s>

no threadcrap please.

odisn 12-06-04 03:23 PM


Originally Posted by Buck Turgidson
Agreed.




This series should come in replica colostomy bags.


Gee, thanks for stopping by... :crap:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:01 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.