|
Originally posted by Johnny Zhivago Andy has "movie x" because Andy likes it. Kate has "movie y" because Kate likes it. There is no better, it's a matter of personal taste. |
i want my .20 secs back, neither wins cause neither has a "collection" thats more of an assortment.
|
Originally posted by evitagen Actually, Andy has more Y movies and Kate has more X movies. |
Your sister has BIG DADDY. :up:
You don't. :down: |
Originally posted by B.A. Your sister has BIG DADDY. :up: You don't. :down: |
Let's see here....
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 +5 Kill Bill Vol 2 +5 Pulp Fiction +5 Reservoir Dogs +4 Bowling for Columbine -15 Road Trip 0 Scarface 0 American Pie 1 +1 American Pie 2 +1 American Pie 3 -6 Donnie Darko +4 One Hour Photo +2 Trainspotting +4 Fight Club +3 Shawshank Redemption +5 total: 18 points Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful +1 Big Daddy -2 American Pie 2 +2 Mean Girls +4 The Day After Tomorrow -3 Top Gun +3 How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days -5 Pirates of the Caribbean +6 Bridget Jones Diary 0 Shrek 2 0 Don't Say A Word -3 About A Boy +4 Jumanji -5 Signs +2 Vertical Limit +1 (for visuals and sound) total: 5 points Do not question the science that went into this calculation, it would be incomprehensible to any pedestrian scholar. ...not even Michael Moore could stop Andy's domination. |
Andy's Collection (good ones only)
Bowling for Columbine American Pie 1 American Pie 2 Fight Club Shawshank Redemption Kate's Collection (good ones only) American Pie 2 Top Gun (and this ones a stretch) Just my opinion :P |
Re: Please Settle My Debate
Andy's Collection
Kill Bill Vol 1 - like Kill Bill Vol 2 - like Pulp Fiction - like Reservoir Dogs - like Bowling for Columbine - never saw Road Trip - overrated Scarface - like American Pie 1 - like American Pie 2 - like American Pie 3 - like Donnie Darko - like One Hour Photo - never saw Trainspotting - never saw Fight Club - like Shawshank Redemption - like Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful - ok Big Daddy - like American Pie 2 - like Mean Girls - never saw The Day After Tomorrow - never saw Top Gun - like How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days - like Pirates of the Caribbean - like Bridget Jones Diary - never saw Shrek 2 - like Don't Say A Word - never saw About A Boy - never saw Jumanji - never saw Signs - like Vertical Limit- never saw Deep Blue Sea - never saw Beetlejuice - like I guess you win, but she's only 15 and i'm partial to a lot of those "guy" movies. |
I like Kate's selection of movies better.
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 - like Kill Bill Vol 2 - like Pulp Fiction - never saw Reservoir Dogs - never saw Bowling for Columbine - never saw Road Trip - it was pretty funny Scarface - never saw American Pie 1 - like American Pie 2 - like American Pie 3 - like Donnie Darko - never saw One Hour Photo - never saw Trainspotting - never saw Fight Club - I thought this was overrated, prefer Mortal Kombat- SERIOUSLY! Shawshank Redemption - never saw Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful - never saw Big Daddy - like American Pie 2 - like Mean Girls - like The Day After Tomorrow - like Top Gun - like How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days - like Pirates of the Caribbean - like Bridget Jones Diary - never saw Shrek 2 - like Don't Say A Word - like About A Boy - never saw Jumanji - like Signs - like Vertical Limit- never saw Deep Blue Sea - never saw Beetlejuice - like Yeah, yeah whatever. I've never seen what some of you might consider the best movies of all time. I'm more into joe-sixpack movies, but I HATE foolscreen. If there's no chance they'd ever try and make a video game or Happy Meal toys about a movie, I've probably never seen it. |
Originally posted by scott1598 why do constantly feel the need to pick on me? it's just wrong... Hey, atleast I acknowledge you. ;) |
Kate has twice as many that I own also so my vote is for Kate.
|
wow tough crowd.
Remember that these 2 are still teenagers. Andy has guy movies Kate has girl movies. I'm a guy so I like Andy's movies. If I was a girl, I'd probably like Kate's movies. Plus, if you like your collection, who really cares what others think? The important thing is that you enjoy it. |
No one likes One Hour Photo???
|
Andy loses because he actually posted this.
Kate wins. |
Re: Please Settle My Debate
On a -2 (Awful/Very Bad) to +2 (Great/Very Good) scale
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 Good +1 Kill Bill Vol 2 Good +1 Pulp Fiction Great +2 Reservoir Dogs Good +1 Bowling for Columbine Good +1 Road Trip Awful -2 Scarface Good +1 American Pie 1 Good +1 American Pie 2 OK +0 American Pie 3 Bad -1 Donnie Darko Good +1 One Hour Photo OK +0 Trainspotting Great +2 Fight Club Great +2 Shawshank Redemption Good +1 Total: 11 points (15 movies) Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful Good +1 Big Daddy Bad -1 American Pie 2 OK +0 Mean Girls OK +0 The Day After Tomorrow OK +0 Top Gun OK +0 How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days Awful -2 Pirates of the Caribbean OK +0 Bridget Jones Diary Good +1 Shrek 2 Good +1 Don't Say A Word Awful -2 About A Boy Very Good +2 Jumanji OK +0 Signs OK +0 Vertical Limit OK +0 Deep Blue Sea OK +0 Beetlejuice Good +1 Total: 1 point (17 movies) Andy wins by a lot. |
With Michael Moore's presence, what would've been a runaway for Andy turns into a squeaker for him, since the only decent movies in Kate's collection were Pirates of the Caribean and Beetlejuice.
|
Re: Please Settle My Debate
As far as rewatchability...
Originally posted by AndyHome Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 Kill Bill Vol 2 Pulp Fiction Reservoir Dogs Scarface American Pie 1 One Hour Photo Trainspotting Fight Club Shawshank Redemption Kate's Collection Top Gun Pirates of the Caribbean Beetlejuice |
Andy's sis wins....
Sorry andy but Bowling for Columbine makes you lose points |
Andy wins (not a very close call, IMO)
|
Originally posted by joltaddict None of the above. |
Poorly designed poll. You didn't include a "they are equally bad" option and a "they are equally great" option. I'd choose "they are equally bad" because, for one, I refuse to vote positively for a DVD collection that includes all three American Pie movies.
Sorry, that's just the way it is in my world. |
Where's the "I dont like either collection" option?
Really, the only movie off both lists that I own is Pirates of the Caribbean, so I guess by default Kate wins - but it's like coming in first at the Special Olympics. Yes, you may have a gold medal, but youre still retarded. (and I'm a 35 year old guy) |
Originally posted by Numanoid Which is exactly why you win. |
I like some of each.....so I'd say it's a tie
|
25/F
Movies I like out of each collection: Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 Kill Bill Vol 2 Pulp Fiction Reservoir Dogs Scarface American Pie 1 American Pie 2 American Pie 3 Donnie Darko One Hour Photo Trainspotting Fight Club Shawshank Redemption Kate's Collection Big Daddy American Pie 2 Mean Girls The Day After Tomorrow- This one was ok Top Gun Pirates of the Caribbean Bridget Jones Diary Shrek 2 Beetlejuice I voted for Andy's Collection |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:58 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.