Q4 (October, November, and December) could be the best quarter ever in regards to amazing DVD releases... but which do you think is the best? Remember, this is the best overall DVD, not the best film.

Past results...

Q3 Results (top 10):

1) Casablanca (Two-Disc Special Edition) - 30 Votes
2) The Lord of the Rings - The Two Towers (Two-Disc) – 28 Votes
3) Scarface (Anniversary Edition) – 25 Votes
4) 24 - Season Two – 18 Votes
5) Daredevil – 12 Votes
6) Sleeping Beauty (Special Edition) – 11 Votes
7) Fargo (Special Edition) – 6 Votes
8T) Chicago – 3 Votes
8T) Family Guy: Volume 2 – 3 Votes
10) Simpsons Season 3 - 2 Votes

Q2 Results (top 10):

1) Black Hawk Down (3-Disc Deluxe Edition) - 51 Votes
2T) Spirited Away – 5 Votes
2T) Die Another Day – 5 Votes
2T) Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets – 5 Votes
5T) Dances With Wolves (Special Edition) – 4 Votes
5T) Terminator 2 (Extreme Edition) – 4 Votes
5T) Led Zeppelin – 4 Votes
8T) 25th Hour – 3 Votes
8T) By Brakhage (Criterion) – 3 Votes
8T) Beatles Anthology - 3 Votes

Q1 Results (top 10):

1) Who Framed Roger Rabbit (Vista Series) - 26 Votes
2) Six Feet Under - The Complete First Season - 16 Votes
3) Stargate (Ultimate Edition) - 12 Votes
4) Futurama - Vol. 1 - 10 Votes
5) Three Colours Trilogy - 9 Votes
6) X-Men 1.5 - 6 Votes
7) Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (Criterion Collection) - 5 Votes
8T) Signs (Vista Series) - 4 Votes
8T) Jonah - A VeggieTales Movie - 4 Votes
10) The Osbournes - The Complete First Season (Uncensored) - 3 Votes

1) Work of Director Michel Gondry
2) Firefly The Complete Series
3) Coupling Season 2
4) Best of Insomniac with Dave Attell Uncensored Vol. 2
5) Work of Director Spike Jonze

(in other words, I voted for "Other")

Are we going by movie or dvd? I dont see how Spirited Away with its lack of extras and edge enhancement could beat out a 4 disc Dances With Wolves or T2 Extreme Edition.

Alien Quad

Alien Quadrilogy. Best DVD of 2003.

The Work of Director Michel Gondry!

Alien Quad by far.

Alien Quadrilogy, hands down.

Once Upon a Time in the West

I don't see how anything could compete with Alien Quadrilogy. It is one of the finest DVD releases ever both in terms of quantity and quality of material. It blows away all competition.

Another vote here for the Alien Quadrilogy

Man, I just realized what a GREAT quarter it was for DVD releases. I'll have to give it to Alien Quadrilogy myself. Two Towers Extended was amazing, but it wasn't as groundbreaking and meticulous as the Quad.

Alien Quad. No other single release or boxed set from this year can match it for quality and the sheer amount of extras it contains.

...and Spike Jonze and Chris Cunningham!

A great trilogy of releases at near bargain prices and more features than Criterions. This was my Christmas gift to me.

It's all about the behemoth that is the Quad.

Alien Quad all the way

I voted Alien Quadrilogy as it is the best DVD release but if the poll was for best DVD release for a single film then LOTR:TT-EE would be the easy winner!

I haven't delved too deeply into the Alien quadrilogy yet so I'm going to have to go with the Fassbinder box which brought some great films to light in beautiful presentations and extras which were presented with a deep appreciation for the director.

Come on guys, Alien Quad is falling behind!

TTT: EE

Gotta go with Alien on this one.

Lord of the Rings: Two Towers Extended Edition

Alien Quadrilogy (If its not the best of Q4 then it sure is the biggest!)

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (Extended Edition)

Alien Quad indeed rocks. but I'll go for The Mondo Cane Collection from BU...because it needs a little love.