DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   Survivor? (USE A QUESTION MARK IF YOU'RE ASKING A QUESTION) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/336410-survivor-use-question-mark-if-youre-asking-question.html)

Amigo 12-18-03 04:53 AM

Survivor
 
Anyone know if they are going to ever release these all on DVD? I know they have highlight DVD's now.. but I want the actual episodes... need to relive the memories! :)

digitalG 12-18-03 05:53 AM

I also would like to know, missed out on a few season's of Survivor already. :(

Yakuza Bengoshi 12-18-03 07:17 AM

I don't know, but I have a question for those interested in this. If they were available on DVD would you rent them or buy? If buy, why?

Amigo 12-18-03 07:32 AM

The question is why not buy them? ;)

gjamesm 12-18-03 08:33 AM

Give me season sets of this and the Amazing Race and I'd pick them up in a second!

Qui Gon Jim 12-18-03 09:08 AM


Originally posted by Yakuza Bengoshi
I don't know, but I have a question for those interested in this. If they were available on DVD would you rent them or buy? If buy, why?
Same reason you buy any movie or TV set. I love Survivor. If you dont "get it" it is tough to explain.

Yakuza Bengoshi 12-18-03 09:16 AM


Originally posted by Qui Gon Jim
Same reason you buy any movie or TV set. I love Survivor. If you dont "get it" it is tough to explain.
I'm sorry if my question came off negatively or as being too vauge. I guess my question, or remark perhaps, is that I never thought of a show like Surivior as being rewatchable (not because of the instrinsic quality of the subject matter, but rather because of the format of the show -- long build up to a big conclusion), and I was looking for some insight into what other people take from it or experience it on successive viewings. I can see how (1) that question could be asked of any show or film, and (2) it can be difficult to answer.

I retract the question.

JuryDuty 12-18-03 10:39 AM

I agree that while I think Survivor is one of the best shows of all time, I don't see much rewatchable value with it.

HOWEVER, I have many friends that want to collect the full sets of this series, so there is certainly a market for it.

I think there's hope since CBS's Big Brother 3 has been released on a full-season DVD.

CaseyB 12-18-03 11:10 AM

I'd love to see this set as well. I haven't watched a full season since the first one since it's up against a show I have to watch each week, but I love the shows I've been able to catch.

I don't think of Survivor as a game show so I think it would certainly be rewatchable. The gorgeous background with the "storyline" make it an easy choice for me.

A few years ago (during the 2nd season) I met Mark Burnett and asked him about a complete season on DVD and he didn't seem too high on it. Hope he changed his mind since then. :) I can't understand why CBS would give us one of the worst seasons of Big Brother (many would argue all the seasons of that show are awful) and not Survivor or Amazing Race.

Amigo 12-18-03 02:17 PM


Originally posted by Yakuza Bengoshi
I'm sorry if my question came off negatively or as being too vauge. I guess my question, or remark perhaps, is that I never thought of a show like Surivior as being rewatchable (not because of the instrinsic quality of the subject matter, but rather because of the format of the show -- long build up to a big conclusion), and I was looking for some insight into what other people take from it or experience it on successive viewings. I can see how (1) that question could be asked of any show or film, and (2) it can be difficult to answer.

I retract the question.

I see what your saying now... well, I can see where your coming from but it's different with Survivor... the show is an epic, you can get very attached to the characters & don't wanna let go & get dissapointed when it's all said & done. That is why I would love to watch them again even tho I already know the outcome of most.

I'm heavily attached to Elizabeth from the second series... she was such a sweetie! :) I would have given anything to be in Roger's place in that series.

Qui Gon Jim 12-18-03 03:34 PM


Originally posted by Yakuza Bengoshi
I'm sorry if my question came off negatively or as being too vauge. I guess my question, or remark perhaps, is that I never thought of a show like Surivior as being rewatchable (not because of the instrinsic quality of the subject matter, but rather because of the format of the show -- long build up to a big conclusion), and I was looking for some insight into what other people take from it or experience it on successive viewings. I can see how (1) that question could be asked of any show or film, and (2) it can be difficult to answer.

I retract the question.

And I am sorry if my reply came off that way. I think they are rewatchable, unlike a regular game show. I would like to see things that I missed the first time. Also, no episodes except the first season have been repeated, so if you missed an episode, you were basically screwed.

Joe Schmoe 12-18-03 03:49 PM

I'm content just watching the highlights from each season, such as the fights and plot twists. I don't need to re-live every moment, especially when I already know the outcome of each challenge. However, CBS stopped releasing the Best of "Survivor" DVDs after season 2. I hope they release more of these instead of full season box sets for those of us who want to save a few bucks.

evenswr 12-18-03 04:58 PM

I would buy every season of Survivor on the release date, if not sooner. Very re-watchable.

Also, I believe this thread should have a question mark at the end of the title. In fact, I recommend this title:

"Survivor...Season Box Sets Ever?"

...as, of course, we've already been given some disappointing "best moments" discs...

Joe Schmoe 12-18-03 05:03 PM


Originally posted by evenswr
...as, of course, we've already been given some disappointing "best moments" discs...
I was happy with them. Perhaps CBS could make everyone happy by releasing more "best of" DVDs along with whole season sets like Warner Bros. did for "Friends."

CaseyB 12-18-03 05:48 PM

We demand Richard Hatch Uncensored!

Qui Gon Jim 12-19-03 06:59 AM

As with any TV show, give us all or give us nothing. Let viewers choose the moments they want to see again. Those Friends discs were a HUGE mistake, and have since been remedied.

Joe Schmoe 12-19-03 10:22 PM


Originally posted by Qui Gon Jim
As with any TV show, give us all or give us nothing. Let viewers choose the moments they want to see again.
Yes, but your way means every buyer has to pay $40-$50 (whatever) for a season box set even if he or she is only interested in key moments. If you don't like the cheap "best of" DVDs, don't buy them. Wait for the season box set instead.

evenswr 12-20-03 05:30 AM


Originally posted by Joe Schmoe
Yes, but your way means every buyer has to pay $40-$50 (whatever) for a season box set even if he or she is only interested in key moments.


Sounds suspiciously like the argument for pan and scan. "I'm just interested in the key moments of the film, I don't need to see every little piece of the screen."


If you don't like the cheap "best of" DVDs, don't buy them. Wait for the season box set instead.
How long am I supposed to wait? They haven't even released a "Best of" DVD for season 3 yet, and we're almost on season 8!

Qui Gon Jim 12-20-03 05:58 AM

.

Yes, but your way means every buyer has to pay $40-$50 (whatever) for a season box set even if he or she is only interested in key moments. If you don't like the cheap "best of" DVDs, don't buy them. Wait for the season box set instead.
Yes but who is to decide what the "best" moments are. This is highly subjective.

Why should I be happy that a studio is putting their resources behind "best of" while making me wait for the whole package. Survivor is like any other show. TV on DVD should be uncut and assembled in season formats released in entirity. I say this about any show there is

Amigo 12-20-03 06:05 AM

I'm all for uncensored versions lol .. especially for the Amazon series. ;)


A few years ago (during the 2nd season) I met Mark Burnett and asked him about a complete season on DVD and he didn't seem too high on it. Hope he changed his mind since then.
Well.. DVD's have grown a lot over the last couple of years... I'm sure he has noticed this.. I bet a LOT of those 25 million that watch it want the full set DVD's.

Joe Schmoe 12-21-03 12:39 PM


Originally posted by evenswr


Sounds suspiciously like the argument for pan and scan.
Nope. I hate pan & scan, but that's a movie issue; "Survivor" is a game show. Big difference, at least IMHO. You want to re-live every moment of "Survivor"? Great. Buy the box sets if they're ever made. And if they ever release more "best of" DVDs, I'll buy those.

evenswr 12-21-03 02:37 PM


Originally posted by Joe Schmoe
Nope. I hate pan & scan, but that's a movie issue.
Joe, why do you hate pan & scan?

Joe Schmoe 12-22-03 12:29 PM


Originally posted by evenswr
Joe, why do you hate pan & scan?
Because it doesn't fit my 16X9 TV screen.

evenswr 12-22-03 01:12 PM


Originally posted by Joe Schmoe
Because it doesn't fit my 16X9 TV screen.
So you must hate this disc:

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0...1.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

retihsuhnt 12-22-03 03:22 PM


Originally posted by gjamesm
Give me season sets of this and the Amazing Race and I'd pick them up in a second!
I remember seeing both Big Brother and an Amazing Race at BB sometime early this year or last.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:35 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.