Chaplin Collection 2
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jul 1999
Posts: 1,891
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York, NY
Chaplin Collection 2
Don't know how this got by everyone. DavisDVD announced the news on Wed:
http://www.davisdvd.com/news/daily_news.html
This one will be a 13 or 14 disc set (not clear on whether the doc will also be two discs). Seems that they would have broken them up more evenly.
I'm excited.
Dan
http://www.davisdvd.com/news/daily_news.html
This one will be a 13 or 14 disc set (not clear on whether the doc will also be two discs). Seems that they would have broken them up more evenly.
I'm excited.
Dan
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,701
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Will 'The Kid', 'A Woman of Paris', and 'A King In New York' have the scenes which were removed from later cuts of the film on the DVD at all? I'm assuming they'll be the final cuts (as with 'Modern Times'), based on what they've said previously, but I'm wondering if pressure from the fans will force them to at least include the scenes as supplementary material (as with, again, 'Modern Times').
I mean, I bought the Image versions of those anyway, and won't be selling them off unless the new releases have those cuts (I may buy the DVDs at some point for the other extras, though; I'm planning to do that with 'Modern Times' but haven't bought it yet), but I was wondering about those.
[Based on the doc TCM showed after 'The Kid' last night -- another "Chaplin Today" doc -- I'd say the scenes are definitely not in the movie itself.]
Also, I had heard that there was going to be some problem with 'The Chaplin Revue', something that Image had corrected on 'The First National Collection' but which WB (or maybe the Chaplin Estate) wasn't going to do for that release, but I can't remember what it was and can't find it now.
I mean, I bought the Image versions of those anyway, and won't be selling them off unless the new releases have those cuts (I may buy the DVDs at some point for the other extras, though; I'm planning to do that with 'Modern Times' but haven't bought it yet), but I was wondering about those.
[Based on the doc TCM showed after 'The Kid' last night -- another "Chaplin Today" doc -- I'd say the scenes are definitely not in the movie itself.]
Also, I had heard that there was going to be some problem with 'The Chaplin Revue', something that Image had corrected on 'The First National Collection' but which WB (or maybe the Chaplin Estate) wasn't going to do for that release, but I can't remember what it was and can't find it now.
#10
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 788
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Seattle
Originally posted by ThatGuamGuy
Will 'The Kid', 'A Woman of Paris', and 'A King In New York' have the scenes which were removed from later cuts of the film on the DVD at all? I'm assuming they'll be the final cuts (as with 'Modern Times'), based on what they've said previously, but I'm wondering if pressure from the fans will force them to at least include the scenes as supplementary material (as with, again, 'Modern Times').
I mean, I bought the Image versions of those anyway, and won't be selling them off unless the new releases have those cuts (I may buy the DVDs at some point for the other extras, though; I'm planning to do that with 'Modern Times' but haven't bought it yet), but I was wondering about those.
[Based on the doc TCM showed after 'The Kid' last night -- another "Chaplin Today" doc -- I'd say the scenes are definitely not in the movie itself.]
Also, I had heard that there was going to be some problem with 'The Chaplin Revue', something that Image had corrected on 'The First National Collection' but which WB (or maybe the Chaplin Estate) wasn't going to do for that release, but I can't remember what it was and can't find it now.
Will 'The Kid', 'A Woman of Paris', and 'A King In New York' have the scenes which were removed from later cuts of the film on the DVD at all? I'm assuming they'll be the final cuts (as with 'Modern Times'), based on what they've said previously, but I'm wondering if pressure from the fans will force them to at least include the scenes as supplementary material (as with, again, 'Modern Times').
I mean, I bought the Image versions of those anyway, and won't be selling them off unless the new releases have those cuts (I may buy the DVDs at some point for the other extras, though; I'm planning to do that with 'Modern Times' but haven't bought it yet), but I was wondering about those.
[Based on the doc TCM showed after 'The Kid' last night -- another "Chaplin Today" doc -- I'd say the scenes are definitely not in the movie itself.]
Also, I had heard that there was going to be some problem with 'The Chaplin Revue', something that Image had corrected on 'The First National Collection' but which WB (or maybe the Chaplin Estate) wasn't going to do for that release, but I can't remember what it was and can't find it now.
* The 2-disc The Kid contains 6 minutes of scenes deleted by Chaplin for the 1971 re-release
* The single-disc A King in New York contains 16 minutes worth of 14 deleted scenes
* The single-disc A Woman of Paris contains 6 minutes of deleted scenes.
None of these are available by seamless branching. The Chaplin Estate has been doggedly faithful to Chaplin's late-career revisionism (unfortunately, IMHO).
Please see my post here for extensive discussion about the First National shorts.
#13
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Kolchak
I bought this set today.Wanted to know is there a volume 3 coming out too? And what will be included if there is? Thanks
I bought this set today.Wanted to know is there a volume 3 coming out too? And what will be included if there is? Thanks
I kinda doubt it. If memory serves, the 2 sets cover most if not all of Chaplin's feature films, and Warner/MK2 might not have gotten any rights for the other Chaplin shorts.
#15
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 2,202
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Montreal, Canada
I love this set!!..Chaplin IS/WAS the greatest. (sorry Muhammad Ali)
My only "minor" complaint is the box is too freakin big. As soon as i unwrapped the plastic it fell apart. This should have been in a stronger box
..But like I said there's so much stuff in here it's worth every penny..The 2 hour documentary on his life was very interesting and I loved Johnny Depp's soundbite about the famous roll dance
City Lights is just brilliant. The whole flower seuqence at the beginning with the blind girl and the heartbreaking ending is pure movie magic
RIP Mr Chaplin
My only "minor" complaint is the box is too freakin big. As soon as i unwrapped the plastic it fell apart. This should have been in a stronger box
..But like I said there's so much stuff in here it's worth every penny..The 2 hour documentary on his life was very interesting and I loved Johnny Depp's soundbite about the famous roll dance
City Lights is just brilliant. The whole flower seuqence at the beginning with the blind girl and the heartbreaking ending is pure movie magic
RIP Mr Chaplin
Last edited by shanester; 03-14-04 at 03:45 PM.
#16
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by shanester
My only "minor" complaint is the box is too freakin big. As soon as i unwrapped the plastic it fell apart. This should have been in a stronger box
My only "minor" complaint is the box is too freakin big. As soon as i unwrapped the plastic it fell apart. This should have been in a stronger box
#17
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Georgia, USA
Image Entertainment and Film Preservation Associates released a 7-disc set of all of the Mutual and Essanay shorts made by Chaplin. (look for the set that includes the "Chaplin's Goliath" documentary on Eric Campbell)
If all of the surviving Keystones were to be released to DVD (Kino or FPA is possibly working on a set, not certain though), the entire body of Chaplin's films would be on DVD.
Oh... MK2 might be coming out with a newly restored version of "Tillie's Punctured Romance." However, Image already has a DVD out (of a mediocre print, though). The rest of the Keystones are on various awful public domain DVD's and the excellent "Slapstick Encyclopedia" set from Image.
If all of the surviving Keystones were to be released to DVD (Kino or FPA is possibly working on a set, not certain though), the entire body of Chaplin's films would be on DVD.
Oh... MK2 might be coming out with a newly restored version of "Tillie's Punctured Romance." However, Image already has a DVD out (of a mediocre print, though). The rest of the Keystones are on various awful public domain DVD's and the excellent "Slapstick Encyclopedia" set from Image.
#18
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 452
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Are there any reviews that compare the set to the Image versions? The first collection had picture quality issues for Region 1.
I need to figure out which release of The Circus I want to get, and if I want to pick up City Lights again.
I need to figure out which release of The Circus I want to get, and if I want to pick up City Lights again.




Don't these studios know I'm trying not to spend as much on DVDs for the next few months?

