Bring it back and say its defective. Bestbuy only returns defective discs. They will say get another one. This time grab the widescreen version. Should work.

That's exactly what i did.

I actually pulled that trick to exchange my old The Shining disc for the newer, restored one.

:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

OMG!!!!
It's spelled lying, not lieing!!!!!!!!

And BTW Best Buy has never questioned me about returning pan & scan for widescreen copies of fully opened DVDs, even without the insert!!!!!!

I have never had a problem exchanging at Best Buy. They generally don't care as long as one does not ask for one's money back.

It happened to me twice at Best Buy - Die Another Day and The Matrix Reloaded. The former, I opened completely before realizing what I'd bought. As for the latter, I only managed to remove all the security stickers but one. Best Buy exchanged both of them for me with no lying required.