a little audio problem with Day of the Dead SE
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,218
Received 2,204 Likes
on
1,507 Posts
a little audio problem with Day of the Dead SE
Here's a review of the upcoming Day of the Dead Special Edition from Anchor Bay:
http://www.thewebofhorror.com/dayreview.html
This part of the review is a little troubling though:
Now here's the deal: A TV version of Day of the Dead was prepared, deleting much of the gore and redubbing practically all the dialogue due to the excessive profanity. This version was never used in the US, but this print inexplicably wound up being used for a Japanese laserdisc (the best the film had ever looked on video at that point, but still...). Now, apparently, Anchor Bay at least partially made use of that print in some way, for their new disc, causing these few instances of dubbed lines replacing profanity. I don't know how bad it is, but I'm sure it will be noticable to fanatics like myself who have the films dialogue practically memorized. Kind of bad news, but I guess I'll still be buying it.
http://www.thewebofhorror.com/dayreview.html
This part of the review is a little troubling though:
The one flaw (and here's where I reveal, if I haven't already, just how much of a dork I am-- these things will not even register on the ears of the casual viewer) in this presentation's audio comes in the form of three or four instances in which dubs from the aforementioned Japanese laserdisc can be heard. Knowing nothing of the details of this disc's production, I can only guess that the Japanese print was used for some of this transfer, and a few odds and ends of that disc's laugh-a-minute soundtrack found their way onto this DVD. No biggie.
Now here's the deal: A TV version of Day of the Dead was prepared, deleting much of the gore and redubbing practically all the dialogue due to the excessive profanity. This version was never used in the US, but this print inexplicably wound up being used for a Japanese laserdisc (the best the film had ever looked on video at that point, but still...). Now, apparently, Anchor Bay at least partially made use of that print in some way, for their new disc, causing these few instances of dubbed lines replacing profanity. I don't know how bad it is, but I'm sure it will be noticable to fanatics like myself who have the films dialogue practically memorized. Kind of bad news, but I guess I'll still be buying it.
#5
I'm unfamilar with what exactly the Japanese dub is, and find the quote from the review confusing.
Cultshock, your speculation about 'TV edit' style dialouge being cut into the movie in a few places is very troubeling. I'm going to assume that's not the case right? If audio was used from that transfer, surely it would have been lines that were the same as in the original version, right? The people who worked on this wouldn't have done somthing so stupid, right?
Looks like I better hold on to my old version of DAY OF THE DEAD until I can check the new one out.
Cultshock, your speculation about 'TV edit' style dialouge being cut into the movie in a few places is very troubeling. I'm going to assume that's not the case right? If audio was used from that transfer, surely it would have been lines that were the same as in the original version, right? The people who worked on this wouldn't have done somthing so stupid, right?
Looks like I better hold on to my old version of DAY OF THE DEAD until I can check the new one out.
#6
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Miami,Florida
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
****KK!!!!!!! same thing happened on the AB DVD of Sleepaway camp,oh well thsi is what going to happen.Once that ino leaks out into us Day Of The Dead fanatics,Anchor Bay will have one hell of a complaint..i proll know most of the lines and im sure i will notice this problem
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,218
Received 2,204 Likes
on
1,507 Posts
Originally posted by Crocker Jarmen
I'm unfamilar with what exactly the Japanese dub is, and find the quote from the review confusing.
Cultshock, your speculation about 'TV edit' style dialouge being cut into the movie in a few places is very troubeling. I'm going to assume that's not the case right? If audio was used from that transfer, surely it would have been lines that were the same as in the original version, right? The people who worked on this wouldn't have done somthing so stupid, right?
I'm unfamilar with what exactly the Japanese dub is, and find the quote from the review confusing.
Cultshock, your speculation about 'TV edit' style dialouge being cut into the movie in a few places is very troubeling. I'm going to assume that's not the case right? If audio was used from that transfer, surely it would have been lines that were the same as in the original version, right? The people who worked on this wouldn't have done somthing so stupid, right?
At any rate, according to the above review, there are several instances where swearing is noticably dubbed over. Someone at Anchor Bay should have caught this, but I guess someone was asleep at the switch.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Anchor Bay screws the pooch again.
Surprise, surprise.
Surprise, surprise.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
I have removed this and the upcoming Dawn set from DVDAf wishlist. Maybe if AB fixes it, I'll pick it up. Until then, I'll be content with my Elite NOTLD.
#13
Member
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 199
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
these things will not even register on the ears of the casual viewer
#15
Suspended
Still picking it up (Only seen Day 2-3 times, so I wouldn't notice). As long as they don't dub/erase the classic Dawn quote, I'll be fine.
#16
My Generosity Is Legendary
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Home of the Golden Snowball
Posts: 1,271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Josh-da-man
Anchor Bay screws the pooch again.
Surprise, surprise.
Anchor Bay screws the pooch again.
Surprise, surprise.
I think I need to print this thread so I can stop explaining why I have multiple versions of the same movie.
#17
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: New York City
Posts: 1,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Pac-Rat
I think I need to print this thread so I can stop explaining why I have multiple versions of the same movie.
I think I need to print this thread so I can stop explaining why I have multiple versions of the same movie.
Good idea. I'm giving the printout to my wife with the next Amex bill.
#18
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I'm still going to buy it. I don't own either Dawn or Day on DVD, and have wanted them for so long.
#20
Member
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: L.A., CA
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just found another review over at http://dvdmaniacs.net/
Iīm not bothered by it. Just canīt wait to get my hands on
an SE of Day. Waited long enough for that baby.
ILSA
Iīm not bothered by it. Just canīt wait to get my hands on
an SE of Day. Waited long enough for that baby.
ILSA
#21
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 1999
Location: Camp Crystal Lake
Posts: 1,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: "Asinine"
The fact people that are cancelling their pre-orders without even hearing/seeing ANY of the disc for themselves should have people pausing to rethink the definition of the word.
The fact people that are cancelling their pre-orders without even hearing/seeing ANY of the disc for themselves should have people pausing to rethink the definition of the word.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
At the very least, it should give people a reason to wait until the disc is actually released and reviewed before running out and buying it.
Ever since the big e-tailer crash (before, places like BigStar would offer a bigger discount on pre-orders), there's no longer any incentives to pre-order.
Ever since the big e-tailer crash (before, places like BigStar would offer a bigger discount on pre-orders), there's no longer any incentives to pre-order.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by DVD_O_Rama
RE: "Asinine"
The fact people that are cancelling their pre-orders without even hearing/seeing ANY of the disc for themselves should have people pausing to rethink the definition of the word.
RE: "Asinine"
The fact people that are cancelling their pre-orders without even hearing/seeing ANY of the disc for themselves should have people pausing to rethink the definition of the word.
Canceling a preorder doesn't mean 'never going to buy'. It just means 'not going to buy before reading more reviews and/or seeing/hearing these issues for myself'. I think that's the exact opposite of asinine, when there are apparently issues with the disc.
#24
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 1999
Location: Camp Crystal Lake
Posts: 1,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bboisvert
I don't see how this is 'asinine' at all. Perhaps you aren't considering the definition of pre-order -- buying something sight unseen.
Canceling a preorder doesn't mean 'never going to buy'. It just means 'not going to buy before reading more reviews and/or seeing/hearing these issues for myself'. I think that's the exact opposite of asinine, when there are apparently issues with the disc.
I don't see how this is 'asinine' at all. Perhaps you aren't considering the definition of pre-order -- buying something sight unseen.
Canceling a preorder doesn't mean 'never going to buy'. It just means 'not going to buy before reading more reviews and/or seeing/hearing these issues for myself'. I think that's the exact opposite of asinine, when there are apparently issues with the disc.
Considering that I have been collecting movies for over a quarter of a century, I've bought eveything from VHS, Beta, RCA Videodisc, Laserdisc, DVD, D-VHS and just about every other format that's been available for home consumption (and some that haven't), and I've bought many titles several times.
Never once did I have the nerve to piss and moan about "this is no the definitive version, and therefore I'll boycott.." blah blah.
Do you realize how many inferior, pan & scan, dubbed atrocities I've had to sit through just because I wanted to see the damn movie???
Ok, that's a loaded question as you have no idea or desire to know what my viewing habits are. Fair enough.
I guess I'm just sick and tired of the knee-jerk reactions that are so prevelant today, due the damned internet. Some schmuck in Peoria thinks he heard a mouse fart in the rear channel French 2.0 track, and now every Joe DVD Guru© that prowls the internet forums is demanding a re-pressing, because his $20 entitles him to nothing else then absolute perfection in every single facet. Puh-leeze.
**** the film, it's all about the polish on the package ain't it, bub?
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,218
Received 2,204 Likes
on
1,507 Posts
Unfortunately, DVD has really spoiled us. I remember the old days when I had to get 6th generation grey market videos just to see a hard to get film I was interested in. I first saw Day of the Dead over 15 years ago on a heavily censored video tape (Ontario was very censorous towards violence back then) and I was happy enough just to finally see the film.
Its great to finally be able to watch films in our own living room that look and sound as good as or better than they did in theatres. So, I can live with a few imperfections and mistakes here and there, because its still way better than the crappy videos I used to collect.
Its great to finally be able to watch films in our own living room that look and sound as good as or better than they did in theatres. So, I can live with a few imperfections and mistakes here and there, because its still way better than the crappy videos I used to collect.