amphobian:

Best
Serpent and the Rainbow
Star Trek Collection
Silence of the Lambs

Worse (Cause I have to)
Bruce Springsteen
Jerry Springer Show
Christmas Vacation

You need
Natural Born Killers
Cube
Citizen Kane

A link to my guzzlefish if the profiler isn't working:

http://www.guzzlefish.com/collection...ame=waskydiver

Critiquing wasky seems presumptuous, but...

Best:
Solaris
Spartacus
Walkabout

Worst:
Grease (A movie I loathe...)
Joe vs. the Volcano
Scream (Any of them.)

Need: (Toughest category...)

You have several Tarkovsky films. Where's Nostalghia? Problems w/ the Fox disc?

Any of the Star Trek: The Next Generation season sets would compliment your fine ST movie collection.

You have a couple of Reese Witherspoon's films. Twilight (for reasons both crass and high brow) or Freeway would make nice additions to your list.

All in all, a really sweet collection there.

thanks for taking a look, i'll rate dcgotenks

of those missing ones you mentioned. we've been holding off on shawshank b/c they keep talking about a SE, we do need to get signs (i can't remember why we didn't when it came out--i think we were "budgeting" then ) both films i love.

dcgotenks:

best:

battle royale (read the book too, the english translation just came out)
office space (a must)
die hard set (i really need to bite the bullet and get this one! myself)

worst:

fast & the furious (can't stand VD)
the tuxedo
sweet home alabama (i'm guilty of this too, but only b/c it was a gift)

missing

i'd order the 3-disck of brotherhood of the wolf
you'd probably enjoy kalifornia
check out some some genres other than action and comedy

hgar78:

Best:
Ginger Snaps CE (yay!)
Edward Scissorhands
The Fantasia Anthology

Not-the-Best:
From Dusk Till Dawn
Gladiator
The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Need:
Amadeus: The Director's Cut
Jurassic Park (only saw the sequels)
Night of the Living Dead Millenium, burn the 30th anniversary!

I was also passed over

um...Mature Forum?

for SideShow:

Best:
-This is Spinal Tap: Criterion Collection
-12 Monkeys
-Ben Folds Five: Complete Sessions at West 54th

Worst:
-Spice World
-Halloween 3: Season of the Witch
-The Majestic

You Need:
-The Ultimate Toy Box (ditch that ol' two-pack!)
-The Mystery Science Theater Collection, Vol. 3 (another Shorts disc and The Sidehackers make this set well worth it)
...and a few Criterions...
Rififi: Criterion Collection
The Vanishing: Criterion Collection
M: Criterion Collection
Dead Ringers: Criterion Collection

Nice Collection!

ok, chrisfarrar:

Best:
25th Hour
About Schmidt
Shallow Grave
Jeepers Creepers
Tomorrow Never Dies (OOP)

Worst:
The Scorpion King
Rock Star
K-Pax
Sugar and Spice
Scooby-Doo

You Need:
Predator
The Boondock Saints
Black Hawk Down (3-Disc)
Kingpin
Close Encounters of the Third Kind (2-Disc)

I think those would be right up your alley.

I was passed over also...

http://www.dvdtracker.com/dvd_list.a...order_by=title

I'll get you DumDum...

Best:

Rushmore: CC
Boogie Nights: Platinum Edition (2 Disc Set)
Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Season #2


Worst:

ECW: Best Of Cactus Jack
ECW: Cyberslam '99
ECW: Wrestlepalooza '97


Needed:

The Thing (Carpenter)
Saving Private Ryan
Miller's Crossing


Nice collection, BTW (except for the wrestling stuff )

I'll evaluate Jesse, since I was skipped earlier.

Best:

Badlands
The Duellists
Walkabout

Three of the most beautifully shot films I've ever seen.

Worst: (Again, difficult)

Bedazzled
There's Something About Mary
Any Given Sunday

Need:

You have Chinatown and Five Easy Pieces. The Last Detail and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest would complete the Nicholson Hall of Fame 70's Quadrology.

You've got McCabe and Mrs. Miller and M*A*S*H. Nashville would fit well next to them.

Again, a fabulous collection.

Buck Turgidson -

Best -
Pulp Fiction
Big Trouble in Little China
Dr. Strangelove

Worst (this was hard as I like almost all movies, which is made evident by my collection) -
Assassins
Poison Ivy 2
Evolution

Need -
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Jaws
The Shinning (you seem to be a Kubrick fan)





My Collection -
Guzzlefish

LordOrgg -

Best:
- Mr. Show: S1&2
- Get A Life
- Tron

Worst:
- Blade Runner
- Freddy Got Fingered
- The Time Machine

Need: (this is tough - that's a nice collection!)
- An Evening with Kevin Smith (you have Mallrats, so you must be a fan )
- Cannonball Run (if you liked Rat Race, this is much better - entertaining commentary, too)
- The Complete Monty Python's Flying Circus

Cardinal Fang -

Best:
- Evil Dead: Book of the Dead
- Seven
- Pulp Fiction

Worst:
- A.I.
- Drop Dead Gorgeous
- Sarah MacLauglan: Mirroball

Need: (this is tough - that's a nice collection!)
- Fear and Loating in Las Vegas (Criterion)
- Lethal Weapon 1-3 (you have part 4!!!)
- Bourne Identity (since you have Matt Damon movies)

MY LIST:
http://www.guzzlefish.com/collection...ame=doubledown

DJ_Longfellow:

Best:
Sorority House Massacre/SHM 2
Punch-Drunk Love
Frailty
25th Hour

Worst:
Happy Gilmore (NO OAR=NO SALE! )
Labyrinth
Rock Star

You should pick up:
The Vanishing:Criterion Collection
Battle Royale
The Dead Zone (Walken/Cronenberg)
The Fly (Cronenberg)
Trainspotting (R2, or when a better R1 version comes out)

Looks like a really fun collection--I noticed a lot of similarities with my collection.

...please, posters, don't skip over me this time...

cupcake jesus:

Best:
Apocalypse Now
The Bicycle Thief
Charade
M Hulot's Holiday
Hitchcock Criterion Set
MST3K

Love those classics!

Worst:
Boogie Nights
Scarface
Magnolia
Chasing Amy

4 out of 5 of my least favorite movies ever...


Missing:
Touch of Evil - I enjoy this a bit more than Citizen Kane
Shadow of a Doubt - My favorite Hitchcock movie
Topkapi - If you enjoyed Rififi
The Third Man
Mr. Show


Good collection! Can always use more classics though.


Here is my collection:
http://www.guzzlefish.com/collection...rname=toddsm66

As mentioned earlier don't have a list but i hope Toddsm66 won't mind me appraising his collection....and a very nice collection it is

Three of the good one's

Metropolis (Fritz Lang)
20,000 Leagues Under The Sea
Seven Samurai (one of my fave films so had to include it)

You've got a whole load more i could have chosen.


Three that i personally wouldn't have

My Myself & Irene
The Muppet Movie
South Park Series or film


Three to consider

Die Nibelungen - Excellent DVD from Kino though maybe not quite as impressive in terms of restoration as 'Metropolis' but still a nice companion to your other Fritz Lang disc.

Baraka - Basically you've got every genre pretty much covered but something a little different and i would certainly recommend it to anyone.

The Spaghetti Western Boxset (Blue Underground) - Notice you've a few classic type westerns and this release from Blue Underground is superb!!

no one in front...

my collection (same as in the sig):
http://www.guzzlefish.com/collection...ez&mediatype=D

cool_neez

Best - 7 Samurai, 6th Sense, 3 Kings

Worst - Heat, Days of Thunder, UHF

Rec'd (kind of hard to get a feel for what you like since you're all over the map ) - Sanjuro/Yojimbo (Kurosawa Criterions), Six String Samurai, Charade


http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.html?cat=1&id=nemein

nemein -
Best = Leon: The Professional, 12 Monkeys, Vanilla Sky

Worst = Knockaround Guys, Legend of the Drunken Master, Ghostship

Missing = Emporer's New Groove (the best Disney in my opinion!), William Shakespear's Romeo and Juliet (You seemed to like Baz Luhrman thought you should have this one too.), When Harry met Sally... (Best romantic comedy by Meg Ryan in my opinion!) oh and The Fifth Element! (I think you would like it)

Great Collection though, I was thrilled to see stuff like Clue, Cronicles of Narnia, and those Mind's Eye DVDs, you've got cool taste. =)

BTW, this is my first post.. so be gentle! =)

my list
http://www.guzzlefish.com/collection...me=SmurfyLissa

SmurfyLissa:

Best:
-Without Limits (the better of the Prefontaine films)
-25th Hour
-The Game (and underrated classic)
-Waking Life

Worst:
-Seven (should get the New Line Platinum edition)
-Good Will Hunting (like Seven, needs an upgrade to the Collectors' Edition)
-The Jerk (no OAR = NO SALE )
-The New Guy

Should buy:
Other than the upgrades of Good Will Hunting and Seven...
-Open Your Eyes (Abre Los Ojos--The basis for Vanilla Sky)
-Ghostbusters
-Stand by Me
-The Terminator: SE

You have some solid "foundation" titles to build your collection on--looks like it could be good.

For cupcake jesus

Best:
- Fight Club - Special Edition
- Close Encounters of the Third Kind - Collector's Edition
- The Godfather - DVD Collection

Worst:
- Armageddon - The Criterion Collection
- The Talented Mr. Ripley
- Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure

Should buy:
- The Professional - International cut (a good upgrade)
- Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace
- Full Metal Jacket - Restored

For "The Freak":

Looks as if we don't have too much in common regarding our DVD collections, though it seems as if you and I agree in musical tastes, so here's my two cents:

Best 3
Terminator 2 - Ultimate (Terminator 3 pales in comparison to this classic)
Donnie Darko (I saw this one several months ago and I still think about it)
Shrek (Seen it a few times and never get tired of it!)

Least 3
Unbreakable (Disappointing follow-up to Sixth Sense)
Forrest Gump
It (I like Stephen King, but with only a couple of exceptions, I don't care for much for big screen/little screen adaptations)

Recommendations
Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense (Great concert film, even if you don't like the Heads)
Almost Famous- Untitled (Cool film for fans of rock & roll)
Das Boot - Superbit (Looks like you have few war/underwater adventure DVD's in your collection, so you might like this one)

Like you, I am pretty new to this game, here's the link to my collection:

http://www.dvdprofiler.com/mycollect...p?alias=rick_k

you're collection is private...

go in your account in Profiler's site to make it public...

Thanks, Freak! I think it's public now...

Link to my DVD collection:

http://www.dvdprofiler.com/mycollect...p?alias=rick_k