Where is Young Sherlock Holmes?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Special Edition
Where is Young Sherlock Holmes?
I read that this was being worked on well over a year ago. Does anyone have any current info on when this film will be released?
I would love to have an isolated track of Bruce Broughton's score and deleted scenes if any are available. A commentary with Chris Columbus and Barry Levinson would also be great.
I would love to have an isolated track of Bruce Broughton's score and deleted scenes if any are available. A commentary with Chris Columbus and Barry Levinson would also be great.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
*Bump!*
Okay . . . so this DVD is slated to be released on December 2, 2003 (according to Amazon and the "Release Updates" thread). Apart from it being widescreen, does anyone know any more details on the release? Couldn't find anything . . .
Okay . . . so this DVD is slated to be released on December 2, 2003 (according to Amazon and the "Release Updates" thread). Apart from it being widescreen, does anyone know any more details on the release? Couldn't find anything . . .
#5
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by cinephan
It's going to be barebones. It's a $14.99 MSRP.
It's going to be barebones. It's a $14.99 MSRP.
#6
Member
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 87
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I can remember a day when we were all chastising Paramount for having that no-budge $29.99 SRP. At that time people were assuring Martin Blythe that they'd be happy with just the movie, if only they could get that damn price down. Well, here we are, getting great new transfers, with no extras or inserts, for fifteen bucks, which traslates to under ten at many retails and online sites. And a 2-disc special edition of ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST will be out there for about fifteen. Paramount has listened to us. Movies like DRAGONSLAYER, while they are to die for for many of us fans, will not sell in sufficient numbers to warrant special edition treatment. I would love to have trailers for DRAGONSLAYER and YOUNG SHERLOCK HOLMES, but I will be the last to gripe about their absense when I'm paying so little for quality product that, had they belonged to other studios, might not be getting released at all. I say, Thank You, Paramount. You heard, you responded, and we benefit.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Dick
I can remember a day when we were all chastising Paramount for having that no-budge $29.99 SRP. At that time people were assuring Martin Blythe that they'd be happy with just the movie, if only they could get that damn price down. Well, here we are, getting great new transfers, with no extras or inserts, for fifteen bucks, which traslates to under ten at many retails and online sites. And a 2-disc special edition of ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST will be out there for about fifteen. Paramount has listened to us. Movies like DRAGONSLAYER, while they are to die for for many of us fans, will not sell in sufficient numbers to warrant special edition treatment. I would love to have trailers for DRAGONSLAYER and YOUNG SHERLOCK HOLMES, but I will be the last to gripe about their absense when I'm paying so little for quality product that, had they belonged to other studios, might not be getting released at all. I say, Thank You, Paramount. You heard, you responded, and we benefit.
I can remember a day when we were all chastising Paramount for having that no-budge $29.99 SRP. At that time people were assuring Martin Blythe that they'd be happy with just the movie, if only they could get that damn price down. Well, here we are, getting great new transfers, with no extras or inserts, for fifteen bucks, which traslates to under ten at many retails and online sites. And a 2-disc special edition of ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST will be out there for about fifteen. Paramount has listened to us. Movies like DRAGONSLAYER, while they are to die for for many of us fans, will not sell in sufficient numbers to warrant special edition treatment. I would love to have trailers for DRAGONSLAYER and YOUNG SHERLOCK HOLMES, but I will be the last to gripe about their absense when I'm paying so little for quality product that, had they belonged to other studios, might not be getting released at all. I say, Thank You, Paramount. You heard, you responded, and we benefit.
Besides, some of these bare bones releases DESERVE extras. It doesn't bother me that Black Sunday doesn't come with extras, but something like Young Sherlock Holmes and Dragonslayer should. If you don't want to create new material for the disc, at least give us the theatrical trailer and some text info and bios. Even Warners does that on their bare bones releases.
#8
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by Shannon Nutt
I'd rather see them boost the price $5 to $10 and give us some extras. Other studios release movies for $19.99 (Retail) and load them up with bonus features.
Besides, some of these bare bones releases DESERVE extras. It doesn't bother me that Black Sunday doesn't come with extras, but something like Young Sherlock Holmes and Dragonslayer should. If you don't want to create new material for the disc, at least give us the theatrical trailer and some text info and bios. Even Warners does that on their bare bones releases.
I'd rather see them boost the price $5 to $10 and give us some extras. Other studios release movies for $19.99 (Retail) and load them up with bonus features.
Besides, some of these bare bones releases DESERVE extras. It doesn't bother me that Black Sunday doesn't come with extras, but something like Young Sherlock Holmes and Dragonslayer should. If you don't want to create new material for the disc, at least give us the theatrical trailer and some text info and bios. Even Warners does that on their bare bones releases.
While Young Sherlock Holmes didn't make the same impact on an overall genre, it did pioneer some of the most advanced special effects of the time, including the first completely CG character to be used in a movie. In my mind, this accomplishment deserves more attention than a bare bones release. They could have at least scrounged ogether some of the already-existing specials that I know are out there (having seen them at some point before on TV).
So, while I am one of those "to die for for many of us" fans, and am very excited to have these two DVD's available, I am still dissapointed in how the releases were handled. I'd have definately paid more to see it done otherwise.




