DVD Talk review of 'McLeod's Daughters - Season 4'
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
DVD Talk review of 'McLeod's Daughters - Season 4'
I read Paul Mavis's DVD review of McLeod's Daughters - Season 4 at http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=31675 and...
Hey Paul, good review, I'm just wondering if you really wanted this to have a Collector Series rating. You only give it a 4 in video and less in all other categories, and in the Final Thoughts section you say "I highly recommend McLeod's Daughters: The Complete Fourth Season."
That's cool if you want the high rating, but it just appears that it may have been a mistake based on the review itself.
Hey Paul, good review, I'm just wondering if you really wanted this to have a Collector Series rating. You only give it a 4 in video and less in all other categories, and in the Final Thoughts section you say "I highly recommend McLeod's Daughters: The Complete Fourth Season."
That's cool if you want the high rating, but it just appears that it may have been a mistake based on the review itself.
#2
Oh, yeah -- BIG mistake. Those ratings are on drop-downs, and a simple slip of the wrist (along with perhaps an unsteady mouse hand -- after all, it was after watching 32 hours of the thing), and presto! A good Aussie soap becomes the media event of the year!
Thanks for the heads up, and hopefully, not too many of you McLeod's Daughters non-believers out there put in Amazon.com orders, based on that rating!
Thanks for the heads up, and hopefully, not too many of you McLeod's Daughters non-believers out there put in Amazon.com orders, based on that rating!
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
No worries. I was intitially thinking "how could they give Superbad almost perfect 5's without a CS rating, but give this one the top score?" But after reading the complete review, I figured it was something like that. I will now continue to enjoy your reviews.