DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Reviews and Recommendations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations-8/)
-   -   Laserdisc suggestions (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations/505486-laserdisc-suggestions.html)

Dr. Forrester 07-05-07 12:51 AM

Request: Laserdisc Suggestions
 
Mainly driven by my disappointment that there won't be a Scorsese commentary on the new Taxi Driver SE, I decided to take the plunge and pick up an LD player on the cheap. It's an Pioneer LD-V2200; nothing too fancy, but good enough for my needs.

Here's what I'm planning on picking up:
Taxi Driver w/ commentary by Scorsese and Schrader
Burn Witch Burn w/ commentary by Richard Matheson
King Kong w/ commentary by Ron Haver

Any suggestions for LDs that have features (particularly commentaries) that aren't likely to ever see a DVD release will be greatly appreciated!

Case01 07-05-07 02:44 AM

The 3 Bond films with recalled Commentary

gorgo99 07-05-07 06:40 AM

The original, untarnished Star Wars Trilogy. Get the THX widescreen versions, either singly or in the boxed set (best version), if you can find it. Avoid the Special Editions, as those are the "updated" version.

matome 07-05-07 07:44 AM

Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992) Criterion CAV

chente 07-05-07 09:07 AM

Get the Criterion disc of The Graduate. One of the best commentaries I've ever listened to.

Matthew Ackerly 07-05-07 09:08 AM

The Game Criterion

inri222 07-05-07 11:26 AM

Cronenberg's Crash
Menace II Society
Repulsion
The Fisher King
Midnight Cowboy

Drexl 07-05-07 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by gorgo99
The original, untarnished Star Wars Trilogy. Get the THX widescreen versions, either singly or in the boxed set (best version), if you can find it. Avoid the Special Editions, as those are the "updated" version.

Weren't those from the same source as for the most recent DVD? Or are you referring to a different version?

dvd-4-life 07-05-07 06:30 PM

Time Cop (W/S along w/dts) and Mimic(dts).

speedyray 07-05-07 08:53 PM

Santa with Muscles

Oh, and I second a lot of what others have said.

Carrie CC
I also have The Killer CC and Hard Boiled CC
Several WS titles that are FS on DVD

wewantflair 07-06-07 09:40 PM

While you're on Hogan movies, get No Holds Barred, also.

gorgo99 07-07-07 06:58 AM


Originally Posted by Drexl
Weren't those from the same source as for the most recent DVD? Or are you referring to a different version?

Not sure which version you are referring to... the recent DVD was based on the Special Edition + more modifications, making it a "Special-er" edition. Apparently the 2nd release DVDs had the original (unmodified) as extras, but they aren't anamorphic, etc. So, I guess you're right, they're the same. The laserdisc might look better?

Dr. Forrester 07-11-07 02:52 PM

Thanks for the advice all, much appreciated! I"ve already picked up Burn Witch Burn! and Kong, so here's my shopping list for the next few months:

Criterion SE Bonds
Crash
Fischer King
Godfather Trilogy 1908-1981


Not sure which version you are referring to... the recent DVD was based on the Special Edition + more modifications, making it a "Special-er" edition. Apparently the 2nd release DVDs had the original (unmodified) as extras, but they aren't anamorphic, etc. So, I guess you're right, they're the same. The laserdisc might look better?
The "extras" discs of the newest SW DVD releases are in fact transfers from the old LDs. I already picked those releases up on the cheap at Costco, so I'm not in need of the laserdiscs.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:06 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.