DVDTalk to review Deadwood?
02-07-05, 01:52 PM
#1
Moderator
Thread Starter
DVDTalk to review Deadwood?
Curious as to why a DVDTalk review hasn't been posted for the HBO series, Deadwood yet? It is released tomorrow (2/8) and a review may sway some to make a blind-buy. Is a review in the works?
02-07-05, 02:59 PM
#2
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,824
Received 1,882 Likes
on
1,238 Posts
das Monkey is tackling the review for DVD Talk. There wasn't a lot of lead time with this set, unfortunately, so a review is probably still a short while off.
02-07-05, 06:56 PM
#4
DVD Talk Hero
• Adam Tyner •
das Monkey is tackling the review for DVD Talk. There wasn't a lot of lead time with this set, unfortunately, so a review is probably still a short while off.
das Monkey is tackling the review for DVD Talk. There wasn't a lot of lead time with this set, unfortunately, so a review is probably still a short while off.
das
02-07-05, 07:53 PM
#6
DVD Talk Hero
02-07-05, 11:47 PM
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Episode 12 is called "Sold Under Sin", not "Sold Under Sub". While submarines first make their appearance in the US in the Civil War, they weren't found in South Dakota until much, much later 
02-09-05, 10:24 AM
#13
DVD Talk Hero
Nice review, das - why didn't you give it the Collector's Series rating? Because the show's story meandered a bit in the middle of the season? Not that it is a big deal or anything, but everything in the review seemed to point in that direction.
And I thought we agreed that you would start bolding the important parts for the simple folk who just want a quick fix.
And I thought we agreed that you would start bolding the important parts for the simple folk who just want a quick fix.
02-09-05, 11:47 AM
#14
DVD Talk Hero
• B.A. •
Nice review, das - why didn't you give it the Collector's Series rating? Because the show's story meandered a bit in the middle of the season? Not that it is a big deal or anything, but everything in the review seemed to point in that direction.
Nice review, das - why didn't you give it the Collector's Series rating? Because the show's story meandered a bit in the middle of the season? Not that it is a big deal or anything, but everything in the review seemed to point in that direction.
• B.A. •
And I thought we agreed that you would start bolding the important parts for the simple folk who just want a quick fix.
And I thought we agreed that you would start bolding the important parts for the simple folk who just want a quick fix.
can just read the Introduction (and first paragraph of Content) and Conclusion and get an idea of what the show is about and what I think about it. As for bolding, they're all "important parts". das
02-10-05, 08:07 AM
#15
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by das Monkey
For one, the special features are good but not stellar. Secondly, I think it falls a bit short on replay value compared to some other shows of similar quality. And finally, as you mention, I do think the story drops a bit in some places in the middle of the season. I must be clear that when I say these things, I am splitting hairs, and the show is far superior to just about everything else on television, but when assigning these ratings I need to split those hairs, and I try to reserve the Collector Series rating for the absolute best of the best in terms of extras or content (preferably both), something that truly stands out and demands special attention. While this set comes close, I don't think it reaches that level. I'm hoping the second season does.
Originally Posted by das Monkey
I know you're just joking around, but if any part of you is serious on this topic, I do try to structure my reviews so someone with poor reading skills like yourself can just read the Introduction (and first paragraph of Content) and Conclusion and get an idea of what the show is about and what I think about it. As for bolding, they're all "important parts".
das
can just read the Introduction (and first paragraph of Content) and Conclusion and get an idea of what the show is about and what I think about it. As for bolding, they're all "important parts". das
Your reviews kick ass - keep up the good work. It's nice to see a well-written piece that had some thought put into it.
02-12-05, 12:48 PM
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Nice review, das, but I think it took me longer to read your article than it did to watch the whole season of episodes!
