DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Reviews and Recommendations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations-8/)
-   -   Special edition re-release of "Goodfellas" (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations/379790-special-edition-re-release-goodfellas.html)

Mike Lowrey 08-14-04 05:08 PM

Along with Goodfellas, what other good mafia-type movies are there?

The Untouchables, Scarface, Casino, Carlitto's Way...what else, if any...

Zoo Billy 08-14-04 05:29 PM

Donnie Brasco.

Skyler 08-14-04 06:06 PM

The Godfather, The Godfather II, Once upon a time in America, Millers Crossing, King of New York, Traffic.

Tony Dvdfan 08-15-04 01:06 AM


Originally posted by Mike Lowrey
Along with Goodfellas, what other good mafia-type movies are there?

The Untouchables, Scarface, Casino, Carlitto's Way...what else, if any...

How about State of Grace w/Sean Penn?

NaturalMystic79 08-15-04 09:20 AM


Originally posted by Zoo Billy
Donnie Brasco.
:thumbsup: Hell yeah!

bareva 08-16-04 02:34 PM

one down-one to go--->casino ES

Dan1boy 08-16-04 04:53 PM

and after that.... Heat SE (which technically isn't really 'mafia' related but I think most people would place it in the same genre category, right?)

mmm...Casino...*drool*

Gil Jawetz 08-17-04 01:14 PM

I've got the whole Scorsese boxed set here. Came from Amazon today. Got my review copy of Mean Streets yesterday. Review is up here in case you're interested. Can't have Goodfellas without Mean Streets.

Citizen 08-17-04 01:18 PM

Bugsy....

Does this make you happy?

Then why dont I see you smiling?

mjlukich 08-17-04 04:52 PM


Originally posted by Citizen
Bugsy....

Does this make you happy?

Then why dont I see you smiling?

Just curious, did you really like Bugsy? I rented it once and wasn't able to finish it, but it just seemed to drag on and on for me. Neither Beatty nor Benning seemed to pull off their respective characters, at least for me.

Shroud 08-17-04 11:47 PM

I really enjoyed Bugsy and have it as part of my dvd collection. Very entertaining story, and from a different point of view you have Mobsters with Patrick Dempsey. Not as serious of a gangster flick but interesting.

OldBoy 08-18-04 05:50 AM

Are we ever going to get DVD Talk's review?

Gil Jawetz 08-18-04 09:12 AM

DVD Savant is reviewing it, so look for an excellent piece of writing when he's done with it.

Frankly, if I had more time I'd bust out my own review to go with the Mean Streets review. Maybe this weekend.

Artman 08-18-04 03:37 PM

Just noticed a black line running right down the middle of the frame in one shot. One minute into Ch 27, it's just a five-second shot of Deniro. Nothing big, but a little annoying.

NaturalMystic79 08-18-04 05:29 PM

I picked up Goodfellas SE at Best Buy today for under $10! Thank gawd for the bonus coupons. :)

Gil Jawetz 08-20-04 10:55 AM

Review's up.

OldBoy 08-20-04 04:13 PM

Gil,
Nice review. How come not 'DVD Talk Collector's Edition'? Just wondering...

Gil Jawetz 08-20-04 06:32 PM


Originally posted by scott1598
Gil,
Nice review. How come not 'DVD Talk Collector's Edition'? Just wondering...

I didn't review it, sucka! It was DVD Savant. Had I reviewed it it would probably have gotten collector's edition (I haven't had a chance to watch it yet but obviously I'm well familiar with the content. I've certainly watched it many, many times since I saw it in the theater.)

If I had to guess it would be based on Savant's hesitations about the film's content; he seems to acknowledge that the film is a masterpiece but is a bit uneasy with how grim it makes the state of human morality out to be. Me, I think it's a masterpiece for that exact same reason. Hmmm... maybe I will write another review (although I've got the new Mary-Kate and Ashley DVD waiting to be reviewed too...) ;) (is there such a thing as a smiliy that winks and cries at the same time?)

OldBoy 08-20-04 08:52 PM

My bad...I guess by you posting the link it gives the impression that you also wrote the review. Seems a little deceptive, but hey I am not Savant so I cannot complain too much of say stealing thunder, getting the glory, reaping the rewards... <a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/4/4_1_107v.gif' alt='Teethy' border=0></a>

so hey DVD Savant, how come no '...Collector's Edition' rating?

Gil Jawetz 08-20-04 09:38 PM

This is me from a little earlier in the thread:


Originally posted by Gil Jawetz
DVD Savant is reviewing it, so look for an excellent piece of writing when he's done with it.

Frankly, if I had more time I'd bust out my own review to go with the Mean Streets review. Maybe this weekend.

;)

OldBoy 08-21-04 10:12 AM

Gil,
This is me from now...I saw that, but being that "Goodfellas" was taking so long (no offense Savant), I thought it may have changed viewing hands!! <a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/4/4_1_7v.gif' alt='Cool' border=0></a>


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:31 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.