Review needed:Imposter
...Despite Sinise's thespian gravitas, and the movie's imaginative art direction and spirited, even frenetic editing, director Gary Fleder's adaptation of Philip K. Dick's 1952 short story, "The Impostor" never takes off.
The story, which includes familiar elements from other Dick film adaptations, including "Blade Runner" and "Total Recall," feels too slight and hackneyed. The movie automatically pegs itself for the straight-to-video sci-fi rental shelf.
From Desson Howe's review in The Washington Post
...like I say: poor Philip K. Dick...
...at least the DVD, which features the Director's Cut, seems to be alright...
...still... poor Philip K. Dick...
. . . . . .
Last edited by Hendrik; 08-10-02 at 10:01 AM.
By the way, not only did they steal the uniforms from Starship Troopers, but they even used an entire shot from Starhip Troopers during the opening sequence!!! (The one from FedNet, where they show Buenos Aires obliterated after the asteroid hit), but presented in a different context in this film. Was I the only one who noticed this? What a ripoff!!!!
It seems to be a frequent occurence that entertaining sci-fi movies get negative reviews and/or comments among (what I consider to be) pseudo movie critics. It sure would be appreciated here if those folks who don't really care for sci-fi would keep their biased opinions to themselves. Not trying to start a fight - just MHO.
I recommended it to a buddy and he also liked it. He is a much bigger Philip K. Dick fan than me.
Definatley a renter though- can't say I'd ever rewatch it enough to buy it.
http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=4294
(Failed link removed, review reposted instead.)
The short stories of Philip K. **** have provided us with some memorable science fiction films. “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” was adapted into the Ridley Scott’s sci-fi staple movie “Blade Runner” with Harrison Ford. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Paul Verhoeven brought “Total Recall” to the big screen. More recently the pairing of Steven Spielberg and Tom Cruise has brought life to “Minority Report.” “Impostor” is another of ****’s stories adapted for the screen, unfortunately it just isn’t as memorable.
Gary Sinise portrays a scientist (Dr. Olham) who has just returned from vacation for the unveiling of his latest creation, a weapon that is supposed to win an intergalactic war that has ravaged the earth. When the good doctor returns to work though, he is quickly whisked away by a government security force led by Vincent D’Onofrio (Major Hathaway). Hathaway lets Dr. Olham in on a little secret: the good doctor is not who, or even what, he thinks he is. Very quickly Olham is on the run trying to prove that he is not an alien weapon impersonating the doctor.
Starring two actors whom I am yet to see a bad performance from, “Impostor” has a great cast in place. D’Onofrio portrays the stereotypical arch-nemesis with poignant accuracy, complete with over the top “bad guy” mannerisms and phrases (including the little fu-manchu beard). Sinise is more believable than the many all too convenient escapes his character manages. The supporting cast is loaded with talent: Madeline Stowe as Maya Olham; Tony Shalhoub as Nelson (the doc’s best friend); and Mekhi Pfifer as Cale (a downtrodden “resistance fighter” who helps the doc).
The story is somewhat muddled and filled with too many contrivances. It always amazes me how mild mannered scientists can always outwit, outfight, and outshoot highly trained military forces. It is also naggingly curious that the government has no interest in actually testing the doctor to see if he is an alien assassin. If you want to ignore plot holes and just enjoy the sci-f scenery, check out “Impostor.” If you want a clever sci-fi mystery, wait for “Minority Report” later this year. 3 Stars.
Last edited by Abob Teff; 08-16-02 at 03:31 AM.
All in all a perfectly enjoyable SF film, and I will add it to my collection.