Review Wanted: Grave of the Fireflies
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 3,521
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Mouthweathercity, IL.
I just order this, since someone recommended it. However, what is your take on this film. Is it as good as I have heard it is? I am grateful for any response.
#2
Moderator
I always catch flak for this, but what the hell... I didn't care for it. Maybe it's just an anime thing that I don't really care for, although this is one of the best ones I've seen wrt the art work. Actually I think my main problem is
I don't know maybe that's a little harsh
It's been awhile since I've seen it and maybe I would react differently now.
[Edited by nemein on 04-12-01 at 07:17 PM]
Spoiler:
I don't know maybe that's a little harsh
It's been awhile since I've seen it and maybe I would react differently now. [Edited by nemein on 04-12-01 at 07:17 PM]
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 17,214
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: |-|@><0r L@n|)
nemein: I had exactly the same problem with the film as you did:
For me, it wasn't the soul-rending story I'd been expecting, but it is a pretty moving film. And it's strong evidence against those that think anime is just robots and fan-service.
- David Stein
Spoiler:
For me, it wasn't the soul-rending story I'd been expecting, but it is a pretty moving film. And it's strong evidence against those that think anime is just robots and fan-service.
- David Stein
#6
Cool New Member
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Atlanta, GA
nemein and sfsdfd:
You both have valid points. This, to me, was part of the story's tragedy. The boy's pride, or perhaps laziness, which kept him from doing the right thing at the right time lead to the tragic consequences. However I think this adds to the movie rather than detracts from it.
DVD Smurf:
After you watch it, read the info at
http://www2.hawaii.edu/~dfukushi/Hotaru.html
Grave of the Fireflies is an excellent example of anime. It is worth watching, but perhaps not often.
Lee
You both have valid points. This, to me, was part of the story's tragedy. The boy's pride, or perhaps laziness, which kept him from doing the right thing at the right time lead to the tragic consequences. However I think this adds to the movie rather than detracts from it.
DVD Smurf:
After you watch it, read the info at
http://www2.hawaii.edu/~dfukushi/Hotaru.html
Grave of the Fireflies is an excellent example of anime. It is worth watching, but perhaps not often.
Lee
#8
Member
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 145
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am not a huge anime fan but have enjoyed several movies in this genre, Akira, Ghost in the Shell, Ninja Scroll and Princess Mononoke to name a few. I find Grave of the Fireflies to be the most moving and provoking anime feature that I have seen. I have many friends who are serious film buffs who are not interested in anime, but really liked Grave of the Fireflies and rank it highly among their favorite war films.
This is not a pleasant movie that you can watch repeatedly, but it does belong in your collection if you enjoy great movies with great emotional content.
This is not a pleasant movie that you can watch repeatedly, but it does belong in your collection if you enjoy great movies with great emotional content.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
I think this is one of the must have anime DVDs.
My take was that the film attempts to show the greater tragedy. A childish innocence and sense of play vs the reality of war....and it's toll and how it affected them. If anyone here has scene the UK animated film, When the Wind Blows...it's the same thing. An older English couple and their innocence and ignorance vs the atomic bombs.
The almost magical beginning and end to GOTF, I thought were very well done and added to it.
My take was that the film attempts to show the greater tragedy. A childish innocence and sense of play vs the reality of war....and it's toll and how it affected them. If anyone here has scene the UK animated film, When the Wind Blows...it's the same thing. An older English couple and their innocence and ignorance vs the atomic bombs.
The almost magical beginning and end to GOTF, I thought were very well done and added to it.
#10
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,797
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hong Kong
Originally posted by alpo
nemein and sfsdfd:
You both have valid points. This, to me, was part of the story's tragedy. The boy's pride, or perhaps laziness, which kept him from doing the right thing at the right time lead to the tragic consequences. However I think this adds to the movie rather than detracts from it.
Lee
nemein and sfsdfd:
You both have valid points. This, to me, was part of the story's tragedy. The boy's pride, or perhaps laziness, which kept him from doing the right thing at the right time lead to the tragic consequences. However I think this adds to the movie rather than detracts from it.
Lee
You need to remember that Grave of the Fireflies is based on a *true* story. The big difference is that:
Spoiler:
To me, this seems justified, and it makes the film much more gritty and real than portraying Seita as some completely innocent victim.
#11
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,797
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hong Kong
Final addition: Grave of the Fireflies is easily one of the best films I've ever seen. It easily, IMO, compares to Schindler's List in the portrayal of actual WW2 events.
#12
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 3,767
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: Seattle, Washington, America the Beautiful
Startide's published review of Grave of the Fireflies (EXCERPT)
The Use of Light as a Mise-en-scene
Element in the Grave of the Fireflies
Grave of the Fireflies is an animated movie from Studio Ghibli directed by Isao Takahata. It shows a portion of the effects of WWII from civilian eyes, and strives to convey its message through emotion rather than experience as many movies try to do.
[Edited by Startide on 04-17-01 at 10:28 AM]
Element in the Grave of the Fireflies
Grave of the Fireflies is an animated movie from Studio Ghibli directed by Isao Takahata. It shows a portion of the effects of WWII from civilian eyes, and strives to convey its message through emotion rather than experience as many movies try to do.
Spoiler:
[Edited by Startide on 04-17-01 at 10:28 AM]
#13
Banned
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 67
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Tampa,FL.
I didnt really like it. I bought it off of hype and sold it after watching it twice. Crappy animation that looks pre 1980's quality, mixed with lame characters. The only bad part is when a relative passes away, other then that, your friends will laugh at you for thinking this dvd belongs amongst a godly collection.
#14
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,797
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hong Kong
Originally posted by MaXYYYY
I didnt really like it. I bought it off of hype and sold it after watching it twice. Crappy animation that looks pre 1980's quality, mixed with lame characters. The only bad part is when a relative passes away, other then that, your friends will laugh at you for thinking this dvd belongs amongst a godly collection.
I didnt really like it. I bought it off of hype and sold it after watching it twice. Crappy animation that looks pre 1980's quality, mixed with lame characters. The only bad part is when a relative passes away, other then that, your friends will laugh at you for thinking this dvd belongs amongst a godly collection.
2. Have you seen the film?
3. If you have, and that is seriously your review, I think you should check in at a clinic.
#15
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 3,767
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: Seattle, Washington, America the Beautiful
Grimfarrow, not everyone enjoys a genuine artistic narrative film like Grave of the Fireflies. It's based upon a literate award-winning book, which is a plus for some and actually a minus for others. It isn't an action flick with ships and missiles. It doesn't have Ninja Scroll action such as Setsuko sliding down the sword blade (that scene, if you can imagine it, probably would get cheers from types of audience and groans from the rest of us). And there is no ecchi action which as you know, is bound to dissuade a number of anime fen (surely, you know of those anime fen that turn their noses up at almost anything that isn't hentai).
Of course I like it as you can see from my excerpted review above which focused on the director's clever use of lighting to either tell or aid the story. I picked that out in hopes that other people who didn't see that aspect of the film might enjoy it for the director and staff's insight at using the animation medium to its fullest.
When "MaXYYYY" says he doesn't like it, I can understand that. Also, there are a lot of anime fans that actually don't care for it for one reason or another (as I've seen at anime screenings). They come purely to be entertained on action flicks. Where are the missles? None. Where are the skimpy skintight plugsuits? None. No ecchi mixed with violence? No violence mixed with ecchi? Okay, they're gone. For some people, life is too short to not have fun or be titillated with flicks. Feeling sad watching movies is for someone else and not them.
Of course I like it as you can see from my excerpted review above which focused on the director's clever use of lighting to either tell or aid the story. I picked that out in hopes that other people who didn't see that aspect of the film might enjoy it for the director and staff's insight at using the animation medium to its fullest.
When "MaXYYYY" says he doesn't like it, I can understand that. Also, there are a lot of anime fans that actually don't care for it for one reason or another (as I've seen at anime screenings). They come purely to be entertained on action flicks. Where are the missles? None. Where are the skimpy skintight plugsuits? None. No ecchi mixed with violence? No violence mixed with ecchi? Okay, they're gone. For some people, life is too short to not have fun or be titillated with flicks. Feeling sad watching movies is for someone else and not them.
#16
DVD Talk Special Edition
I liked the movie, but think people often overplay how depressing it is. Sure, its not an upbeat movie, but I think you'd have to be fairly emotional in order to get broken up over it. Good movie though!
#17
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 3,767
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: Seattle, Washington, America the Beautiful
While Grave of the Fireflies is animated in the 1980's style, this is just a style of animation and not a difference in technical animation quality or workmanship. The technical animation merits are excellent as this was a theatrical release film instead of OAV.
#18
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 3,521
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Mouthweathercity, IL.
I watched this tragedy last night, and I was in tears. How can one blame the child for the events that happen to him and her?
Pride? No, I believe that he is acting in a way, which father would have done. But then again, his father is no child, and a child only knows how to immitate, since the complete understanding for the world is not yet learned by the cildren. For any of you who knows Maslows steps of needs recognize that both the girl and the boy do not get adequate support from an adult. which is needed for an appropriate development for a child. This is a tragedy that I could not watch in one sitting. I had to spilt it up with an hours break in between, because it is so difficut for the mind to imagine how horrible it must have been for the children, and at the same time process all the information that was given. The director must have very good insights in child development, and he has done his research before he made this masterpiece. I give it 10/10.
Pride? No, I believe that he is acting in a way, which father would have done. But then again, his father is no child, and a child only knows how to immitate, since the complete understanding for the world is not yet learned by the cildren. For any of you who knows Maslows steps of needs recognize that both the girl and the boy do not get adequate support from an adult. which is needed for an appropriate development for a child. This is a tragedy that I could not watch in one sitting. I had to spilt it up with an hours break in between, because it is so difficut for the mind to imagine how horrible it must have been for the children, and at the same time process all the information that was given. The director must have very good insights in child development, and he has done his research before he made this masterpiece. I give it 10/10.





