DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD & Home Theater Gear (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-home-theater-gear-5/)
-   -   16:9 or 4:3? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-home-theater-gear/86618-16-9-4-3-a.html)

Kromax 03-02-01 03:20 PM

Discuss your thoughts regarding this subject.


briank 03-02-01 03:35 PM

I enjoy 16:9 much better! Suits my periphial vision and has a better "feel" to it.

That's why I bought a 16:9 television.

And "less" black bars while watching wide-screen movies.
And for 4x3 television I use TW1 on my Toshiba which does (in my opinion) a beautiful slight stretch to fill the screen.

JimRochester 03-02-01 03:36 PM

That's a bit open-ended don't you think? Are you thinking about buying a TV and need input? Did you want opinions on the merit of each? I have a 16x9 Mitsubishi and love it. Some have said because of the limited WS programming available they'll buy the biggest 4:3 they can get and put up with the black bars. For me regular TV looks fine on my widescreen TV. DVD looks awesome!!

Kromax 03-02-01 03:38 PM


Originally posted by JimRochester
That's a bit open-ended don't you think?
Yes. That was my intention.

DigIt 03-02-01 03:43 PM

16:9 is the ideal display size for 16:9 material.
4:3 is the ideal display size for 4:3 material.

Kromax 03-02-01 03:46 PM


Originally posted by DigIt
16:9 is the ideal display size for 16:9 material.
4:3 is the ideal display size for 4:3 material.

Oh.

X 03-02-01 04:19 PM


Originally posted by DigIt
16:9 is the ideal display size for 16:9 material.
4:3 is the ideal display size for 4:3 material.

I mostly agree.

broadwayblue 03-02-01 06:35 PM

check out this site for side by side comparisons of viewing areas of 16X9 and 4:3 sets. pretty cool.

http://www.cavecreations.com/tv2.cgi


Fhrx 03-03-01 01:37 AM

I'd prefer 16:9!

Tony Block 03-04-01 01:26 PM


Originally posted by Kromax

Originally posted by DigIt
16:9 is the ideal display size for 16:9 material.
4:3 is the ideal display size for 4:3 material.

Oh.

Yes. I see your point. Yes.

Fhrx 03-04-01 07:12 PM

You gotta admit, DigIt has a good point there. ;)

reverb 03-04-01 09:30 PM


Originally posted by briank
I enjoy 16:9 much better! Suits my periphial vision...
That's an impossibilty... Search for 'peripheral' here and at HTF for why;)

Gladiator_UAE 03-05-01 04:03 AM

It Depends
 
It all depends on what you wanna use it for.

For most TV channels, I would prefer 4:3.
For DVD Movies, go for 16:9

If your TV is the last step in your home theater system, then I'd prefer 16:9. However, if you are planning to buy a projector, then go for 4:3 TV and get a 16:9 Capable projector.

I have a 4:3 TV that is used mostly for news. For DVD, I normally watch it on 16:9 Projector.

Regards,

Mitsurugi 03-06-01 10:18 AM


Originally posted by DigIt
16:9 is the ideal display size for 16:9 material.
4:3 is the ideal display size for 4:3 material.

It all makes sence now -smile-

Movie_Man 03-06-01 04:17 PM



Yes, I agree with the above.

:brickwl:


Kromax 03-07-01 07:44 AM


Thanks for the posts. The decision has been made to go with the 16:9 format.






All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:36 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.