S Video vs. Component Video: which makes DVDs prettier?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,342
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Papillion, NE!
S Video vs. Component Video: which makes DVDs prettier?
I'm currently hooked up my Sony Wega Tv to my DVD via component video cables. I was told that it would make the image clearer than s video and normal video cables. I sthis true or gimmick??
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 12,671
Received 1,244 Likes
on
458 Posts
From: Somewhere Hot Scoville Units: 9,999,999 Zodiac Sign: Capricorn
In Order (1 being the best)
1. Component
2. S-Video Cable
3. Composite
4. RF
If you're television has the capability of using Component Video, then by all means use it. I use S-Video cable with mine, only because It doesn't have a component hook up. Even though I'm very happy with it, I've seen the difference the two make, and component is slightly better (especially noticeable on bigger screen televisions).
1. Component
2. S-Video Cable
3. Composite
4. RF
If you're television has the capability of using Component Video, then by all means use it. I use S-Video cable with mine, only because It doesn't have a component hook up. Even though I'm very happy with it, I've seen the difference the two make, and component is slightly better (especially noticeable on bigger screen televisions).
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 1999
Posts: 1,075
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Easton, PA
Here's a link I posted in another thread asking the same question. It shows a visual comparison of all three hook ups. Of course the type and length of cable you use will make a difference also.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
The larger and higher quality your display, the more pronounced the difference between S-video and component is. On most average size (25-32") consumer televisions, the difference between the two is slight but noticeable.
Best possible picture from DVD? Usually. Don't forget higher resolution sources like D-VHS or HDTV broadcast.
That rule of thumb is correct, but there are many factors that can complicate the matter: The quality and type of the display (RPTV vs direct view vs front projection; CRT vs DLP vs LCD; etc.). Whether the deinterlacer in the progressive scan DVD player is better than the one in the HDTV. Whether the DVD player is infected with the chroma upsampling bug. Whether you use (or can afford!) a scaler.
There's a lot of information to take in if you want the "best picture possible". I say make the best of what you can reasonably afford without going bankrupt and enjoy it.
Originally posted by slop101
Correct me if I'm wrong, but
progerssive scan dvd player + component cables + HDTV = best possible picture
Correct me if I'm wrong, but
progerssive scan dvd player + component cables + HDTV = best possible picture
That rule of thumb is correct, but there are many factors that can complicate the matter: The quality and type of the display (RPTV vs direct view vs front projection; CRT vs DLP vs LCD; etc.). Whether the deinterlacer in the progressive scan DVD player is better than the one in the HDTV. Whether the DVD player is infected with the chroma upsampling bug. Whether you use (or can afford!) a scaler.
There's a lot of information to take in if you want the "best picture possible". I say make the best of what you can reasonably afford without going bankrupt and enjoy it.
#11
Member
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kentucky
I've got a 55" Mits (not HDTV
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
#12
Member
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 243
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: antarctica
Originally posted by bhamon
I've got a 55" Mits (not HDTV
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
I've got a 55" Mits (not HDTV
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
I have a 32" Toshiba, and I could clearly tell a difference between component and s-video. The colors were much more defined, especially the redness of the blood in Black Hawk Down.
Last edited by llzackll; 08-24-02 at 10:35 PM.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by bhamon
I've got a 55" Mits (not HDTV
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
I've got a 55" Mits (not HDTV
) I tried both S-video and component. I could not tell a difference so I took the $35 component cables back and kept the $10 S-video cable. I suggest S-video if you do not have HDTV.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Call me silly, but what are the basic hookups called like on a Super Nintendo where the yellow is the video and the red and white are the audio? Composite or component?
tks
tks
#15
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 2,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York, NY
Originally posted by milo bloom
Call me silly, but what are the basic hookups called like on a Super Nintendo where the yellow is the video and the red and white are the audio? Composite or component?
tks
Call me silly, but what are the basic hookups called like on a Super Nintendo where the yellow is the video and the red and white are the audio? Composite or component?
tks
Think of the meaning of the words.
Composite - combined - 1 video cord (yellow)
Component - seperated - 3 video cords
S-Video is one cord that keeps luminescence (brightness) and chrominance (color) seperate.
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Do you have to buy special component video cables or can you use anything with RCA plugs on it?
#17
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by BigPete
Do you have to buy special component video cables or can you use anything with RCA plugs on it?
Do you have to buy special component video cables or can you use anything with RCA plugs on it?
The advantage to component cables is that they come bundled together and are labeled to help you sort out the Y, Cr, and Cb. It's really just a convenience. If you can keep track of that on your own, three yellow RCA cables will do.
#18
DVD Talk Special Edition
This might be a dumb question, but here goes:
Composite signals use the RED and WHITE cords to send audio signals. What exactly do they separate? Or does it just stand for RIGHT speaker and LEFT speaker?
Composite signals use the RED and WHITE cords to send audio signals. What exactly do they separate? Or does it just stand for RIGHT speaker and LEFT speaker?
#20
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 336
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hawkeye State
What's a good brand of composite cables? I bought MonsterVideo2 from Circus City - but then I was pretty much in a hypnotic state after buying a 34" Sony Widescreen (KV-34XBR800). The cable was $74.54. If there's something just as good at a cheaper price, I can return the Monster Cable.
#21
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 2,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York, NY
Originally posted by PlumPeach
What's a good brand of composite cables? I bought MonsterVideo2 from Circus City - but then I was pretty much in a hypnotic state after buying a 34" Sony Widescreen (KV-34XBR800). The cable was $74.54. If there's something just as good at a cheaper price, I can return the Monster Cable.
What's a good brand of composite cables? I bought MonsterVideo2 from Circus City - but then I was pretty much in a hypnotic state after buying a 34" Sony Widescreen (KV-34XBR800). The cable was $74.54. If there's something just as good at a cheaper price, I can return the Monster Cable.
#22
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 336
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hawkeye State
In my earlier post I meant component not composite. I'll be running component from my DVD player to my new Sony Widescreen. I'm just wondering if there's a lower cost alternative to Monster. My tv doesn't come for a couple days so the Monster cables are still unopened.
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 9,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Heart of the Heart
Originally posted by Chad
In Order (1 being the best)
1. Component
2. S-Video Cable
3. Composite
4. RF
If you're television has the capability of using Component Video, then by all means use it. I use S-Video cable with mine, only because It doesn't have a component hook up. Even though I'm very happy with it, I've seen the difference the two make, and component is slightly better (especially noticeable on bigger screen televisions).
In Order (1 being the best)
1. Component
2. S-Video Cable
3. Composite
4. RF
If you're television has the capability of using Component Video, then by all means use it. I use S-Video cable with mine, only because It doesn't have a component hook up. Even though I'm very happy with it, I've seen the difference the two make, and component is slightly better (especially noticeable on bigger screen televisions).
1. DVI (digital transmission for best image quality)
2. Component
3. S-Video Cable
4. Composite
5. RF
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by broadwayblue
you need to adjust your rankings now. there is a new kid on the block.
1. DVI (digital transmission for best image quality)
2. Component
3. S-Video Cable
4. Composite
5. RF
you need to adjust your rankings now. there is a new kid on the block.
1. DVI (digital transmission for best image quality)
2. Component
3. S-Video Cable
4. Composite
5. RF
This will probably change in the future, though.
#25
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by broadwayblue
you need to adjust your rankings now. there is a new kid on the block.
1. DVI (digital transmission for best image quality)
2. Component
3. S-Video Cable
4. Composite
5. RF
you need to adjust your rankings now. there is a new kid on the block.
1. DVI (digital transmission for best image quality)
2. Component
3. S-Video Cable
4. Composite
5. RF
1. DVI / SDI
2. 5-BNC to 5-BNC
3. 15-Pin VGA to 5-BNC
4. 15-Pin VGA to 15-Pin VGA
5. Component (3-BNC to 3-BNC)
6. S-Video
7. Composite
8. RF




