DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/650423-treasury-editions-oversized-comic-books.html)

Red Hood 05-03-20 04:18 PM

Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I though we had a thread about this but couldn't find it. My decision to start one is because one of may favorite things about comic books are the treasury-sized ones. Even though the majority of them were released before my time, once I learned about them, I started collecting them. I have a pretty big collection of Treasury books but throughout the years I missed some releases and have learned of some obscure ones that are a little harder to track. Just this past month, DC released a treasury edition, (or Famous First Limited Collector's Edition like they call it) of their first comic book ever, New Fun Comics #1. At one point, this was supposed to be a Wal-Mart exclusive, but then it was supposed to be released at LCS and book stores, but with the pandemic, it seems that it was only released as of now through Amazon. This book is hardcover, like some of the Famous Firsts from the 70's and it's gorgeous.


There was a nice website called Treasury Comics that had a up to date listing of all the Treasury and oversized books released by every company but apparently that side died. There this other site that a good list (don't know if it's complete) up to 2018.

Treasury Comics: Oversized Comics Checklist with Scans

The listing of course is missing anything released over the past 2 years, including the 3 X-Men Grand Design Treasury Editions. Does anyone know of a site that has a complete listing?


PhantomStranger 05-03-20 04:37 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
They seem like they'd be fun to collect. Never really got into Treasury editions but their size lends them to being displayed.

Bronkster 05-03-20 06:27 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I have quite a few that I bought new (yeah, I'm an old fart). I had no idea that the format continued past the 1970s. That New Fun book looks nice! Might have to do some huntin' for that.

Edited to add: Well, that didn't take long! Got it on Ebay! Doesn't come out until the 20th though.

Red Hood 05-03-20 07:22 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by Bronkster (Post 13734842)
I have quite a few that I bought new (yeah, I'm an old fart). I had no idea that the format continued past the 1970s. That New Fun book looks nice! Might have to do some huntin' for that.

Edited to add: Well, that didn't take long! Got it on Ebay! Doesn't come out until the 20th though.

Amazon has it right now!

https://smile.amazon.com/dp/17795011...ing=UTF8&psc=1

Red Hood 05-03-20 07:41 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
One thing of note: Even though Marvel has been releasing Treasury Editions for the past 4 years (starting with the Spider-Man one, Guardians of the Galaxy, Women of Power), some of the books they call Treasury in recent months, are not Treasury size per se. This happened with Silver Surfer: Black and History of the Marvel Universe. They are oversized but not Treasury sized.

majorjoe23 05-03-20 07:56 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Image put out a fun one a few years back, Giant Size Kung Fu Bible Stories. It was mostly Erik Larsen and Bruce Timm.

Trevor 05-03-20 08:11 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I’ve always loved Treasury editions, but can’t quite remember my history with them.

I’m almost positive I picked up a lot of the original DC ones back when they originally came out, but at some point lost them all. More later, past my bedtime.

but before I forget, there is a cool treasury podcast as part of the Fire and Water Network of shows.

B5Erik 05-03-20 09:59 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I bought several Treasury Editions back in the 70's and early 80's. My favorite was always the Spectacular Spider-Man edition from 1975, which was actually a reprint of ASM Annual #1 (Sinister Six) and ASM #6. It had a fantastic John Romita cover (which immediately caught my attention). After that I was hooked on the oversized editions. Great stuff!

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/55/fa...83b7576ffc.jpg

Unfortunately, I read them all to death and they're beat to hell. I think I've still got them somewhere. I love those things.

ytrez 05-04-20 07:40 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I bought a bunch of these in my youth and still have several floating around somewhere. My favorites were the Defenders and a Holiday Grab Bag from Marvel and the Tarzan books from DC.

Bronkster 05-06-20 10:29 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
A cursory check using the Price Guide shows that I have almost all of the DC editions. What's missing is all the Rudophs. :lol:

cultshock 05-06-20 11:58 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I love them, but I only remember buying two when I was a kid, a Hulk Treasury, and Batman vs. Hulk. I'm sure I would have bought more, but I had limited funds and $1.50 or $1.75 would get me nearly a half dozen regular comics.

Bronkster 05-06-20 12:49 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Yeah, a buck-fifty back then was a lot of money!

digidoh 05-06-20 05:15 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Also fantastic about that Spider-man Special Edition is the back cover is a reverse angle of the front (showing the back of the villains and Spidey's "face").

will travel 05-07-20 01:17 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
13th Dimension recently had an article about BATMAN #1 Treasury Edition. Which has links to other articles and podcasts. GROOVY!

https://13thdimension.com/why-the-ba...uring-classic/


Red Hood 05-07-20 08:52 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Some old school dealers have told me stories of how some scammers (including dealers themselves) would rip off the top cover for the DC Treasuries and try to sell them to rubes as if the book were the real deal. For example, a con artist would rip the cover of the Superman #1 Limited Collector's Treasury and try to sell it as if it was the original golden age Superman first issue. Well, to my surprise this type of scam still happens on eBay

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Superman-Co...p2047675.l2557

Hokeyboy 05-07-20 10:04 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
This was my very first comic book that I remember owning. I got it when I was 6 in 1977. It had all the Flash/Superman races up to that date, plus all kinds of fun bonus pages like blueprints to the Fortress of Solitude, the bottled city of Kandor, and much much more. It was lost to time but I managed to snag another copy off eBay.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...61f474b6e7.jpg

Josh-da-man 05-07-20 10:26 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Not a fan of over-sized comic books. Too hard to store. I prefer a uniform size for everything. Even those old Love & Rockets TPBs and Epic Moebius TPBs are a pain in the butt to store on my bookshelves.

The only Treasury I remember owning is back when I was a kid (actually one of my first comic books) was Marvel's adaption of The Empire Strikes Back.


https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...f0794e5b20.jpg

And, believe you me, I read the fuck out of that thing in the summer of '80.




b2net 05-08-20 06:37 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
This thread brings back so many good memories.

Bronkster 05-08-20 12:44 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by b2net (Post 13737807)
This thread brings back so many good memories.

I agree! I've been tempted a few times already to pull mine out and read some of them again! :lol:

Trevor 05-08-20 07:21 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by Bronkster (Post 13738064)
I agree! I've been tempted a few times already to pull mine out and read some of them again! :lol:

They’re part of my monthly checklist, so I get a regular fix.

ddrknghtrtns 05-09-20 10:15 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 13737704)
This was my very first comic book that I remember owning. I got it when I was 6 in 1977. It had all the Flash/Superman races up to that date, plus all kinds of fun bonus pages like blueprints to the Fortress of Solitude, the bottled city of Kandor, and much much more. It was lost to time but I managed to snag another copy off eBay.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...61f474b6e7.jpg

Did you ever learn how to draw The Flash?

Hokeyboy 05-09-20 11:23 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by ddrknghtrtns (Post 13738486)
Did you ever learn how to draw The Flash?

No.
No I did not...

will travel 05-14-20 01:41 AM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
I first Oversize comics was DC Special Series #27, Batman vs Hulk with art beautiful art by the GREAT Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...78d48c308b.jpg
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...8b01532b54.jpg

ddrknghtrtns 05-15-20 01:22 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 

Originally Posted by will travel (Post 13741047)
I first Oversize comics was DC Special Series #27, Batman vs Hulk with art beautiful art by the GREAT Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...78d48c308b.jpg
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...8b01532b54.jpg

Last year, I found the sequel to it in paperback at a local habitat for $0.50. Found a Pizza Hut bookit certificate inside for a free personal pan. I wonder if it is still redeemable?

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...7754971525.jpg

PhantomStranger 05-15-20 05:51 PM

Re: Treasury Editions & Oversized Comic Books
 
Haven't heard about one of those Pizza Hut Book-it certificates since the 1980s.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:15 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.