Classic/retro comic strips thread
#351
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
The Incal, written by Jodorowsky, art by Mobius. Published in sections in the 1980s. I saw pieces of it in Heavy Metal, but this is the first time I've read it all the way through.
Mobius was an amazing artist. In one panel, he shows eight anonymous technicians in a row in front of computers. You've seen that shot a hundred times before. But Mobius drew each one of them doing something different. For a single panel, those guys had personalities. Some of the backgrounds are insanely detailed. A high tech dystopian city, miles of garbage, a thousand-warrior battle royale, and an ocean planet are drawn in exquisite detail. Yet he was so good at flow that I was swiftly drawn from one panel to the next, forgetting that I wanted to look at the details.
Jodorowsky's script is a lot like what he had done in El Topo in the 1960s -- lots of arresting ideas in an atmosphere of mysticism, but a plot that never quite makes sense. Part of the problem is the serial publication required a climax every few pages. It got repetitive how a new problem would come out of nowhere, and be quickly solved by a solution out of nowhere at the start of the next chapter. In order to fight The Darkness, the Incal says that everyone in the galaxy has to go into theta sleep. Next chapter: Okay, done. But wait: there are 78 billion people in the next galaxy who are awake!
It's still worth reading, because the good ideas are brilliant, and they still hold up despite having been taken and reused so many times by other creators since then.
This book is smaller than magazine size. I briefly thought about getting one of the collectible full size books. But everyone else had the same thought and the prices went up fast. I decided not to get one when the price went above $250. Someone thought it was worth $890 for the last one on Amazon Marketplace.
I don't this this is filmable. The plot is incoherent, the protagonist is unlikeable, and it would all have to be CGI.
Mobius was an amazing artist. In one panel, he shows eight anonymous technicians in a row in front of computers. You've seen that shot a hundred times before. But Mobius drew each one of them doing something different. For a single panel, those guys had personalities. Some of the backgrounds are insanely detailed. A high tech dystopian city, miles of garbage, a thousand-warrior battle royale, and an ocean planet are drawn in exquisite detail. Yet he was so good at flow that I was swiftly drawn from one panel to the next, forgetting that I wanted to look at the details.
Jodorowsky's script is a lot like what he had done in El Topo in the 1960s -- lots of arresting ideas in an atmosphere of mysticism, but a plot that never quite makes sense. Part of the problem is the serial publication required a climax every few pages. It got repetitive how a new problem would come out of nowhere, and be quickly solved by a solution out of nowhere at the start of the next chapter. In order to fight The Darkness, the Incal says that everyone in the galaxy has to go into theta sleep. Next chapter: Okay, done. But wait: there are 78 billion people in the next galaxy who are awake!
It's still worth reading, because the good ideas are brilliant, and they still hold up despite having been taken and reused so many times by other creators since then.
This book is smaller than magazine size. I briefly thought about getting one of the collectible full size books. But everyone else had the same thought and the prices went up fast. I decided not to get one when the price went above $250. Someone thought it was worth $890 for the last one on Amazon Marketplace.
I don't this this is filmable. The plot is incoherent, the protagonist is unlikeable, and it would all have to be CGI.
Last edited by Nick Danger; 12-05-21 at 10:25 AM.
The following users liked this post:
davidh777 (12-05-21)
#352
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Krazy and Ignatz: Tiger Tea.
The Krazy Kat dailies were mainly gag-a-day strips. Herriman sometimes got an idea that produced gags for three to five days. Then there's Tiger Tea. This book collects the Tiger Tea story, which ran for almost a hundred days. It has more whimsy and fewer puns than usual, a strong plot, and very few thrown bricks. I prefer whimsy, so I think it's a great book.
I have a fairly large Krazy Kat collection, but I missed this book when it came out at $13. It's out of print now and I had to pay double.
The Krazy Kat dailies were mainly gag-a-day strips. Herriman sometimes got an idea that produced gags for three to five days. Then there's Tiger Tea. This book collects the Tiger Tea story, which ran for almost a hundred days. It has more whimsy and fewer puns than usual, a strong plot, and very few thrown bricks. I prefer whimsy, so I think it's a great book.
I have a fairly large Krazy Kat collection, but I missed this book when it came out at $13. It's out of print now and I had to pay double.
#353
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I found Alex Toth Genius Isolated at a LCS and have always been interested in it so I got it, despite the unwieldy size and high price tag. Then the dude at the counter mentions he also has a copy of Genius Illustrated in the back, so I bought that too.
I guess these are technically still in print and available at the Library of American Comics website, but I’m ok with the purchase.
I guess these are technically still in print and available at the Library of American Comics website, but I’m ok with the purchase.
#354
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Krazy and Ignatz: Tiger Tea.
The Krazy Kat dailies were mainly gag-a-day strips. Herriman sometimes got an idea that produced gags for three to five days. Then there's Tiger Tea. This book collects the Tiger Tea story, which ran for almost a hundred days. It has more whimsy and fewer puns than usual, a strong plot, and very few thrown bricks. I prefer whimsy, so I think it's a great book.
I have a fairly large Krazy Kat collection, but I missed this book when it came out at $13. It's out of print now and I had to pay double.
The Krazy Kat dailies were mainly gag-a-day strips. Herriman sometimes got an idea that produced gags for three to five days. Then there's Tiger Tea. This book collects the Tiger Tea story, which ran for almost a hundred days. It has more whimsy and fewer puns than usual, a strong plot, and very few thrown bricks. I prefer whimsy, so I think it's a great book.
I have a fairly large Krazy Kat collection, but I missed this book when it came out at $13. It's out of print now and I had to pay double.
The following users liked this post:
Nick Danger (12-22-21)
#355
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
My Tiger Tea book arrived today. Nice book! Thanks for bringing this to my attention, Nick! I only flipped through it, and will read it as soon as I'm finished with Terry and the Pirates.
#357
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I pre-ordered the Terry and the Pirates set which was supposed to ship this month, but publishing delays have pushed it to maybe end of April. Good news is you can still get in on the pre-order.
The following users liked this post:
davidh777 (04-03-22)
#359
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
What Terry and the Pirates is that? The only version I see that's available for pre-order is from Clover Press, at $120 per volume.
$1200 for a set is too rich for me.
$1200 for a set is too rich for me.
#360
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
The complete strip will be collected in twelve deluxe 11″ x 14″ hardcover volumes each containing a full year of Terry and the Pirates, with a thirteenth volume by Dean Mullaney and Bruce Canwell that tells the behind-the-scenes story of the strip!
Vol. 1 collects all dailies and Sundays from the strip’s beginning on October 22, 1934 through the end of 1935 in a deluxe 192 pp, 11″ x 14″, hardcover. This initial volume is scheduled for a March 16, 2022 release with subsequent volumes dropping every four months!
Volume 13 is a Clover Press exclusive, available for purchase only on their website or as complementary gift with full series subscription (more details below)!
Vol. 1 collects all dailies and Sundays from the strip’s beginning on October 22, 1934 through the end of 1935 in a deluxe 192 pp, 11″ x 14″, hardcover. This initial volume is scheduled for a March 16, 2022 release with subsequent volumes dropping every four months!
Volume 13 is a Clover Press exclusive, available for purchase only on their website or as complementary gift with full series subscription (more details below)!
I signed up for the full subscription. I seem to recall the initial payment at the time was around $210. I think shipping will be billed separately, as each volume goes out.
If it were an up front charge of $900, there's no way I would have signed up. $225/ year seemed doable- especially if I can sell off the older IDW volumes to help defray the cost.
You're committed to paying the year upfront, but can cancel the series at the next years renewal.
Seeing the differences in blowups between the two convinced me. I would have loved to have seen this printed even larger, but the improvement in reproduction quality is substantial enough on it's own to justify the upgrade.
Last edited by Paul_SD; 04-07-22 at 06:49 PM.
The following users liked this post:
davidh777 (04-07-22)
#361
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
The $900 pre-order offer is still live on the clover site. First payment is $215. They expect to receive the shipment on June 6 so they gave Diamond a new release date of June 29.
The following users liked this post:
Paul_SD (04-08-22)
#362
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I think I’m going to do the 1/13 bundle. I like exclusives, and reading those two will make me more sure that I really want the rest. I’ll lose some money if I go all in maybe, but less risk if I decide I don’t need it all.
The following users liked this post:
davidh777 (04-07-22)
#363
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Vol. 1 is the first year, and I’ve heard it gets better after that. FWIW I really enjoyed the part of the first LOAC volume I read, so that gave me confidence to dive in on the set.
#364
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I finished volume one of Terry and the Pirates (not the new release, obviously) and really liked it. I'd love to continue with the series, but given that I'm at an age now where the probability of my ever re-reading it would be slim, I just can't justify the cost. Twenty years ago this would be a no-brainer.
#365
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I'm not trying to get anyone into financial straits, but I honestly don't think that any first time reader will be able to get a good impression of why the strip made it's mark from just the first of these new volumes.
Even in the older, six volume editions that Bronkster is reading, the content of the second volume is where the strip really found it's footing and started to become something special.
The first year or so is fun enough, throwback adventure fare, but it's definitely more narratively slight in comparison to how the strip develops in the second year and beyond. Especially once the war impacts it.
By the middle of his run, he's assembled this wonderfully diverse, Howard Hawks-style cast of richly embellished supporting characters that all keep weaving surprisingly, and naturally, in and out of the main characters lives.
In the older set, once you get to the fourth volume and the character arc of Raven, you should be able to understand why the strip is considered a masterpiece.
At that point, when you look back to those first months to a year, and all the b-movie skullduggery with the Dragon Lady, it's like you're looking back at a child who's now a man. Literally.
Even in the older, six volume editions that Bronkster is reading, the content of the second volume is where the strip really found it's footing and started to become something special.
The first year or so is fun enough, throwback adventure fare, but it's definitely more narratively slight in comparison to how the strip develops in the second year and beyond. Especially once the war impacts it.
By the middle of his run, he's assembled this wonderfully diverse, Howard Hawks-style cast of richly embellished supporting characters that all keep weaving surprisingly, and naturally, in and out of the main characters lives.
In the older set, once you get to the fourth volume and the character arc of Raven, you should be able to understand why the strip is considered a masterpiece.
At that point, when you look back to those first months to a year, and all the b-movie skullduggery with the Dragon Lady, it's like you're looking back at a child who's now a man. Literally.
The following users liked this post:
davidh777 (04-08-22)
#366
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
I'm not trying to get anyone into financial straits, but I honestly don't think that any first time reader will be able to get a good impression of why the strip made it's mark from just the first of these new volumes.
Even in the older, six volume editions that Bronkster is reading, the content of the second volume is where the strip really found it's footing and started to become something special.
The first year or so is fun enough, throwback adventure fare, but it's definitely more narratively slight in comparison to how the strip develops in the second year and beyond. Especially once the war impacts it.
By the middle of his run, he's assembled this wonderfully diverse, Howard Hawks-style cast of richly embellished supporting characters that all keep weaving surprisingly, and naturally, in and out of the main characters lives.
In the older set, once you get to the fourth volume and the character arc of Raven, you should be able to understand why the strip is considered a masterpiece.
At that point, when you look back to those first months to a year, and all the b-movie skullduggery with the Dragon Lady, it's like you're looking back at a child who's now a man. Literally.
Even in the older, six volume editions that Bronkster is reading, the content of the second volume is where the strip really found it's footing and started to become something special.
The first year or so is fun enough, throwback adventure fare, but it's definitely more narratively slight in comparison to how the strip develops in the second year and beyond. Especially once the war impacts it.
By the middle of his run, he's assembled this wonderfully diverse, Howard Hawks-style cast of richly embellished supporting characters that all keep weaving surprisingly, and naturally, in and out of the main characters lives.
In the older set, once you get to the fourth volume and the character arc of Raven, you should be able to understand why the strip is considered a masterpiece.
At that point, when you look back to those first months to a year, and all the b-movie skullduggery with the Dragon Lady, it's like you're looking back at a child who's now a man. Literally.
You just saved me $900! Probably over a grand with shipping….
#367
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
(salivating)
Probably should have amended or rescinded that.
People will be able to get an idea of why the strip is beloved from the first volumes of the old or new editions. Caniff's storytelling verve is there from the get go.
It's just that the strip gets so much deeper into the dramatics as it advances- characters, subplots, atmosphere...
It's a little like the jump from Star Wars to Empire- except that the strip never regresses to Return of the Jedi. It keeps going at that same trajectory of not dumbing the material down or taking the easy way out.
People will be able to get an idea of why the strip is beloved from the first volumes of the old or new editions. Caniff's storytelling verve is there from the get go.
It's just that the strip gets so much deeper into the dramatics as it advances- characters, subplots, atmosphere...
It's a little like the jump from Star Wars to Empire- except that the strip never regresses to Return of the Jedi. It keeps going at that same trajectory of not dumbing the material down or taking the easy way out.
#368
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Clover Press just sent out an email. They have Vol. 1 and 13 in hand and are currently packing them to ship out to customers.
It's also last call to get in on early bird pricing.
It's also last call to get in on early bird pricing.
#370
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Mine was scheduled for the 11th, but showed up today.
I'm happy seeing how these were packed. That was always a big ? for me. I hope the remaining 11 volumes will be double boxed as well.
I'm happy seeing how these were packed. That was always a big ? for me. I hope the remaining 11 volumes will be double boxed as well.
#371
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,611
Received 1,015 Likes
on
839 Posts
Re: Classic/retro comic strips thread
Yeah, mine arrived yesterday. The vols 1 and 13 are individually shrink-wrapped, then they’re shrink-wrapped together, then they’re in a packing box inside a mailing box. Very secure, and the strips themselves look great.