Rob Liefeld - Worst comic book artist ever?
#126
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,242
Received 1,733 Likes
on
1,134 Posts
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Sal Buscema was drawing Spectacular when I first started reading Spider-Man regularly in 1988, so I guess I'm just used to that style.
Jon Bogdanove's X-Factor art in the early '90s is probably my least favorite ever, with Igor Kordey's New X-Men fill-ins coming in as a very close second.
Jon Bogdanove's X-Factor art in the early '90s is probably my least favorite ever, with Igor Kordey's New X-Men fill-ins coming in as a very close second.
#127
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
He had a very distinctive style during his Spectacular Spider-man. I can't imagine Bagley, Larsen, or McFarlane being able to convey the emotion of DeMatteis' scripts the way Buscema did.
As a kid I wasn't a big fan of his, instead preferring the flashier future Image founders' styles, but Spectacular was the Spider-man title that I remembered the best. Looking back he's one of my favorite Spider-man artists.
#128
Banned by request
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Comic art doesn't have to be flashy to be good, but Buscema's Spectacular Spider-Man stuff is really rough. If I were running Marvel I'd have kicked him off the roster.

#129
DVD Talk Legend
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I still blame Kordey for killing my love of comic books. I hated him on New, and he ruined X-Treme for me. I still say that was a big FU to Claremont by taking Laroca off the title and putting Kordey on there as his replacement.
#130
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Totally disagree.
He had a very distinctive style during his Spectacular Spider-man. I can't imagine Bagley, Larsen, or McFarlane being able to convey the emotion of DeMatteis' scripts the way Buscema did.
As a kid I wasn't a big fan of his, instead preferring the flashier future Image founders' styles, but Spectacular was the Spider-man title that I remembered the best. Looking back he's one of my favorite Spider-man artists.
He had a very distinctive style during his Spectacular Spider-man. I can't imagine Bagley, Larsen, or McFarlane being able to convey the emotion of DeMatteis' scripts the way Buscema did.
As a kid I wasn't a big fan of his, instead preferring the flashier future Image founders' styles, but Spectacular was the Spider-man title that I remembered the best. Looking back he's one of my favorite Spider-man artists.


Last edited by mrhan; 02-26-12 at 10:17 AM.
#131
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: May 2004
Location: sector 2814
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
That's Sal inking his own work, later in his spectacular run they used other inkers.
#133
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I used to be a heavy comic book collector many years ago. I loved The New Mutants. After a certain number the quality of art went down hill, this was around the time Warlock came into the scene. Here is an issue of the artwork that I found:


Does anyone know who the artist is?


Does anyone know who the artist is?
Last edited by Sonic; 02-28-12 at 01:12 AM.
#135
DVD Talk Legend
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Bill Sienkiewicz?
I think there is a line between extremely stylized and "shitty".
I personally don't care for Sienkevicz. I never liked Stroman and was never a fan of Windsor-Smith but I recognize what they're doing. While I would never call their art "shitty" I certainly would call that Buscema art above shitty.
edit: whotony beat me too it but he did remind me that even though Bachalo is in that stylized catagory as well his is a style that I really enjoy.
I think there is a line between extremely stylized and "shitty".
I personally don't care for Sienkevicz. I never liked Stroman and was never a fan of Windsor-Smith but I recognize what they're doing. While I would never call their art "shitty" I certainly would call that Buscema art above shitty.
edit: whotony beat me too it but he did remind me that even though Bachalo is in that stylized catagory as well his is a style that I really enjoy.
#136
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Bill Sienkiewicz?
I think there is a line between extremely stylized and "shitty".
I personally don't care for Sienkevicz. I never liked Stroman and was never a fan of Windsor-Smith but I recognize what they're doing. While I would never call their art "shitty" I certainly would call that Buscema art above shitty.
I think there is a line between extremely stylized and "shitty".
I personally don't care for Sienkevicz. I never liked Stroman and was never a fan of Windsor-Smith but I recognize what they're doing. While I would never call their art "shitty" I certainly would call that Buscema art above shitty.
But I remember having a hard time embracing that style. I was still collecting the issues but hoping the artwork would go back to looking more refined and not so square.
#138
Senior Member
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Check out Sienkiewicz's work with Frank Miller on Elektra: Assassin an Daredevil: Love and War. Not great stories (written by Miller), but the art is just a trip to look at.
#139
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 51,768
Received 907 Likes
on
749 Posts
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Very nice--which Conan run is that? Something from Savage Sword?
#140
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I must be old because I'd read anything by Sal Buscema before ANY Image artist. Jim Lee included.
The printing on those 90's issues was especially bad, being in flexographic format. I recall an issue, with Green Goblin I think, that was printed standard that looked great. One of my favorite pieces of his work. And his older Hulk work stands on a level all its own.
His brother was certainly a better draftsman but Sal submitted quality work every time and while I can't say he was never late, I bet it was a rarity. He was a true professional. (and those John B. pages certainly look like Savage Sword to me)
As to Sienkiewicz, his issues of New Mutants were a revelation to me. Everything after him seemed so...normal. His work was certainly non-traditional but pretty spectacular to my eyes. He was doing "art" rather than drawing a comic book. I still find it surprising that he worked that style into a title like New Mutants, which was seemingly written to be a traditional book. That makes it all the better to me. If you don't like Sienkiewicz you'll never like the title but, if you can appreciate his work & style, go back and read New Mutants as an adult. You may be surprised.
The printing on those 90's issues was especially bad, being in flexographic format. I recall an issue, with Green Goblin I think, that was printed standard that looked great. One of my favorite pieces of his work. And his older Hulk work stands on a level all its own.
His brother was certainly a better draftsman but Sal submitted quality work every time and while I can't say he was never late, I bet it was a rarity. He was a true professional. (and those John B. pages certainly look like Savage Sword to me)
As to Sienkiewicz, his issues of New Mutants were a revelation to me. Everything after him seemed so...normal. His work was certainly non-traditional but pretty spectacular to my eyes. He was doing "art" rather than drawing a comic book. I still find it surprising that he worked that style into a title like New Mutants, which was seemingly written to be a traditional book. That makes it all the better to me. If you don't like Sienkiewicz you'll never like the title but, if you can appreciate his work & style, go back and read New Mutants as an adult. You may be surprised.
#141
DVD Talk Hero
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I'll admit, as a kid I also had a tough time with Sienkiewicz coming on the title, because I wasn't used to such stylized work. I also didn't really appreciate Frank Miller or even (gasp) Jack Kirby until way later on.
Speaking of Spidey artists, reading through that McFarlane Spidey omni, his art wasn't as refined as I remembered. It's also interesting hearing how Todd wouldn't follow the style sheets for the characters, which probably partially helped his success as his cartoony style really stood out in contrast to the other Spidey artists. It's also interesting to note the complaints from the old guard of artists, who could probably draw a lot better if they wanted to but were churning out pages as a business (with low page rates to boot) and didn't really appreciate this younger guard putting all this detail into the work...
I read that Life and Times of Bishop mini that Stroman did... while he was always very stylistic, I had a tough time following that one... I mean, a lot of that was set in the future so there was room for artistic license, but even stuff like baby Hope that should look human just doesn't.
Bachalo: I loved him on Death, and on Gen X, but when he went off and did Steampunk his stuff became nigh incomprehensible to me. I mean, it's beautiful but it's really, really hard to tell what's going on, which is kind of the point of sequential art.
Bogdanove: I appreciated his art in Man of Steel, but man I hated those X-factor issues of X-tinction Agenda.
Speaking of Spidey artists, reading through that McFarlane Spidey omni, his art wasn't as refined as I remembered. It's also interesting hearing how Todd wouldn't follow the style sheets for the characters, which probably partially helped his success as his cartoony style really stood out in contrast to the other Spidey artists. It's also interesting to note the complaints from the old guard of artists, who could probably draw a lot better if they wanted to but were churning out pages as a business (with low page rates to boot) and didn't really appreciate this younger guard putting all this detail into the work...

I read that Life and Times of Bishop mini that Stroman did... while he was always very stylistic, I had a tough time following that one... I mean, a lot of that was set in the future so there was room for artistic license, but even stuff like baby Hope that should look human just doesn't.
Bachalo: I loved him on Death, and on Gen X, but when he went off and did Steampunk his stuff became nigh incomprehensible to me. I mean, it's beautiful but it's really, really hard to tell what's going on, which is kind of the point of sequential art.
Bogdanove: I appreciated his art in Man of Steel, but man I hated those X-factor issues of X-tinction Agenda.
#142
DVD Talk Legend
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I do wonder how much of it was an artistic leap and how much was just going to better paper and coloring. If I recall Spider-Man was a premium comic at the time and used better paper then Amazing and I know they used better coloring on the early Image comics then they were using at Marvel at the time.
#143
DVD Talk Hero
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I don't think it's just coloring/paper. At that point in his career Todd had a lot more freedom, especially from deadlines, and as we saw once they went in business for themselves, deadlines are hard to keep. I don't remember what the gap was between Todd's Amazing work and his own Spidey title, but I'm sure he had ample time to do it.
#144
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
Speaking of Sienkiewicz. I actually thought he was a hack when he first started. It was obvious he was trying to be Neal Adams. He did his first work for Adams but I started to like his work after it started to evolve into something that was his own.

#145
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I'm such a huge fan of Sienkiewicz. Some of the stuff he draws is just mind-blowing.
I was super-stoked to meet him at Comic-con last year; it was one of the highlights of the trip. I commissioned this sketch from him:

One of my favorite Sienkiewicz covers (a little Kelley Jones, but still awesome):
I was super-stoked to meet him at Comic-con last year; it was one of the highlights of the trip. I commissioned this sketch from him:

One of my favorite Sienkiewicz covers (a little Kelley Jones, but still awesome):

Last edited by TheBang; 02-27-12 at 09:32 PM.
#146
#147
Suspended
re: Rob Liefeld (or Sal Buscema?!?!?!?!) - Worst comic book artist ever?
I can't believe people are ripping on Seinkewicz and Our Pal Sal -- two of the great artists of the last few decades.
I love Sal's run on Spectacular Spider-Man and I really love the work he did on Thor with Walt Simonson writing.
Check out Sal's 70s work on the Hulk or the Defenders for a more conventional artistic style.
I love Sal's run on Spectacular Spider-Man and I really love the work he did on Thor with Walt Simonson writing.
Check out Sal's 70s work on the Hulk or the Defenders for a more conventional artistic style.
#149