To correct myself, the price was $5.62. The secret is, the Insider Reward discount has started to apply to them. I was able to make two orders and include these titles. My first order was:

$0.00 - Casablanca (BD) - (after I cashed in my points at Insider rewards)
$5.62 - Batman (BD)
$5.62 - Batman Returns (BD)
$5.62 - Batman & Robin (BD)
$5.62 - Superman (BD)
$0.00 - Shipping - (after I cashed in my points for Casablanca)
----------------
$22.48 - Total

Then I got

$49.94 - Inception Blu-ray Combo Suitcase
$49.94 - Inception Blu-ray Combo Suitcase
$5.62 - Batman Forever
-$20 - SAVINGS (coupon)
$0.00 - Shipping - (after purchasing over $60)
----------------
$85.52 - Total

Note: On the Inception order my Batman Forever came to about $4.55 (because SAVINGS amounts to roughly 19% discount). I also used a 7% rebate on both for extra savings through fatwallet. The hurdle I had to overcome was that adding more than 4 of these $7.5 titles removed the Insider Reward. So I had to add other stuff to make sure the prices were maintained. Some coupons, especially the $5 off "welcome" coupon, affected the results, so be careful what you use.

One or more of the Batman BDs always seem to be out of stock. How accurate/efficient is their email notification for outof stock items?

wanted all 4 but just put in an order for batman and batman returns. 6.75 a piece was a steal

I got the $5 coupon sent to me for leaving the Legends of the Superheroes sitting in my cart while waiting for a sale code (none of the previous codes mentioned in this thread would work any longer). Got free shipping because the total was over $50, but still had to pay $2.50 for the separately shipping Warner Archive DVD-R one and then sales tax upped the total price. But why did Clash of the Titans only get 75¢ off the $7.50 price, costing $6.75 when all the others were $5.62?

I got an email for $5 off my cart items. With that and the 25% off insider discount I ordered Batman, Batman Returns, and Clash of the Titans for $18 after shipping and tax. That was a nice coupon to get on my birthday.

Hi I need help to make sure I'm not missing anything. All I have is a $5 off coupon they emailed me I guess the other promo's aren't working. I got all the batmans COT and Superman. I couldn't get free shipping with that so I got 2 other movies that are priced fair but I see people getting these for like under $6 so I must be missing some codes. What's the 25% insider discount as well. Thanks for your help

Sign up to http://insiderrewards.warnerbros.com. I'm not sure how to kick start the discount, but maybe find the link to the shop from the membership site. It's free. A free shipping code is FREESHIP. I think you have to purchase $30 minimum. Also, if your coupon for $5 off is the welcome coupon, don't use it! It'll remove all your other coupons and offers.

Well I have the free shipping and got the 10% off to work again but that's been it. It's weird it shows all the titles at 5.62 then I go to add to cart then they are 6.75. I'll probably order today or tomorrow so hopefully someone can help me figure out how to get the extra dollar off each one. Thanks again.

Anyone still waiting on their Batman BDs to ship?

I placed my order for Batman 1-4, Clash of the Titans, and Twister on 11/14 and they're still sitting as "In Process." I emailed support, so I'll see what they say.

I am. I only got Batman Forever, as per my previous post above. I'm also backordered on Doctor Who series 5 (BD), Sherlock (BD), and V (BD). These are starting to hit the one and two month mark, respectively.

I got all four of my Batdudes together a few weeks ago. It took perhaps a couple of weeks for them to get to me, but compared to Deep Disappointment, which had passed THREE MONTHS on my order, it was a blink of an eye.

First Best Deny, and now Deep Disappointment, huh? I dub this store Warner Backorder. I hope it catches on.

Well, at least I'm not waiting on movies I really want to see. They're just movies I want for my collection.

Yeah, same here. It was hard to pass up for $5.62, but anything more than that was easy.

I'm still waiting for my order too.

My $5.62 Twister bluray shipped. Now time to get rid of my DVD.

Yep, my Nov. 14 order that says it "will ship by 11/22/10" is still nowhere to been seen, despite the order (which I can't seem to bring up when I click on it) being listed as "shipped" in my order history.

I had forgotten I even ordered the 3 Batman movies, Superman and Clash of the Titans (still trying to find out when my two Nov. 24th orders will ship from them), so thanks for the reminder!

1 of 6 orders shipped today.

Superman Doomsday
Logan's Run

Not the order I hoped would ship first, but I'll take it.

Finally shipped. Got Batman, Batman Returns, Batman & Robin, Superman and a free Casablanca.

I just got shipping confirmation for my 11/14 order of Batman, Batman Returns, and Clash of the Titans. YAY!

My copy of Batman Returns finally shipped today!